re: Alice in Borderland S2 - drops Thursday

I enjoyed season 2 as well.


***SPOILERS***

My only real issue was like you said, it seemed like suddenly it was just impossible to kill people. Kuina got stabbed like 20 times and made it. The girl with the prosthetic leg took a full clip to the abdomen.

Overall liked a lot of the premise. Some of the face cards were really good characters.

Very true, particularly the one legged girl. I took all this as more evidence that the whole thing is a VR game, or they are clones going through this over and over as they die and are recreated. But it could just be way over the top unbelievable action.

Binged S1 and S2 over the past few days. Great show, S2 wasn't as strong, but I still enjoyed it. Will be curious to see where it goes from here.

I thought it was good but frankly I don’t think the writers know what to do with the world yet.
Like this way more than Squid Game, but squid game felt like it set out with defined rules, world and bad guy

Alice feels like they wrote an awesome show and world, and now that they are getting more seasons they have to figure out what the world is and how to explain it

Could be VR, alternate dimension, dream… who the heck knows and not sure how they deliver that without disappointing.

Only have two episodes left for S2. Really liking it so far.

I have a few gripes, like why so much of the city is overgrown with vines since it’s only been a month or two. Or the fact that so often it comes down to Arisu and his crew simply talking their way into winning games (especially Chishiya). Or the fact that they brought Niragi and Aguni basically back from the dead and the main group is trusting them.

But all in all I’m liking the games and liking the outcomes. The whole King of Spades thing seems weird, but I guess he’s the “main boss” dude or something.

I did have some questions, like what the hell Arisu and Usagi saw in the hot spring pools. I watched the scene multiple times and still couldn’t see/tell what it was.

Interested to see if there is some resolution at the end of this one or if they leave it open ended. Something tells me a third season of this may not be as good (since it’s not easy to keep up the quality the longer it lasts and the more answers get fleshed out), but I’ll be with this show for the long haul anyway. I love it. I’ll come read the thread and see what people think once I’m done (hopefully today or tomorrow).

quote:

---

Wasn't it pretty clearly explained at the end? It wasn't VR or a futuristic simulation. It was these people literally fighting for their life while unconscious in the hospital after tbe meteor blast, while in tbe borderland between life and death.

---

Now I believe you’re right, and essentially we’ve gotten all the explanation that we’re going to get.

Ok so I just finished and read the thread in full.

I liked this season WAY more than pretty much everyone else in here apparently. I thought it was awesome. While I did have some gripes similar to everyone else, I thought it did a great job of getting back into the game action while also upping the antes a bit. But also explaining things here and there to help the characters (and us) piece things together.

My gripes are similar to previous ones mentioned. But the biggest is the damage players were able to take and just keep going or stay alive. Like it was so bad sometimes that it was distracting. Niragi and Aguni were ridiculous, as was Kuina taking 37 stabs to the side and abdomen. But the worst was the high school girl taking half a mag to the torso and basically exploding and collapsing….then dragging herself across the field to Aguni. Also they kept giving people death scenes only to bring them back later. It’s like these people are superheroes who can withstand brutal damage…and I won’t even get into the ridiculousness that was the king of spades. But I just chalked it up to anime culture and rode with it.

My other main gripe was how dragged out and slow some of the parts were, especially the emotional ones. The whole Aguni/Usagi thing in the queen of hearts game took like 35 minutes and could’ve been done in ten at most.

But that being said, I thought the season was really good. Not as good as S1 but that’s okay…S1 was pretty amazing. It did feel a little weird that the story seemed to get wrapped up so nicely in E8 but then they tease the Joker at the end. This show could end right now and be pretty awesome. But I’ll ride with new seasons as long as they put them out.

I don’t really care for the explanation of “purgatory” (the Borderlands) for the games though. That didn’t make much sense to me and I wasn’t a huge fan of that route. But at least it’s an explanation and makes SOME sense. I guess I just wish it was something different. But it still made sense and didn’t ruin the show for me or anything. Although like someone said, there’s seemed to be people that died in Borderlands that were alive post-meteor, so chalk that up as another reason I didn’t care for that explanation of what was going on.

Can anybody explain what Arisu and Usagi saw in the hot spring pool? I still have no idea what the frick that was or was supposed to mean. I thought it was maybe a camera (similar to the one in the flowers in the croquet game), but I didn’t see a camera. Also, the cameras and whatnot don’t make much sense in the explanation of the borderlands.

quote:

---

My wife and I both liked the VR explanation best. Purgatory makes sense, but future VR being the explanation and ending the show there would have worked.

---

Yeah I think VR or a simulation of some sort would have worked well. And I assume the Borderlands served as a purgatory for everyone involved in the meteor incident. But with all of the different explanations from the QoH, it seems like they kept trying to take us down the road of making us think it had something to do with it all being in Arisu’s mind.

I also don’t fully get the choice at the end for people to be able to stay in BL as citizens or decline. Does that mean they chose death? Or just chose to stay in a coma or something like that?

For now, I’ll check out this show for as long as they make seasons. But I’m not sure I have much desire to see people other than Arisu and his group. They were great characters. I’d be open to new ones I guess but they’d have to be as good or better.

Yeah I posted that before seeing the final episode. I believe the QoH explained that a little.