Started By
Message

How do you properly thicken a gumbo?

Posted on 9/26/21 at 7:22 am
Posted by Webbbster
Member since Oct 2013
211 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 7:22 am
Went to Commanders Palace on Friday. Their gumbo was rich, thick and amazing.

Mine has good flavor but very watery. Essentially the consistency of chicken stock (which is what it is). How can I thicken to more of a gravy-like consistency?

PS - I don’t want okra.
Posted by Bigryno7
Nashville
Member since Jun 2009
1492 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 7:35 am to
Use more roux
Posted by TigerMan327
Elsewhere
Member since Feb 2011
5796 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 7:50 am to
Flour
Posted by Webbbster
Member since Oct 2013
211 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 7:51 am to
Should I increase the ratio of flour to oil at the beginning? I usually do 1 cup of each to start.
Posted by Webbbster
Member since Oct 2013
211 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 7:52 am to
How much oil and flour do you use at the beginning?
Posted by OTIS2
NoLA
Member since Jul 2008
51405 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 7:53 am to
1/1 is fine. Just increase the amount of roux you’re using.
Posted by Lambdatiger1989
NOLA
Member since Jan 2012
2389 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 7:53 am to
My roux make up is 3 cups flour to 1lb butter. This makes enough roux to thicken 5 quarts of stock.
Posted by jamboybarry
Member since Feb 2011
33038 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 8:28 am to
You need a thicker roux, more roux or both

I do 1.5 flour to oil and get a more stew like gumbo liquid which is what I like
Posted by jamiegla1
Member since Aug 2016
7547 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 8:54 am to
roux and use chicken or turkey stock made with the same meat youre going to put in it
Posted by butters stotch
Southpark, CO
Member since Sep 2008
27 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 8:56 am to
In addition to quantity of roux, I find most home cooks use boxed stock. A gelatinous home made stock, like most decent restaurants use, is the true difference in texture.
Posted by Bigryno7
Nashville
Member since Jun 2009
1492 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 8:59 am to
I would second this. My smoked Turkey stock in gumbo is really rich and gravy like. I basically go into a coma after eating. So delicious.
Posted by SixthAndBarone
Member since Jan 2019
9850 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 8:59 am to
Yep, thicker roux and that means more flour.
Posted by Stadium Rat
Metairie
Member since Jul 2004
9863 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 10:00 am to
Figure out your stock to roux ratio and adjust accordingly. Recipes I've surveyed range from 20 to 1 all the way down to 7 to 1.

Your oil to flour ratio doesn't need to change from what you like.

As most cooks on here know, the darker the roux, the less thickening power it has.
This post was edited on 9/26/21 at 10:05 am
Posted by gumbo2176
Member since May 2018
17867 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 10:51 am to
You can also mix a few tablespoons of Corn Starch with a little bit of water and add it to the gumbo and that will thicken it up pretty easily.

Go a little at first and let it simmer a bit to see how much it thickens the gumbo. If not thick enough, do a little more until you get the consistency you want.

It will not change the flavor of the gumbo, just the gravy thickness.
Posted by 91TIGER
Lafayette
Member since Aug 2006
18836 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 11:40 am to
quote:

gelatinous home made stock


Some just use gelatin to thicken it.
Posted by cgrand
HAMMOND
Member since Oct 2009
43086 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 11:53 am to
easy answer is to use less liquid to begin with.
I like a dark roux and a thinner than gravy consistency. Nothing worse than a pasty gumbo which is a common result when using more flour in the roux
Posted by butters stotch
Southpark, CO
Member since Sep 2008
27 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 12:02 pm to
Absolutely. Gelatin is derived from collagen, and while it provides no depth of flavor like a long simmered stock, it is a great cheat to get desired consistency.
I would definitely use gelatin before I would use a corn starch slurry, or mess with my flour to oil ratio in the roux.
Posted by mouton
Savannah,Ga
Member since Aug 2006
28276 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 12:07 pm to
To each his own but I don’t understand this boards obsession with thick gumbos. Growing up in Lake Charles and Lafayette areas most families made thinner gumbos that what you normally see in restaurants in Baton Rouge and New Orleans. I remember reading a quote by Paul Prudhomme saying the best gumbos were of the thinner variety. My chicken and sausage gumbo is of the same consistency as Chris’s Poboys in Lafayette for those who have had it.
Posted by geauxpurple
New Orleans
Member since Jul 2014
14734 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 12:21 pm to
If you don’t want okra then the other answer is a thick roux.
Posted by WigSplitta22
The Bottom
Member since Apr 2014
2036 posts
Posted on 9/26/21 at 12:25 pm to
If you don’t want the floury taste use Xanthan gum. A little goes a long way. It comes in a powder
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram