re: Was John Wayne a good actor?

quote:

---

Maybe parts were written to his style. He was selective, borderline over exposed at times, but never left the audience feeling exhausted from his presence.

---

It isn't obvious, but he was way ahead of his time. He was a restrained, under actor. He didn't have much stage experience or training, he was a converted film stuntman/extra. He didn't have a "method" or any sort of instinct to project. He was a relatively conscious "under" actor. A "reactor" if you will. He sought to react as a normal person would, not a Hollywood actor. Not flat or disconnected, but a much more natural delivery of material compared to his peers of the 1930s through 1950s.

If you want to compare him to great actors of his generation, Spencer Tracy and Gary Cooper aren't denigrated as always playing themselves, but there isn't a playing card's difference between the three of them in acting style, delivery or, frankly, ability.

Now, if you look at guys with, perhaps a little more range (or ability, if you prefer), William Powell was also a natural guy who could do serious or funny, or something in between. Cary Grant probably in that same category as well.

But, for film acting as a lead in those sorts of films, John Wayne was a fantastic choice for both an entertaining film as well as a profitable one.

quote:

---

So, a short list:

Stagecoach
Fort Apache
She Wore a Yellow Ribbon
Rio Grande
The Quiet Man (NOTE: Non-western period piece)
The Searchers
Rio Bravo
The Sons of Katie Elder
Big Jake
True Grit
The Shootist

---

How about the Cowboys


And The Shootist has Lauren Bacall Some dont know because most of her movies she was old but she was very nice looking lady when she was young

He was Both a good actor and put asses in seats.

He had presence,maybe because of his size. He also knew how to move on camera, possibly because he had been an athlete.

Unrelated, he said a lot of his acting in Westerns came from conversing with Wyatt Earp, who spent a fair amount of time hanging around the studio commissary.

No. Clint Eastwood is a good actor. John Wayne is a cliche.

quote:

---

Go watch The Searchers or The Shootist or True Grit or Rio Bravo and tell me Wayne wasn't a good actor when he wanted to be.

---

I actually don’t think his performance in True Grit is that good. That Oscar was a lifetime achievement award.

Ethan Edwards in The Searchers is his best role by far. It’s a travesty he wasn’t nominated for an Oscar for it.

John Wayne was a F@G. I had to do work at his house and he answered the door in a dress. He had us install 2way mirrors in his house so he could watch his guests have sex.

Repo Man

Michael Caine gets acting advice from John Wayne