Started By
Message

It seems Trump is treating Iran like MacArthur treated Japan

Posted on 6/24/26 at 10:54 am
Posted by hawgfaninc
https://youtu.be/torc9P4-k5A
Member since Nov 2011
64138 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 10:54 am

quote:

THE LESSON OF VERSAILLES: How Trump is treating Iran like MacArthur treated Japan!

The lesson from history we cannot ignore right now with Iran:

After World War I, the Treaty of Versailles humiliated Germany. It crushed their economy, stripped their dignity, and treated their leadership like criminals. What did that produce? Resentment, chaos, and Adolf Hitler.

We almost repeated that mistake in 1945.

But General Douglas MacArthur refused to go down that road with Japan.

MacArthur understood something the Wilson crowd never did: you don’t win the peace by destroying a defeated nation’s leadership if you can use it for stability instead.

Emperor Hirohito was the symbolic heart of Japan. Many wanted him tried as a war criminal and hanged. MacArthur said no.

He kept Hirohito on the throne as a figurehead, had him renounce divinity, and used the Emperor’s authority to push through sweeping reforms - new constitution, demilitarization, land reform, and real democratization.

Result? Japan didn’t descend into chaos or communism. They became one of America’s strongest allies and an economic powerhouse. MacArthur turned enemies into partners.

Fast forward to today.

There’s a loud crowd that says we must completely humiliate and destroy the current leadership in Iran. Topple the regime, no off-ramp, total humiliation.

That’s Versailles thinking.

And it’s dangerous.

The Iranian people are already suffering under their regime. The smarter play - the MacArthur play - is to create an off-ramp.

Give their leadership a path where they can deliver real prosperity and dignity to their own people in exchange for abandoning nuclear weapons, terrorism sponsorship, and regional aggression.

When a nation’s people start seeing tangible improvement in their lives, the appetite for endless jihad and confrontation drops dramatically.

Stability beats endless occupation. Prosperity beats resentment. Smart power beats performative toughness that creates bigger problems down the road.

America First doesn’t mean we’re weak. It means we’re wise.

We learned from Versailles. We learned from MacArthur’s success in Japan. Let’s apply those hard-earned lessons instead of repeating the same mistakes that birthed the last century’s nightmares.

Strength and strategy. Not just slogans.

The goal isn’t to own the libs or look tough on cable news. The goal is to secure America’s future with the least blood and treasure possible.

History already showed us the winning formula.

Now it’s time to use it.

quote:

Few people realize that while we won the war, MacArthur won the peace.

The day he arrived in Japan he ordered his staff NOT to carry any weapon off the airplane. He knew that this would show the Japanese they had been conquered. Churchill said this was the bravest act he'd see in WWII.

When he arrived the population was starving and had been raised to believe that American Soldiers ate babies.

MacArthur was a student of occupations and knew that he had a limited time to turn things around.

Japan had gone through a period of cultural insanity. MacArthur cured them.

You could make the case that Iran has gone through the same kind of cultural insanity. Hopefully they can be cured.

Doomers meanwhile:



This post was edited on 6/24/26 at 11:55 am
Posted by IMSA_Fan
Member since Jul 2024
885 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 10:56 am to
Where is their new constitution and democratically elected government that was completely forced to disarm? Also, I really hope we don’t station tens of thousands of troops there
This post was edited on 6/24/26 at 10:57 am
Posted by Strannix
C.S.A.
Member since Dec 2012
53921 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 10:57 am to
We should nuke a few cities then
Posted by TrueTiger
Chicken's most valuable
Member since Sep 2004
82969 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 10:58 am to
Japan was open to MacAuthur’s ideas because they had just been nuked.
Posted by TigerBear1971
Member since May 2026
385 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:01 am to
Mr Tweeter Bill Mitchell is naive as frick.
quote:

Japan had gone through a period of cultural insanity. MacArthur cured them.

You could make the case that Iran has gone through the same kind of cultural insanity. Hopefully they can be cured.

Muzzies can't be fixed. Ever.
Posted by goatmilker
Castle Anthrax
Member since Feb 2009
76730 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:02 am to
Only works with the obliteration of the IRG.
Also.
Japan was a Island. Iran is surrounded by nations that hate them.
Vultures would need to be dealt with as well.
This post was edited on 6/24/26 at 11:04 am
Posted by Goforit
Member since Apr 2019
8866 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:10 am to
What happens when dumb people make analogies?
Posted by jlnoles79
Member since Jan 2014
14542 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:11 am to
Bill Mitchell?
Posted by Bunk Moreland
Member since Dec 2010
69306 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:13 am to
patriots.win used to be merciless on that guy as he had pretty bad TDS for a while. He has tried to LARP his way back into MAGA world the last year or two.
Posted by rickyh
Positiger Nation
Member since Dec 2003
13150 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:18 am to
The Japanese were honorable people and did not have a religion that ordered death to all that would not follow their hate filled religion
Posted by riccoar
Arkansas
Member since Mar 2006
5256 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:20 am to
I actually got to talk to a B-28 pilot who flew in the formation over the signing of the US-Japan surrender on the USS Missouri.

They got in a lot of trouble because after they flew their routes, they broke formation and flew over the bomb sights because they wanted to see the destruction.
Posted by AGGIES
Member since Jul 2021
12686 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:20 am to
He’s not naive. He’s a propagandist.
Posted by tide06
Member since Oct 2011
24084 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:22 am to
quote:

Where is their new constitution and democratically elected government that was completely forced to disarm? Also, I really hope we don’t station tens of thousands of troops there

Exactly.

The obvious difference here is that McArthur enacted that peace AFTER defeating them and triggering regime change.

We sued them for peace terms and the same IRGC is running the nation today that ran it prewar.
Posted by AUCom96
Alabama
Member since May 2020
7095 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:24 am to
That spin defies gravity.
Posted by RGT
Member since Aug 2024
2049 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:33 am to
It’s sad that human beings call for nuking innocent citizens because their government is evil.Just like millions were duped by Lenon and his evil ,millions of Iranians were led to the slaughterhouse by the overthrow of the Shah in 1979.Millions of people are trapped there who have no way out.Yall say NUKE THEM ,that makes you no better than the existing extremists.No I’m not a bleeding heart liberal,in fact I’m very concervitive who believes all humans are GODS children.
Posted by jlnoles79
Member since Jan 2014
14542 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:37 am to
quote:

patriots.win used to be merciless on that guy as he had pretty bad TDS for a while. He has tried to LARP his way back into MAGA world the last year or two.



He's just a clown posting for clicks like 99.9% of the influencers on twitter
Posted by Bard
Definitely NOT an admin
Member since Oct 2008
59748 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:47 am to
quote:

Japan was open to MacAuthur’s ideas because they had just been nuked twice.

Fixed. They weren't willing to completely surrender after Little Boy, but the follow up with Fat Man changed their minds with the quickness.

We haven't done anything anywhere close to being as demoralizing to the IRGC.
Posted by theballguy
HSV (Dealing only in satire)
Member since Oct 2011
38781 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:49 am to
Something major you're missing.

Trump did not get an unconditional surrender like Truman and MacArthur did. Trump is Temu Truman.
Posted by theballguy
HSV (Dealing only in satire)
Member since Oct 2011
38781 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:50 am to
quote:

We should nuke a few cities then



Trump should listen to Strannix.
This post was edited on 6/24/26 at 11:50 am
Posted by BulldogXero
Member since Oct 2011
10328 posts
Posted on 6/24/26 at 11:51 am to
Bro just needs to admin this was one of the worst foreign policy blunders in decades
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram