Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message

After 47 years on this earth I changed the standard Karo Pecan Pie recipe my granny made

Posted on 12/12/23 at 10:26 am
Posted by DeoreDX
Member since Oct 2010
4053 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 10:26 am
I love Pecan Pie. It's one of my top 3 favorite deserts. My grandmother used to make it for us all the time when I was little and it reminds me of my childhood. She always used the recipe printed on the Karo Syrup bottle.

Standard Karo syrup pecan pie recipe:

1 cup Karo corn syrup (Light, dark, or a mix of both)
3 eggs
1 cup sugar
2 tablespoons melted butter
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1-1/2 cups pecans
1 9" pie crust

Most recipes carry these ratios. I've seen some add additional flavor (I'm talking about you bourbon or maybe chocolate) and do fancy things like toast the pecans or brown the butter or substitute in some brown sugar. But for the most part the recipe ratios are pretty consistent.

As much as I love Pecan Pie it's one failing in my eyes is that it's sooooo sweet. I'm not usually a super sweet desert guy so the wife always thought my love for Pecan Pie was strange. I was looking up a bourbon pecan pie recipe one day to figure out how much bourbon people usually use in a bourbon pecan pie. In one of the recipe comments someone said they use only 1/2 the amount of sugar to make the pie less sweet. And 1/2 the amount of sugar in brown sugar makes it even more less sweet.

This is what I ended up making.

1 cup Karo corn syrup (1/2 Light 1/2 dark)
3 eggs
1/2 cup light brown sugar
4 tablespoons melted butter
1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 Maker's Mark mini bottle
1 cup pecans coarsely chopped
Enough half pecans to cover the top arranged in a single layer
1 9" pie crust

Get the eggs to room temp. Mix eggs, syrup, sugar melted butter, vanilla extract, bourbon. Put chopped pecans in bottom of pie crust. Pour just enough filling to cover chopped pecans. Arrange pecans on top of filling. Pour rest of filling on pecans. Make sure all the pecans on top had filling poured over it and aren't dry. Bake 350 for 1 hour.

Best pecan pie I've ever had. I made it two more times (except had an opened bottle of bourbon so I didn't need the mini) and served it to other people and they have raved about how great the pie is. Bourbon is not overpowering at all. Very subtle. Without as much cane sugar overpowering everything with sweetness the flavor of the toasted pecans on top really come through. IF you think pecan pie could use a tad less sweetness try it with 1/2 cup of light brown sugar the next time you make one. Thank you random internet recipe commenter for recommended to half the amount of sugar. For me it's a game changer.
Posted by jpainter6174
Boss city
Member since Feb 2014
5281 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 10:28 am to
Will try this, thanks.
Posted by Epaminondas
The Boot
Member since Jul 2020
4119 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 10:32 am to
The most important change is cane syrup instead of corn syrup.
Posted by Midget Death Squad
Meme Magic
Member since Oct 2008
24495 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 11:44 am to
I always put a little bourbon in my pecan pie. It's a game changer. I'll give your recipe a shot next time. I like the addition of the brown sugar. I also agree with an above poster: cane syrup is the way
Posted by Bryno1960
Off River Road
Member since Aug 2013
2499 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 12:14 pm to
I basically use the same recipe except instead of Karo Syrup, I use Maple Syrup, Coconut Sugar and a shot of Kahlua instead of vanilla flavoring. Last time I made one, it turned out great! Don't know why but if I make another, I'm considering using Bailey's just to see how it will be.
Posted by Mr Sausage
Cat Spring, Texas
Member since Oct 2011
12761 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 12:37 pm to
scrape an actual vanilla bean into butter and brown the butter. Throw the cheap vanilla extract out.
Posted by Jax-Tiger
Port Saint Lucie, FL
Member since Jan 2005
24738 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 12:37 pm to
Next cooking challenge is in early January and the theme is Holiday Sides/Desserts.
Posted by NCTigerFan
North Carolina
Member since Nov 2007
354 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 12:46 pm to
Going to try this, thanks. Did you blind bake the crust, or fill it raw?
Posted by Bryno1960
Off River Road
Member since Aug 2013
2499 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 12:55 pm to
When I do use vanilla flavoring, it's not the cheap stuff but real vanilla.
Posted by LSUGUMBO
Shreveport, LA
Member since Sep 2005
8497 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 3:42 pm to
quote:

I changed the standard Karo Pecan Pie recipe my granny made


You better sleep with one eye open- she gonna haunt you!!!!

I don't think the original recipe is too sweet, but I do want to try something a little different. My dad might riot, though- he's a creature of habit, and there should be ZERO adaptation at Easter, Thanksgiving and Christmas.
Posted by Aubie Spr96
lolwut?
Member since Dec 2009
41084 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 4:01 pm to
Will try this soon.
Posted by Professor Dawghair
Member since Oct 2021
1037 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 4:21 pm to
That sounds like a great recipe. Will give it a try.

Interesting that the Steen's recipe on the side of their label calls for 1/2 cup too. But 1 1/2 cups of syrup.
Posted by SpotCheckBilly
Member since May 2020
6402 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 5:44 pm to
A friend of our's dad taught us that trick several years ago. Half the sugar makes the best pie.
Posted by leeman101
Huntsville, AL
Member since Aug 2020
1496 posts
Posted on 12/12/23 at 6:53 pm to
Instead of using 1 cup of Kayo syrup, use a 1/2 cup of Kayo syrup and a 1/2 cup of honey or Sorghum.
This post was edited on 12/12/23 at 6:55 pm
Posted by DeoreDX
Member since Oct 2010
4053 posts
Posted on 12/13/23 at 7:19 am to
quote:

Going to try this, thanks. Did you blind bake the crust, or fill it raw?


I use frozen crusts and just fill it raw. THe wife is industrious enough to make her own crust and blind bakes it. But usually has to cover the crust towards the end to keep from burning it.

Reminds me I once read to start the pie at a higher temperature for 10-15 minutes then drop the temps for a better crust but I never tried it.

ETA: After doing some internet reading now I'm motivated to try blind baking a crust for my next one. Actuall par baking. 425 for 10-15 with weights, take out weights and bakes for 2 more. So it's 1/2 cooked not fully cooked.
This post was edited on 12/13/23 at 7:45 am
Posted by NatalbanyTigerFan
On the water somewhere
Member since Oct 2007
7597 posts
Posted on 12/13/23 at 9:41 am to
quote:

it's sooooo sweet.

If I'm indulging in pecan pie, I'm definitely not worrying about too much sweetness. I only eat pecan pie during thanksgiving time.
Posted by Nawlens Gator
louisiana
Member since Sep 2005
5829 posts
Posted on 12/13/23 at 6:53 pm to

I would try it without any sugar. Seems the syrup would provide enough sweetness for me.

Posted by highup7
Alex City, Al.
Member since Jan 2005
1826 posts
Posted on 12/13/23 at 7:15 pm to
I love a good pecan pie. My new neighbors were outside when I was getting inside my car. The young wife asked me if I would do them a favor when I got back. I said sure. When I got back the couple was still outside and they asked me if I would try a piece of pie. I said okay and the girl went inside and came back out with a slice of pie. The pie was chocolate with pecans. I took a bite and I couldn't believe how good that pie was. The girl told me it was a German chocolate pecan pie. The pie also had coconut in the filling. I love pecan pie but this pie won me over. I'll probably make one sometime this week.
Posted by DeoreDX
Member since Oct 2010
4053 posts
Posted on 12/13/23 at 10:24 pm to
quote:

I love a good pecan pie. My new neighbors were outside when I was getting inside my car. The young wife asked me if I would do them a favor when I got back. I said sure.....


I didn't know where this story was going but if this was the OT I would have thought it the beginning of a porn

I might have to try this German chocolate pecan pie
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram