My Forums

Trending

Quick Links:

Tiger Rant

•LSU Recruiting

•O-T Lounge

•Politics

•More Sports

•Olympics

•SEC Rant

•Saints

•Home/Garden

•Outdoors

•Movie/TV

•Food/Drink

•Money

•Tech

•Music

•Travel

•TD Help

...

Paul Finebaum Names Best Player To Not Win Heisman Trophy

by Larry Leo

May 10, 202236 Comments

On Monday's edition of The Paul Finebaum Show (h/t Brad Crawford of 247Sports), he was asked to name the best college football QB (besides Peyton Manning) to never win the Heisman. Great question. His response...

quote:
"Dan Marino is one we'll throw on that list," Finebaum said. "I'll come up with a couple more here — Stetson Bennett, Colt McCoy ... John Elway was good. Joe Namath wasn't bad, back in the day. Vince Young ... he should've won the Heisman."

"I've got the perfect answer for you, because I still regret not voting for this guy, but — Deshaun Watson."

(The Spun)

Filed Under: NCAA Football

Paul Finebaum Knows Who Deion Sanders Should Be Coaching In 2025

Deion Sanders Responds To Paul Finebaum Calling Colorado 'Nothing'

Paul Finebaum Calls Colorado 'Irrelevant' In College Football Picture

Deshaun Watson's Model Girlfriend Shares More Vacation Photos

36 Comments

Recent Oldest Top

You must be logged in to comment. |

3PieceSpicy•26 months

Dak Prescott

SaintLSU•26 months

Marshall Faulk was robbed as well

Drewco•27 months

Darren McFadden was robbed twice.

Island_Tiger73•27 months

The fact that that moron Finebaum gets a vote is ridiculous.... LOL @ Stetson Bennett

LSU Delts•27 months

First name that came to mind for me was Tyron Mathieu.

LSU Delts•27 months

Tyrann

Ponchy Tiger•27 months

Archie Manning

TutHillTiger•27 months

peyton manning ????

CDawson•27 months

Peyton should have absolutely won it.

TDFreak•27 months

Danny Wuerffel says hello.

arcalades•27 months

that's laughable. Manning couldn't and didn't beat Florida. no peyton shouldn't have won it.

Kirby59•27 months

Rex Grossman

cypresstiger•27 months

Shocked ole Paul didn’t name 11 Bama players

TouchdownTony•27 months

Peyton manning. Jim McMahon Joe Namath Bernie Kosar Eric Dickerson

Corso•27 months

Peter Warrick not winning in 99 because of the Dillard's discount will always suck arse

Amazing Moves•27 months

Best player in the country

m2pro•27 months

give me shaun alexander. mid to late 90's in the SEC was hellacious. Florida, Tennessee, UGA and LSU were killin it.

ncinthenext3•27 months

Flutie stole one from Keith Byars

TigerintheNO•27 months

No, whichever QB won that game was getting the Heisman. Kosar still finished in the top 3 or 4

TouchdownTony•27 months

Actually, when BC and Miami met in 84 the votes were all in at that point. 84 was Fluties to lose from day one with Kosar being close but Miami fell to 8-5 in 84. The day after thanksgiving in 84 was still in the top 5 of games I've ever seen. That damn Flutie would not die.

atltiger6487•27 months

Stetson Bennett? Seriously?

TheWalrus•27 months

Gotta be a troll

tigerfan84•27 months

I stopped reading there

Capo•27 months

Honey Badger would have won hands down without the suspension.

Sid in Lakeshore•27 months

"best college football QB (besides Peyton Manning) to never win the Heisman."

Godfather1•27 months

Ndamukong Suh