Started By
Message

re: So you've just been given command of the Confederate army in late-June 1863....

Posted on 11/21/18 at 9:56 pm to
Posted by Darth_Vader
A galaxy far, far away
Member since Dec 2011
68864 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 9:56 pm to
quote:

Your forces are approaching Gettysburg, Pennsylvania when you get word that battle has been enjoined there. What do you do differently if history could afford you such a chance?


I send one, maybe two, more brigades on pickets charge, directly behind the initial assault force, and win the war.
Posted by LongueCarabine
Pointe Aux Pins, LA
Member since Jan 2011
8205 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 9:58 pm to
quote:

In other words, do what Longstreet wanted to do


This.
Posted by tigerpimpbot
Chairman of the Pool Board
Member since Nov 2011
68263 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 10:03 pm to
quote:

What do you do differently if history could afford you such a chance?

Probably panic.


This is what Robert E. Lee did.

quote:

I'm wildly unqualified.


Well then Mitch the bitch probably would have removed your statute too.

Posted by SamuelClemens
Earth
Member since Feb 2015
11727 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 10:08 pm to
Stand down, avoid the battle and negotiate reconciliation with the union. Basically to change the damage reconstruction caused.
Posted by BowlJackson
Birmingham, AL
Member since Sep 2013
52881 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 10:09 pm to
I would surrender the Confederate Army to face justice for treason
Posted by Biloxi Bacon
Member since Aug 2018
146 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 10:10 pm to
quote:

Turn head straight for DC


Could have done that after the first Bull Run.
Posted by BatonrougeCajun
Somewhere in Texas
Member since Feb 2008
6808 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 10:13 pm to
Why did we have to fight for 4 years and lose 600k Americans? You can’t tell me that this was inevitable. Lincoln wasn’t on the ballot in the southern states during the election of 1860. It was obvious that the southern states had no say in the direction the nation was going and the constitution protected their right to leave the union so again I ask the question; Why did we have to fight a civil war? There was no need for bloodshed
Posted by wareaglepete
Lumon Industries
Member since Dec 2012
14265 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 10:23 pm to
Do you think we have tilted more towards the ideas this country was founded on since the Civil War?
Posted by shinerfan
Duckworld(Earth-616)
Member since Sep 2009
25444 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 10:24 pm to
This is knowing what I know now about 20th century events?

I would immediately pull Lee back from his Northern operations, fortify my lines with a new thing I would call "barbed wire", and try to rush development of the gatling gun and the zeppelin. My new gunships would devastate Federal supply routes and disrupt northern manufacturing to some degree. I would try to create a panic at the thought of the firebombing of civilian population centers without actually following through with mass murder. I would offer a deal to the British Foreign Service that in return for lifting the Federal blockade of my ports I would credit the crown for convincing us to not only free the slaves but to show restraint in the use of my terrible new weapons.

After forcing the North to a grudging truce I would beg for aid and credit from Britain on whatever seemingly ruinous terms they required in order to prop up my shattered economy and help the freedman transition to yeoman farmers All while quietly investing every remaining dollar into speeding up the development and application of my oil reserves. The rise of the petrodollar would ease the strain of that foreign debt but not before I use the greed and villainy of European bankers as justification for my break with Queen Victoria and shift toward Constantinople. Confederate aid in developing Middle Eastern oilfields would deliver prosperous times to stave off the collapse of their broken society, in return for which I would ask them to crush Wahabbism in it's crib. (And possibly grab those Romanian oilfields as well.)

As we moved into the 20th century I would use my now staggering economic might to try and hold off the German war fever until the Bolsheviks emerged as the graver threat.

By the time the carnage of a redirected WWI settles my DixieTurk alliance will be firmly in control of the resources needed to enter the modern world.

Yeah, I get weird when I drink wine.
Posted by Wolfhound45
Member since Nov 2009
121138 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 10:29 pm to
quote:

Yeah, I get weird when I drink wine.
Just a wee bit
Posted by iglass
North Alabama
Member since Apr 2012
3034 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 10:32 pm to
quote:

RollTide1987
So you've just been given command of the Confederate army in late-June 1863....
Your forces are approaching Gettysburg, Pennsylvania when you get word that battle has been enjoined there. What do you do differently if history could afford you such a chance?


Make a right turn and go sack Washington DC.

And also order out Pizza Hut Delivery and have a few pizza pies delivered down to the boys at Vicksburg.
Posted by IceTiger
Really hot place
Member since Oct 2007
26584 posts
Posted on 11/21/18 at 10:38 pm to
quote:

shinerfan


He is glorious!
Posted by Tiger1242
Member since Jul 2011
32628 posts
Posted on 11/22/18 at 12:03 am to
quote:

Why did we have to fight for 4 years and lose 600k Americans? You can’t tell me that this was inevitable. Lincoln wasn’t on the ballot in the southern states during the election of 1860. It was obvious that the southern states had no say in the direction the nation was going and the constitution protected their right to leave the union so again I ask the question; Why did we have to fight a civil war? There was no need for bloodshed

Go study some history, not just military history, social and political history.

We can argue if the southern states had the constitutional right to secede if you want, although I think that’s a silly argument since by seceding they are choosing to ignore the constitution. Plus Andrew Jackson’s force act proved the federal gov could stop a state in direct opposition to a federal directive with force.

Anyway socially the country would not have accepted just letting the south leave. You can blame who you want but there was no chance the creation of the confederacy was not leading to a war one way or the other, and to argue otherwise is foolish
Posted by LongueCarabine
Pointe Aux Pins, LA
Member since Jan 2011
8205 posts
Posted on 11/22/18 at 6:40 am to
quote:

I would surrender the Confederate Army to face justice for treason


There's a moron in every discussion, and here he is.
Posted by dbeck
Member since Nov 2014
29454 posts
Posted on 11/22/18 at 6:47 am to
quote:

So you've just been given command of the Confederate army in late-June 1863
quote:

What do you do differently if history could afford you such a chance?

Posted by rantfan
new iberia la
Member since Nov 2012
14110 posts
Posted on 11/22/18 at 7:04 am to
Built a trojan horse, bring it to DC filled with chocolate pudding. They never would have known what to do.
Posted by kciDAtaE
Member since Apr 2017
16650 posts
Posted on 11/22/18 at 7:04 am to
Drop the bomb
Posted by elprez00
Hammond, LA
Member since Sep 2011
30643 posts
Posted on 11/22/18 at 7:19 am to
Take the high ground. People don’t realize how close the confederate army was to wiping the field with the Union army.

Jackson was sorely missed.
Posted by Wolfhound45
Member since Nov 2009
121138 posts
Posted on 11/22/18 at 7:22 am to
quote:

Jackson was sorely missed.
If Jackson was alive he would have taken Culp’s Hill on the first day.
Posted by udtiger
Over your left shoulder
Member since Nov 2006
107638 posts
Posted on 11/22/18 at 7:47 am to
Double time it so I can take the high ground with half my forces for the Union forces arrive, flank to the north with the other half to try to get behind oncoming forces and surround them as they come in.
first pageprev pagePage 3 of 5Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram