re: Dune Part 1 vs Dune Part 2

quote:

---

Part one was close to perfect.

---

Agreed.

quote:

---

Part two pissed me off with turning Stilgar into a bumbling zealot bellowing "Lisan al Gaib!!" every time Paul did anything. And how they turned Chani into a jaded independent woman who don't need no man and pays her bills. I didn't enjoy it anywhere near as much as part 1.

They completely missed the point of Stilgar and Chani's devotion to Muad'dib as it was portrayed in the books.

---

all of this.


Rewatched part 2 because of this thread last night. It also makes me irrationally mad that Stilgar is fat. Fierce warriors on a desert planet with limited resources aren't going to be fat.