- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Score Board
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- SEC Score Board
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
| Favorite team: | LSU |
| Location: | Near Exxon |
| Biography: | |
| Interests: | all things LSU |
| Occupation: | |
| Number of Posts: | 24653 |
| Registered on: | 6/24/2009 |
| Online Status: | Not Online |
Recent Posts
Message
re: Building Championship Roster
Posted by Scoob on 11/22/26 at 1:06 am to Surv1vor1st
quote:
Plus it would have helped to get some more playing time to the younger WRs. Someone like Jabari Mack, who seems to make plays in spring practice, wants to be at LSU but doesn't see the field. Then he transfers next year
Why transfer? Serious question...
Harris has done enough to enter the draft and go high.
Watkins has been a disappointment with his drops, and skipped this game.
Seems to me we have 2 starting spots open going into next year. If he's good enough to compete at a P4 school for playing time, staying at LSU where he has a year in the system actually looks like a good move for him. If he's not good enough, then that doesn't help our roster going forward.
If he steps down a level to play, he likely wasn't ready to make an impact here.
re: Building Championship Roster
Posted by Scoob on 11/22/26 at 12:32 am to BastropRam13
quote:I think... that's overthinking a bit.
Kiffin’s ability to recruit, retain, and develop is really unknown at this time.
Lane Kiffin is over 50 yrs old, he's been around college football for decades. He's fully aware of the concept of recruiting and developing players, he was doing that his whole career.
Retention- well, that depends on what he can offer the player. Path to a starting role, draft prospects for starters? They stay. They move on if that's specifically better elsewhere. Now, money is also a factor.
So, today's world: LSU is fine for that. We're not going to get raided, Indiana or Texas Tech (for example) isn't going to pull a Deuce Geralds or DJ Pickett from us if they're starting here. We are going to pay enough, and they won't need to "upgrade" to move up the draft board.
We may lose a Harlem Berry, but that's because he doesn't want to sit behind Dilin Jones, and thinks he can find a school/system where he can be the man. But Berry will face the same issue he did here- he's not a big, durable everydown back, he's not a physical presence. And most of the big P4 schools want that instead of a potentially explosive, small scatback.
Recruiting at LSU, that comes down to scouting and making the necessary inroads. We should have enough 'shadow staff' to do that, keep the contacts happy. Developing- he's done that everywhere he's been. There's little/no difference between someone out of the portal, and someone out of high school (that's where they all come from). The portal is just a place to cherry-pick someone you may have wanted but initially missed, and now he's stuck somewhere and you can offer him something better. I don't think Dilin Jones comes here if he's the starter at Wisconsin (maybe he does, it looks like their leading rusher has 370 yds this year, and had 363 last year. WTF, Wisky???)
Answer: no.
Every game we have played, we have either blown the doors off our opponent, or we have lost. If the game is close in the second half, they beat us.
Even in the blowout wins, Clemson, La Tech, and Auburn score TDs in the 4th quarter. We started putting backups early in the 2nd half vs McNeese and they scored 14. We discounted that early in the season, but I think it shows we lack the necessary depth to finish out the game.
Ole Miss, Bama, Texas and Tennessee all outscored us in the 4th quarter.
Simply put, unless we get up 3+ scores, we're not going to hold on vs anybody that's any good. A good team just has to stay in the game, and then they beat us late. All this talk about the defense being gassed, that just means we don't have enough to rotate people in and out.
Every game we have played, we have either blown the doors off our opponent, or we have lost. If the game is close in the second half, they beat us.
Even in the blowout wins, Clemson, La Tech, and Auburn score TDs in the 4th quarter. We started putting backups early in the 2nd half vs McNeese and they scored 14. We discounted that early in the season, but I think it shows we lack the necessary depth to finish out the game.
Ole Miss, Bama, Texas and Tennessee all outscored us in the 4th quarter.
Simply put, unless we get up 3+ scores, we're not going to hold on vs anybody that's any good. A good team just has to stay in the game, and then they beat us late. All this talk about the defense being gassed, that just means we don't have enough to rotate people in and out.
quote:
So you spread it around. Your top 2 guys Harris (very good) and Watkins (pretty bad for LSU standards #2 WR) aren’t even close to what I’m used to at LSU, and yet when they go down, your next level is not really at a level to compete.
To be fair, Harris is better than anyone we had for Nuss to throw to. If Watkins could catch, he'd also be better.
But I think we need to get out of the portal for WRs. Need to get back into winning the La recruiting battles, getting those guys in, and keeping them.
Our last elite WRs were Nabers and Thomas Jr, who were recruits. I also think Pickett is going to be a better corner than Delane, and I wish we'd get more safeties in too. And linebackers too. Need to grab classic La "athletes" and build them up the way we used to.
Which really isn't that far-fetched. UGA is still taking Georgia talent and developing them. They just didn't have to deal with 2 coaching changes and the roster depletions that happen with that. If Kiffin hangs around awhile, I hope we can get back to where we were before.
If we become totally portal dependent, then there's no advantage for LSU outside of donor money (and we can't expect to outbid everyone every year). There are nicer cities to live in, there are teams with more recent titles, there are teams with easier schedules, and richer donors.
re: 5+ loses in first season
Posted by Scoob on 11/21/26 at 10:55 pm to Sulphatig22
quote:I must have missed that happening.
Somehow other first year coaches win natties and do good.
Care to list them?
re: Honest opinion: is Leavitt back next year
Posted by Scoob on 11/21/26 at 10:47 pm to Adam Banks
I think so
re: Building Championship Roster
Posted by Scoob on 11/21/26 at 10:47 pm to BastropRam13
quote:Hmmm
So you think Kiffin has a history of building thru recruiting and not just the portal?
Do I think Kiffin has a history of building through recruiting...?
No, not at Ole Miss. As I understand it, that's why he chose to leave there.
He came here late in the recruiting cycle and we still managed to do pretty good, we expect better going forward. But- breaking news- a top ranked recruiting class isn't going to win year 1. It's going to take time, and it's going to take retention.
So in the meantime, we probably need to recruit some guys to return next year.
Everyone hates Leavitt. Quick look at his numbers: 3019 yds, 20 TD, 12 int, 71% completion, rush for 328 and 8 TD. Probably adds to that vs Arkansas.
Not sure we find "better" in the portal, just saying...
Dilin Jones: 888 yds, 8 TD rushing, 44 receptions for 275 yds. I expect we push him over 1k and 10 TD next week.
He's already said he's coming back, it would be huge to return him.
We need to get some WRs back, and have someone develop from within. Really can't expect to pull another Jackson Harris in the portal.
quote:Damn, you're on to something there.
Didn't take him 11 years to win a natty. Didn't take 11 years to go back to back. How many years has Lane been a head coach ?
Lane should have won titles at Florida Atlantic and Ole Miss!
Seriously dude, quit melting, go hug the wife and kids/grandkids, pet the dog and take a breather.
Kiffin was at Tennessee 1 season, 7-6.
USC 3+ years; 8-5, 10-2, 7-6, 3-2 and fired. They had heavy NCAA sanctions.
FAU 3 years, 11-3, 5-7, 10-3.
Ole Miss 6 years. He won 5, 10, 8, 11, 10, 11. Repeat: at OLE MISS.
He's going to be fine here. This is a step up from everywhere he's been, especially when you consider USC had the NCAA up their arse (and he still went 10-2 there once).
re: Building Championship Roster
Posted by Scoob on 11/21/26 at 10:07 pm to BastropRam13
Supposedly he came to LSU for the recruiting bump. If he was just into portal pickups, he could have stayed at Ole Miss.
This big portal class was to make the team competitive in his first season. Whether it was "good enough" or not is irrelevant; 9 of the 11 offensive starters are from the portal. 6 starters on defense (and we are also starting a freshman). That means we have 2 starters on offense, 4 on defense, that were on the team last year.
Special teams is more of the same. Kicker came this year, punter came last year. Return guys, we have Harlem Berry and a portal guy.
That won't win. We lost any game that was close. You can't build that way, you can't reload and face teams that have built up and expect to win out. You can add pieces, but you need something to build on.
This big portal class was to make the team competitive in his first season. Whether it was "good enough" or not is irrelevant; 9 of the 11 offensive starters are from the portal. 6 starters on defense (and we are also starting a freshman). That means we have 2 starters on offense, 4 on defense, that were on the team last year.
Special teams is more of the same. Kicker came this year, punter came last year. Return guys, we have Harlem Berry and a portal guy.
That won't win. We lost any game that was close. You can't build that way, you can't reload and face teams that have built up and expect to win out. You can add pieces, but you need something to build on.
quote:Let's just wait and see what happens before we start talking shite, ok?
and baseball.
Like, can we at least get to 10 conference wins in baseball before we decide to brag?
quote:There's nothing to accept. If you don't accept it, our record doesn't change.
A few on here accept that but I don't.
It is what it is. We might be top 10 in stats, but we absolutely don't have a Top 10 offense or defense. We have a bunch of blowouts, and a lot of close loses.
Offense- we can move the ball ok, we rarely go 3 and out. We can drive from the 25 to midfield or opposing 40's, and still often come away with nothing. Those are empty yards.
Defense- make excuses all you want, but this defense has failed to stop any opponent in a competitive game when it matters. This is not a top defense.
re: 40% of Tennessee offensive yardage was in 4th
Posted by Scoob on 11/21/26 at 8:41 pm to FlyingTiger06
Our defense gets gassed by being on the field multiple drives, but Tennessee's stays strong, even gets stouter. Same for Texas.
bullshite. Baker plays a very aggressive defense, if everyone is clean you get a lot of stops for negative yardage. But if someone is off, you can get burned. We've seen this for a couple years now, it's nothing new. Has little to do with losing Weeks, things would happen when he was out there too.
The issue with the defense is that Baker can't seem to dial it back "just a little", it's heavy pressure or soft prevent.
There are absolutely issues on the offense and special teams too. Like someone else said, it's at all levels, not just one. But the late game defense shouldn't get more of a pass than the OL, Leavitt's errors, or the absolute trash we put out on special teams. Yet again, this game was tied in the 4th and we had some momentum, and they snapped off 2 straight TD drives to finish it off.
bullshite. Baker plays a very aggressive defense, if everyone is clean you get a lot of stops for negative yardage. But if someone is off, you can get burned. We've seen this for a couple years now, it's nothing new. Has little to do with losing Weeks, things would happen when he was out there too.
The issue with the defense is that Baker can't seem to dial it back "just a little", it's heavy pressure or soft prevent.
There are absolutely issues on the offense and special teams too. Like someone else said, it's at all levels, not just one. But the late game defense shouldn't get more of a pass than the OL, Leavitt's errors, or the absolute trash we put out on special teams. Yet again, this game was tied in the 4th and we had some momentum, and they snapped off 2 straight TD drives to finish it off.
We need to bite the bullet and start developing guys again. Portal is a quick fix, but you overpay for it; Seaton, Princewell, Harris and Benefield were worth it. The rest, mostly just average guys.
I think Trey'Dez gets paid, but won't be a factor in the NFL. People get too excited because he's tall, but that didn't seem to help him, and actually seemed to make him more vulnerable to leg injuries.
I think Trey'Dez gets paid, but won't be a factor in the NFL. People get too excited because he's tall, but that didn't seem to help him, and actually seemed to make him more vulnerable to leg injuries.
re: 40% of Tennessee offensive yardage was in 4th
Posted by Scoob on 11/21/26 at 6:47 pm to Nomadic Bengal
quote:
Almost like the defense being on the field the whole time is an issue
Funny thing-
We had the ball 30:29. We won time of possession.
re: I don't care who is playing. There should be no tolerance for that shite.
Posted by Scoob on 11/21/26 at 6:36 pm to Deadmanshand
I hope Rousse and Murrill call Sankey out publicly on that.
We were trying to gain a competitive advantage, maybe pushing the boundaries but it's not like other teams haven't pushed them also.
This arse clown called for fans to bring things to throw for this game, and they did.
Which is the more egregious action?
We were trying to gain a competitive advantage, maybe pushing the boundaries but it's not like other teams haven't pushed them also.
This arse clown called for fans to bring things to throw for this game, and they did.
Which is the more egregious action?
There's the clutch late game D we know and love
re: LSU at Tennessee
Posted by Scoob on 11/21/26 at 6:09 pm to moock blackjack
Incomplete
At least return it
re: LSU at Tennessee
Posted by Scoob on 11/21/26 at 5:57 pm to moock blackjack
And there's the TD dagger
Hmm flag???
Hmm flag???
Y'know,
When they brought that qb in late, I would have slowly swapped someone out. Slowly
When they brought that qb in late, I would have slowly swapped someone out. Slowly
Popular
0












