re: So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?

I can't argue with you. Facts and logic just seem to evade you. Here 's a link to the cut-up of the LSU/Alabama game. LINK

JUST Watch it all plays under center are running/play action. Again 70 - 75% of our offense is spread.

I never said anything negative about Hurts, Newton or DESHAUN Watson. All I said were they weren't "GREAT at digesting defenses". They relied on their athletic ability to extend plays/drives. THAT'S ALL.

That’s because he didn’t know the offense well enough. LN has struggled with that also. I think Canada would rather incorporate the qb runs if it were up to him. So imo he would prefer a more athletic qb. But if Myles is a better option so be it. O has said he wants a DT qb.. so if LN gets his accuracy issues ironed out & learns Canadas offense he may win the job. But all signs point to Myles Imo. Without a spring camp he seemed to understand the offense better than Ln and was more accurate. O said Myles can make all the Throws early on so to me he’s #2, #1 when Etling graduates. Hopefully LN doesn’t transfer because the talk is right now that Brennan is the future. Bad move if he does. Most depth charts will be tougher than LSU’s. Next year He would see the field soon either by struggles or injury at Lsu Imo. Unless he goes to Grambling or juco route like Lindsey.

quote:

---

JUST Watch it all plays under center are running/play action. Again 70 - 75% of our offense is spread.

---

Dude, you’re killing me. If there are plays run from under center, it is NOT a spread offense. It doesn’t matter if 70-75% of the plays were run from out of the gun. Spread offense is a phylosophy, not a formation. Also, spread offenses run consistently with 4-5 WR. How many 4-5 WR sets has LSU run all season? I’d say less than 10% off the top of my head with 4, and less than 2% with 5.

I hate to break it to you pal, but you’re the one that doesn’t understand the facts. There’s no logic at play here. You’re arguing that because LSU used the shot gun formation, they run a spread offense. There’s no logic, you’re just wrong.

You have to be just trolling now.

You said, "spread offenses run consistently with 4-5 WR"
There are only 11 players on the field. 5 lineman, 1 quarterback. So according to you, spread offenses don't have Full backs/H-Backs/Tight-ends.

To help you out here are the snaps from the LSU/Arkansas game:
RB – Derrius Guice (87.0/43 snaps)
WR – D.J. Chark (85.8/27 snaps)
C – Will Clapp (83.1/58 snaps)
OT – Toby Weathersby (78.3/58 snaps)
QB – Danny Etling (78.1/58 snaps)
WR – Dee Anderson (76.8/16 snaps)
H-Back – Tory Carter (76.7/17 snaps)
OT – Saahdiq Charles (73.4/58 snaps)
WR – Stephen Sullivan (72.2/31 snaps)
TE – Foster Moreau (69.5/56 snaps)
OG – Ed Ingram (65.8/58 snaps)
TE – J.D. Moore (64.2/17 snaps)
OG – Garrett Brumfield (63.2/58 snaps)
WR – Justin Jefferson (60.1/4 snaps)
RB – Darrel Williams (59.4/20 snaps)
WR – Russell Gage (57.8/15 snaps)
WR – Drake Davis (56.4/13 snaps)
WR – Derrick Dillon (44.2/21 snaps)
TE – Jamal Pettigrew (42.3/10 snaps)

Please.....name a school that runs a "spread offense"? I can't wait to see this.

Your math is off bud. 4 WR set equals single running back and/or TE. And sure, spread offenses tend to put TE in the slot.

And since you asked
Clemson
Washington
FSU
Ole Miss
TCU
SMU
Oregon
Texas Tech
Baylor
West Virginia
Houston
Arizona

Need I go on?

Also, really not sure what you were trying to accomplish by listing the percentage of snaps by each player?

quote:

---

I’m assumig you meant the “Run and Gun” offense the Spurrier coined in his Florida days?

---

Spurriers offense was called the "Fun and gun".


The "run and shoot" is a similar but different offense.

NO, NO, NO.... don't try to change it up now. Stop talking out of your arse. You said consistently have 4-5 WRs. Not TEs. Also Foster is usually on the line either in pass protection or to chip DE/OLBs, not in the slot for 56 snaps. There were only 58 snaps in the game not including 4th down.

We run multiple offensive formations/sets as well.
3 WR, RB, TE
2 WR, TE, HB, RB
5 WR = LAST DITCH HAIL MARY


What about Troy Carter and JD Moore? LOL Were they in the slot too? I gave you a link to the film I can literally do no more.

Most of the teams you named run almost the exact same offense as we do.

quote:

---

NO, NO, NO.... don't try to change it up now. Stop talking out of your arse. You said consistently have 4-5 WRs. Not TEs. Also Foster is usually on the line either in pass protection or to chip DE/OLBs. There were 58 snaps in the game not including 4th down. What about Troy Carter and JD Moore? LOL Were they in the slot too? I gave you a link to the film I can literally do no more.

---

You literally just stated exactly why LSU does not run a spread offense. My god. How old are you? 12?

quote:

---

Most of the teams you named run almost the exact same offense as we do.

---

you said a lot of stupid shite, but this is by far the dumbest. I can’t even man. You’re making yourself look like a fool.

LINK

Maybe that will help you, kid. Good luck.

Right Spurriers offense was called the fun and gun it had a lot of spread sets but also used the I formation and didn’t use the shotgun until post 1997. The Run and Shoot was what the Warren Moon Houston Oilers, Atlanta Falcons and Detroit Lions used in the 90s. It was also used by the Houston Cougars in the NCAA with Andre Ware and David Klingler its a 4 wide receiver offense mostly under center and was probly the earliest version of the spread offense. I wasn’t really arguing your point just adding on to it by saying you’re right spread style offenses are a philosophy but that there are different disciplines of spread type offenses. For instance Chip Kelly, Hal Mumme, Dan Mullen and June Jones all run “spread” offenses but are all totally different within the spread construct. Kelly uses tempo and zone read as the backbone of his, Mullen uses traditional power running plays but runs them out of the gun, Mumme hardly runs the ball at all and features the short passing game and Jones runs the Run and Shoot which is psss heavy but also features a running back with limited traditional run plays from under center.