- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Posted on 6/16/23 at 7:11 pm to WhereisAtlanta
quote:
think Vietnam we could have won but chose to leave with our tail between our legs for political reasons
Respectfully, doesn’t sound like you’re very educated on the Vietnam War. The “political” reason for withdrawing was that it wasn’t a winnable war. Which our leaders knew years before we finally left.
Posted on 6/16/23 at 7:54 pm to Chromdome35
Thank you as well, I always find your posts to be of top quality, and echo your comments regarding the others.
While the thread does run off the rails at times and we can be guilty of indulging the trolls (myself included despite trying to ignore them by and large) there is plenty of good information and discussion exchanged.
Plus I would be lying if I said I didn't enjoy parsing through information to try and find out what is accurate and what is not regardless of the source. About 12 months ago we found out more about my grandfather's service history in WWII which had been under moratorium and the details of what he did got me into information use and misuse.
Edit: Clarity
While the thread does run off the rails at times and we can be guilty of indulging the trolls (myself included despite trying to ignore them by and large) there is plenty of good information and discussion exchanged.
Plus I would be lying if I said I didn't enjoy parsing through information to try and find out what is accurate and what is not regardless of the source. About 12 months ago we found out more about my grandfather's service history in WWII which had been under moratorium and the details of what he did got me into information use and misuse.
Edit: Clarity
This post was edited on 6/16/23 at 7:58 pm
Posted on 6/16/23 at 8:24 pm to OutsideObserver
What did he do in WW2?
Posted on 6/16/23 at 8:27 pm to El Mattadorr
quote:
Respectfully, doesn’t sound like you’re very educated on the Vietnam War.
Oh the irony.
quote:
The “political” reason for withdrawing was that it wasn’t a winnable war. Which our leaders knew years before we finally left.
The Paris Peace Accords says hello.
I’m betting you think the Tet Offensive was the “turning point” where after that the war was “unwinnable” for the US.
Posted on 6/16/23 at 8:35 pm to OutsideObserver
They are still probing. Anyone on here know how long the probing attacks are likely to go on before they launch the real offensive attack?
Posted on 6/16/23 at 8:53 pm to TutHillTiger
quote:
Anyone on here know how long the probing attacks are likely to go on before they launch the real offensive attack?
No one knows. It’s about softening up and making an opening.
Posted on 6/16/23 at 8:59 pm to TutHillTiger
quote:
Anyone on here know how long the probing attacks are likely to go on before they launch the real offensive attack?
Until they find the right spot(s). They have to find the weakest point(s) that will still allow them to pursue their goals and they have to keep an eye on the Russian reaction to each of their moves. They have to find a weak enough spot in the defense to effect a quick breakthrough AND have Russia off balance/out of position when they make the breakthrough. Somewhere there is a football OC analog sitting in a booth watching the game calling plays now to set up that special series plays when the conditions are set and the defense is on its heels.
Posted on 6/16/23 at 9:27 pm to Chromdome35
quote:
What did he do in WW2?
He was posted to the Australian Special Wireless Group (ASWG) and was deployed in both Darwin and New Guinea. They played a large role in monitoring both internal and external communications in the Pacific.
Edit: Clarity
This post was edited on 6/16/23 at 9:30 pm
Posted on 6/16/23 at 9:44 pm to OutsideObserver
If you create total BS and pretend that you have secret sources, you can get a lot of clicks and retweets on the bird site.

Posted on 6/16/23 at 9:44 pm to OutsideObserver
double post
This post was edited on 6/16/23 at 9:45 pm
Posted on 6/16/23 at 10:11 pm to OutsideObserver
My wife's grandfather was a Captain in the Marines and served looking at aerial recon photos. I don't think that he got closer to the action than Ulithi or similar. She has a photo somewhere of him with a big wide grin and grass skirt bare chested native women on either side.
An uncle served in New Guinea and elsewhere in the Army as a his unit's machine gunner. He had lots of souvenirs including a several foot long string of Japanese gold teeth. The only thing that pissed him off about WWII was that black soldiers told Aussie women that they were American Indians, so they could get a piece. Nice improvising I think.
An uncle served in New Guinea and elsewhere in the Army as a his unit's machine gunner. He had lots of souvenirs including a several foot long string of Japanese gold teeth. The only thing that pissed him off about WWII was that black soldiers told Aussie women that they were American Indians, so they could get a piece. Nice improvising I think.
Posted on 6/16/23 at 10:38 pm to Darth_Vader
quote:
I’m betting you think the Tet Offensive was the “turning point” where after that the war was “unwinnable” for the US.
McNamara knew the war was unwinnable as early as ‘65. Three years before the Tet Offensive.
Posted on 6/16/23 at 10:44 pm to Chromdome35
quote:
There are lots of good posters in the thread who contribute quality stuff (Gop, Stormy, DoubleD, Obtuse, CitzenK, Cypher, Darth Vader, LSUPilot, and a bunch of others I cant think of off the top of my head) Thanks Everyone
I agree and thank each of you for the constant updates. I read this thread every night before bed. I have nothing to contribute but appreciate those of you that do.
Posted on 6/17/23 at 1:48 am to CitizenK
quote:
My wife's grandfather was a Captain in the Marines and served looking at aerial recon photos. I don't think that he got closer to the action than Ulithi or similar. She has a photo somewhere of him with a big wide grin and grass skirt bare chested native women on either side.
An uncle served in New Guinea and elsewhere in the Army as a his unit's machine gunner. He had lots of souvenirs including a several foot long string of Japanese gold teeth. The only thing that pissed him off about WWII was that black soldiers told Aussie women that they were American Indians, so they could get a piece. Nice improvising I think.
Sounds like a couple of interesting stories or three there!
My pop never talked about his service beyond that he was "up north" as they were sworn to secrecy on what they did and he took that seriously even up until his passing a few years ago. Not sure how close he got to actual combat, as a Signalman he would unlikely have been close to the front, though he was sent to hospital for injuries to his elbow and shoulder on separate occasions while up in New Guinea but we only have his enlistment transcript which is pretty vague on details.
He used to pop out proverbs such as "not to sit with your back to any doors" and "loose lips sink ships" so all the kids and grandkids fantasied that he was a spy or something when younger, which turned out to be not so far from the truth, though not in quite the way we imagined.
Posted on 6/17/23 at 1:58 am to OutsideObserver
My uncles were pilots, one a B-52 pilot who was shot down on his last mission and spent last year of war in a POW camp, but all his crew survived the war, the other was fighter pilot who volunteered with the RAF for Battle of Britain and he crashed or was shot down several times but never captured. Shot down a bunch of Germans but only had 4 confirmed kills.
My great grandfather was was a captain in the merchant marines, that’s all I know. My grandfather was a marine sgt and fought in d-day etc. I was little when he died and that’s all I know about his service. He did have several Lugers.
My great grandfather was was a captain in the merchant marines, that’s all I know. My grandfather was a marine sgt and fought in d-day etc. I was little when he died and that’s all I know about his service. He did have several Lugers.
Posted on 6/17/23 at 3:44 am to TutHillTiger
British Defence Intelligence
INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
UPDATE ON UKRAINE 17 June 2023
Since the start of Ukrainian counter-offensive operations in southern Ukraine, Russia has re-enforced its attack helicopter force in the region.
Imagery shows that over 20 extra Russian helicopters deployed to Berdyansk Airport, approximately 100km behind the front line.
In the constant contest between aviation measures and counter-measures, it is likely that Russia has gained a temporary advantage in southern Ukraine, especially with attack helicopters employing longer-range missiles against ground targets.
INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
UPDATE ON UKRAINE 17 June 2023
Since the start of Ukrainian counter-offensive operations in southern Ukraine, Russia has re-enforced its attack helicopter force in the region.
Imagery shows that over 20 extra Russian helicopters deployed to Berdyansk Airport, approximately 100km behind the front line.
In the constant contest between aviation measures and counter-measures, it is likely that Russia has gained a temporary advantage in southern Ukraine, especially with attack helicopters employing longer-range missiles against ground targets.
Posted on 6/17/23 at 6:06 am to TutHillTiger
Another uncle was a P-38 then P-51 pilot in Europe. His squadron rolled with the front and attacked convoys of German troops and supplies. Early 80's he had put together a business deal which was funded by a German steel company, Klockner, he had to travel to Germany to meet with them. When asked if he had ever been to Germany, he replied that he only flew over it several times but never landed.
Dad enlisted in the Navy after Germany invaded Poland. He figured that there would be a war with us in it and didn't want to walk. His ship sank German subs before we were in the war. At the end of the war, he was involved in decommissioning a USN weather base at Petropavlosk (Kamchatka Peninsula) Russia. The Russian political officer kept bragging how they would take the US from within by using the far left and far right causing doubt among the public. Thus, he hated the Birchers as much as he hated the Hippies.
Two uncles were married with children so were drafted and sent to the Panama Canal Zone. An aunt went to Cincinnati to work in a war production plant. Mom was given a T(eaching) certificate after 3 years in college due lack of teachers. She took a job in Hackberry, LA only accessible by boat back then. Marsh ranchers made bank selling beef to the government plus oil had been discovered by then. They profited greatly from the war effort.
Dad enlisted in the Navy after Germany invaded Poland. He figured that there would be a war with us in it and didn't want to walk. His ship sank German subs before we were in the war. At the end of the war, he was involved in decommissioning a USN weather base at Petropavlosk (Kamchatka Peninsula) Russia. The Russian political officer kept bragging how they would take the US from within by using the far left and far right causing doubt among the public. Thus, he hated the Birchers as much as he hated the Hippies.
Two uncles were married with children so were drafted and sent to the Panama Canal Zone. An aunt went to Cincinnati to work in a war production plant. Mom was given a T(eaching) certificate after 3 years in college due lack of teachers. She took a job in Hackberry, LA only accessible by boat back then. Marsh ranchers made bank selling beef to the government plus oil had been discovered by then. They profited greatly from the war effort.
This post was edited on 6/17/23 at 6:15 am
Posted on 6/17/23 at 7:59 am to CitizenK
Some interesting bits from a story today in The Guardian:

Doshch, Shved, Son and Spielberg from the special drone unit of the 1st brigade near the frontline in eastern Ukraine. Photograph: Emre Çaylak/The Guardian
quote:
Gennadiy may be wounded in hospital, but he has still found a way to participate in Ukraine’s long-awaited counteroffensive. Sitting on a crowded ward at a medical facility in Dnipro, the commander unexpectedly pulls out his mobile to reveal live footage of green fields and tree lines in a newly contested part of the front.
Although he was hurt in an artillery strike overnight between 2 and 3 June, as Ukraine’s attacks on the southern Zaporizhzhia front stepped up, Gennadiy, 51, says that when required he watches the phone screen to help soldiers on the ground. “I’m still working, still correcting artillery fire,” he says. “This is not just so I can watch.”

quote:
Gennadiy (Ukraine’s military allows only first names or call signs to be used) and other soldiers the Guardian spoke to paint a slightly different picture of a gradual buildup. “A month ago we started to increase the intensity of our attacks,” he says, describing operations where he was based with the 114th brigade around Novodarivka, a village on the southern front declared liberated by Ukraine on 4 June.
Progress has been measured, acknowledges the wounded veteran, saying it took 10 days for Ukrainian soldiers to capture Russian trenches in the next tree line. “Why did it take so long to take that one position? We wanted to minimise our losses,” he says, showing me the location in question by switching to the Deep State mapping app, used to track developments in the frontline.
His comments may help explain some of the wider reality. Over the past fortnight, Ukrainian units and leaders have announced the capture of a handful of largely deserted villages, with the gains amounting to four miles (6.5km) at the furthest point, south of Velyka Novosilka. The open fields of Novodarivka are nearby, about eight to 10 miles (13 to 16km) to the west, while a small bulge of Russian forces is positioned in between.
quote:
The hospital in Dnipro is one of many places deep behind the lines where the wounded, once stabilised, come for further surgery if needed and rehabilitation. Like in many Ukrainian hospitals, conditions are cramped at the best of times, but local sources say the facility has been filling up with wounded soldiers over the past fortnight as the counteroffensive has begun.
quote:
From a distance, the war in Ukraine can easily be portrayed as a battle that will hinge on the provision and use of western tanks, rockets and other equipment. But on the front, as significant are other locally developed weapons – most notably the new $400 (£312) or $500 drones being used not for surveillance but in attack.
Four drone operators, led by Shved, whose call sign means “the Swede” on account of his blond hair, promise to take the Guardian to a base five miles (8km) from the Zaporizhzhia front, though at the last minute it is decided the trip is too dangerous because Russian reconnaissance drones were spotted over their dugouts. Instead, he meets the Guardian in a nearby village, a similar distance from the zero line, with outgoing artillery audible in the distance.
The squad are from Ukraine’s 1st brigade, a mechanised force using Czech-modernised, Soviet-standard T-64 tanks, and the drone operators’ job, in part, will be to act in tandem with the armour “as their eyes” when they are deployed to attack.
But the surprise, given the importance attached to drones by Ukraine’s military, is that the soldiers themselves have to fund the effort because the army cannot afford them.
Doshch, Shved, Son and Spielberg from the special drone unit of the 1st brigade near the frontline in eastern Ukraine. Photograph: Emre Çaylak/The Guardian quote:
“We pay up to 70% of our salaries to buy drones,” said Shved, particularly citing the new “first-person view” attack drones.
“That’s why you use these drones like a bomber, not kamikaze, because you don’t have the money to keep replacing them,” said another crew member, Spielberg, so nicknamed when the other soldiers learned he had video-editing skills.
Later at a drone command point about 30 miles (48km) away from the frontline, the squad demonstrate a modified fast-flying $400 Ukrainian-made Aquila, piloted with a controller and goggles. Some of the extra parts, such as the bomb release, are made using a 3D printer, the ink for which was also paid for by the troops themselves. The Aquila can carry one or two grenades and flies at 100kph (62mph) to evade the enemy. The soldiers say it can fly about 3km (1.9 miles) into Russian-held territory and believe it could be a cost-effective alternative to often inaccurate artillery fire.
Drones like this will be a critical part of the fight to come – and here there is nothing the west can teach the Ukrainians, because such drones represent an innovation. “It’s 21st-century warfare,” says another team member, Doshch. And although some of the overwatch can be conducted remotely in bunkers, most of the drone teams (typically four-strong, they say) have to work about 1km behind the front.
quote:
It is their job to be optimistic, given what is at stake. But they also know they are in danger. “We are drone operators, we are target number one, high priority for the Russians. So as soon as we are detected, they will shoot everything into our location,” says Shved, arguing near-misses are not uncommon.
“I have no doubt we will defeat them,” adds Spielberg, “but I don’t know if I can survive until that time.”
Popular
Back to top




1





