Started By
Message
locked post

Who was better? Randy Johnson, greg maddux

Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:20 pm
Posted by Perception
Member since Sep 2017
853 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:20 pm
Or pedro martinez?
Posted by StreakySchmidty
Brisbane
Member since Jul 2014
592 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:20 pm to
Pedro in his prime. His 1999 season was just dumb.
This post was edited on 3/28/19 at 9:22 pm
Posted by Four Leaf Tayback
Member since Aug 2017
1621 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:21 pm to
Johnson
Posted by Perception
Member since Sep 2017
853 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:21 pm to
Or just give me the top 5 pitchers for the 1990s.
Posted by Tigers0891
Baton Rouge
Member since Aug 2017
7151 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:21 pm to
For me In one game, im taking Randy
Posted by lsupride87
Member since Dec 2007
111183 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:22 pm to
Maddux

Can’t believe I am the first person to get it right
Posted by The Seaward
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2006
11530 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:24 pm to
At their peak? Pedro

Overall career? I'd probably give the edge to one of the other two because they pitched a lot more.

All three were obviously great.
Posted by Paul Allen
Montauk, NY
Member since Nov 2007
78301 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:24 pm to
Greg Maddux got a dog after he retired. Hasn’t been walked yet.
Posted by Perception
Member since Sep 2017
853 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:26 pm to
Im going with

randy johnson
Greg maddux
Pedro
Curt Schilling
Roger Clemens
Posted by 0
Member since Aug 2011
17845 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:26 pm to
Better prime? Pedro

Better career? Maddox

Posted by Goldrush25
San Diego, CA
Member since Oct 2012
33963 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:27 pm to
Classic peak vs longevity argument.
Posted by lsutigers1992
Member since Mar 2006
25317 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:27 pm to
Maddux by a mile.

People act like strikeouts count for two outs or something.
Posted by chalmetteowl
Chalmette
Member since Jan 2008
54707 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:35 pm to
quote:

People act like strikeouts count for two outs or something.
this

Maddux used to be extra frustrating bc he almost certainly wouldn't have the best stuff in LA high school ball, let alone MLB, and still nobody really hit him
Posted by SPEEDY
2005 Tiger Smack Poster of the Year
Member since Dec 2003
88135 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:38 pm to
I love the fact that all three were beasts and all three pitched at the same time in the height of the steroid era

I also love that I got to watch all of them in their prime making all those juiced hitters look silly
Posted by ezride25
Constitutional Republic
Member since Nov 2008
26538 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:39 pm to
Nolan Ryan.
Posted by Deplorable Duke
Lousyana
Member since Nov 2016
2619 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:41 pm to
Randy Johnson has that Mark McGwire neck/face disease.

And Mark McGwire has Randy Johnson face/neck.
Posted by Celery
Nuevo York
Member since Nov 2010
11682 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:45 pm to
Pedro
Randy
Maddux
Posted by Perception
Member since Sep 2017
853 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:45 pm to
True...neckface disease
Posted by Lester Earl
3rd Ward
Member since Nov 2003
290723 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:47 pm to
Unit
Pedro
Maddux
Rocket
Smoltz

A better thread would be who is the 5th best pitcher of the 90’s
This post was edited on 3/28/19 at 9:49 pm
Posted by Elwood9
Member since Jan 2019
57 posts
Posted on 3/28/19 at 9:51 pm to
Maddux
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 6Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram