Posted by
Message
STRIPES
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2003
4020 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
I am going with the guy who haa actually been playing in the last 3 years and who the coaches have already picked.


7nette
LSU Fan
Member since Nov 2015
2397 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
I'd say if both were developed to their potential Brennan may have a slightly higher ceiling but Narcisse should have a fairly higher floor. Not sure we currently have the WR's to make Brennan look like Met just yet but they look promising.


Madking
LSU Fan
Ville platte la.
Member since Apr 2016
8357 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
Well obviously Brennan is further along right now or it would’ve been Narcisse as the backup this season. Whether that’s because of Narcisse’s injury or not is beside the point, they are where they are regardless. Pundits and coaches have said Brennan will most likely be an NFL QB, his study habits confidence and arm strength are all no doubters all that’s missing is actually putting it on film. Best possible outcome is Brennan starting the next two seasons while Narcisse totally heals and gets back to being comfortable playing the game giving, with his redshirt, Narcisse two full seasons to start once Brennan leaves after his Jr. year at LSU.
This post was edited on 11/12 at 5:38 pm


BEATIGER
35 Thousand Feet
Member since Jul 2009
451 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
Gawd, I hope you're wrong!

That would mean Canada/O had little success in getting some freak QB talent recruited to LSU.
This post was edited on 11/12 at 5:43 pm


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
16
RogerTheShrubber
LSU Fan
Juneau, AK
Member since Jan 2009
135512 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
Depends on who you like better. Fanboys on both sides

Imagine both will see playing time next year


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
20
mdomingue
LSU Fan
Lafayette, LA
Member since Nov 2010
4196 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
quote:

Looking back at recruiting profiles, Narcisse was more highly recruited than Brennan.




Brennan had more offers but they are two different styles of QB so got offers from different schools with the exception of LSU, Memphis, and Southern Miss. Here are all the offers they had according to 24/7

Brennan - LSU, Arkansas State, California, Cincinnati, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana-Lafayette, Memphis, Oklahoma State, Ole Miss, South Alabama, Southern Miss, Texas-San Antonio, Troy, Vanderbilt, Wake Forest, West Virginia, Wisconsin

Narcisse - LSU, Auburn, Alabama, Arizona State, Clemson, Grambling State, Illinois, McNeese State, Memphis, Nicholls State, North Carolina, Southern Miss, Tulane, Virginia


quote:

Narcisse (#2 ranked QB in LA) received offers from LSU, Auburn, Alabama, Clemson.



Those were some of Narcise's Premiere offers, some of Brennan's were LSU, Cal, Okie State, Wisconsin, and West Virginia.

I do suspect Narcisse is ultimately the better fit for what Canada appears to be doing right now, but Canada is also known to tailor his offenses to fit the talent he has.



slapahoe
LSU Fan
USA
Member since Sep 2009
6402 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
Here's my question on LN....with him being a Dual Threat qb but having 2 major knee surgeries, will the coaches actually treat him like a dual threat and let him run like Hurts or not bc of fear for more injury?


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
70
prepsportsallday
LSU Fan
New Orleans
Member since Nov 2013
2610 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
quote:

I'd say if both were developed to their potential Brennan may have a slightly higher ceiling


Higher ceiling???


basiletiger
LSU Fan
lafayette, la.
Member since Aug 2007
1020 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
Will be 3 years since Narcisse saw significant play. Make it stop.


prepsportsallday
LSU Fan
New Orleans
Member since Nov 2013
2610 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
quote:

Brennan had more offers but they are two different styles of QB so got offers from different schools with the exception of LSU, Memphis, and Southern Miss. Here are all the offers they had according to 24/7


LN was a early 4 star who committed early. His recruitment took off much earlier than MBs. Brennan was a 3 star until late July of his Sr. Year. He impressed 247 at the elite 11. Prior to late spring 2016, LN was higher ranked.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
31
TD SponsorTD Fan
USA
Member since 2001
Thank you for supporting our sponsors
Advertisement
Tigerbait357
LSU Fan
Member since Jun 2011
10718 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
Way to early to know

We haven't seen Narcisse play

Brennan has seen very limited snaps

It will be a toss up IMO

At least both are very talented, hopefully one them can be very good for us at QB next year

IDK if this board will survive another year of bad QB play


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
21
QJenk
LSU Fan
Atl, Ga
Member since Jan 2013
3177 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
We will not know until next year. When one of the players beats out the other.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
10
TigerFanNKaty
LSU Fan
texas
Member since Sep 2008
8392 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
Not trying to be smartass here, but when have you seen him play at this level. I hope the kid is great but he hasn't played in a game in nearly two years and that was high school big difference.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
10
SamuelClemens
Tulane Fan
Earth
Member since Feb 2015
9098 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
If O goes Brennon or bust, does the staff keep Narcisse ready purely as a backup? Or can he be taught the WR position?


7nette
LSU Fan
Member since Nov 2015
2397 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
quote:

Higher ceiling???


Yeah career wise, not just college so I guess that point doesn't really matter.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
00
Ponchy Tiger
LSU Fan
Ponchatoula
Member since Aug 2004
28680 posts
 Online 

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
The honest answer and fair answer is we don't have any idea. Now maybe the coaches know but no one on here does.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
41
Space Cowboy
Member since Oct 2016
2773 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
quote:

who the coaches have already picked 



If that's true then why did coach O say the other day after being cornered by a bunch of Brennan homers like you that Narcisse is now fully rehabilitated and that it was time to see what he can do real soon. He said it because their is going to be a quarterback competition whether you Brennan homers like it or not.

Not to mention, that Narcisse is a much better athlete than the skinny slow kid is and also has the strongest arm on the team. Indeed, if I were a gambler, I'd put my money on Narcisse long before I would put it on the skinny slow kid.


mmcgrath
LSU Fan
New Jersey
Member since Feb 2010
22335 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
quote:

If O goes Brennon or bust, does the staff keep Narcisse ready purely as a backup? Or can he be taught the WR position?
If Brennan is the starter, Narcisse will get plenty of snaps early in significant playing time, even more than Brennan this year.


Space Cowboy
Member since Oct 2016
2773 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
Narcisse got the quality offers, while Brennan got the quantity offers, obviously because Narcisse has the most potential and a much higher ceiling. Give me the guy with quality over the quantity offers any day of the week and twice on Sundays.


DBU
LSU Fan
Member since Mar 2014
15941 posts

re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
Our fans are literally the worst. Good lord


first pageprev pagePage 2 of 8next pagelast page

Back to top

logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram