re: Fun topic. Which NFL qb do you want in a one game scenario all time?

Posted by msudawg1200

Central Mississippi

Member since Jun 2014

9418 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 3:41 pm to Ponchy Tiger

quote:
Montana and it isn't close.

This. I want a damn winner. I don't want a statwhore(Rogers).

Posted by chalmetteowl

Chalmette

Member since Jan 2008

47616 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 3:47 pm to Tvilletiger

whose defense do I have and who's my RB and top WR?

Posted by Scoob

Near Exxon

Member since Jun 2009

20405 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 3:59 pm to JodyPlauche

quote:
quote:
Marino.

He beat the 85 Bears.

Steve Fuller started at QB that game because Jim McMahon was hurt.

When McMahon was finally put in the game, McMahon ran the ball to get Walter Payton his record for most consecutive 100 yard games.

I...along with most Bear fans were passed the Bears had to play New England because we wanted revenge.

As for those who pick Joe Montana...healthy Jim McMahon was 4-1 against Joe Montana.

And we know Montana played on the better team because he has 4 Superbowl rings to McMahon's 2

Not getting into a pissing contest here.

I picked Marino, because the context was "win one game". The 85 Bears had the most obscene defense I've ever seen, they chewed teams up and spit them out. Jim McMahon was nice, but that team wins the Super Bowl regardless of who plays QB.

If the question was "what defense do you take to win one game", I take the 85 Bears D.
And Marino beat them.

Posted by Hurricane Mike

Member since Jun 2008

20059 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 4:14 pm to Tvilletiger

quote:
Fun topic

Negative

Posted by TheeRealCarolina

Member since Aug 2018

17925 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 4:22 pm to Tvilletiger

Rodgers, Young, Marino, Montana, and Manning have to be the top 5 in some order.

Posted by go ta hell ole miss

Member since Jan 2007

13626 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 4:34 pm to lake2280

quote:
Yep Elway easy for me.

He lost 60% of his Super Bowls. That’s your easy choice? I’d take Brady or Montana, but even those would not be an easy choice.

This post was edited on 1/3/22 at 4:41 pm

Posted by High C

viewing the fall....

Member since Nov 2012

53805 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 4:48 pm to Tvilletiger

I came in to say Montana, expecting Brady to be running away with it. Only read the first page, but I’m pleasantly surprised.

Posted by Tvilletiger

PVB

Member since Oct 2015

4892 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 5:38 pm to High C

I am happy with all the Montana love in this thread also. Surprised me.

Posted by mizzoubuckeyeiowa

Member since Nov 2015

35512 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 6:00 pm to Tvilletiger

Well Montana was 4-0 in Super Bowls and has the highest passer rating in Super Bowls...

So if that ONE game was a BIG game, then yeah...Montana...his stats actually IMPROVED in the playoffs and Super Bowl over the regular season while Manning's declined dramatically in the playoffs and Super Bowl.

Posted by biglego

Ask your mom where I been

Member since Nov 2007

76324 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 6:01 pm to Tvilletiger

BIG DICK JOE

Posted by Madking

Member since Apr 2016

47879 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 6:08 pm to Tvilletiger

Montana, nobody was better in Super Bowls and the defining moments of those games. His performance in the 1990 Super Bowl is still the gold standard for perfection when it comes to QB play.

This post was edited on 1/3/22 at 6:09 pm

Posted by dirtsandwich

Member since May 2016

5161 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 6:12 pm to Tvilletiger

Posted by PublixSubs

Maine

Member since Sep 2015

901 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 6:37 pm to Tvilletiger

I get it’s not really the right answer, but everyone worthy has already been mentioned.

Manning, Eli.

It’s one game, so presuming we’re talking about the Super Bowl, he’s undefeated.

I don’t care that some guy caught the ball on his helmet, Eli still got out of that sack. And they beat one of the greatest (and up to that point undefeated) teams.

He’s 2-0 vs Brady in the Super Bowl. Good enough for me.

Posted by ThanosIsADemocrat

The Garden

Member since May 2018

9395 posts

Posted on 1/3/22 at 6:51 pm to Tvilletiger

Elway