Started By
Message

re: Alleva hired the following at Duke in a similar fashion to Orgeron...

Posted on 8/23/18 at 12:40 pm to
Posted by adamb2151
Houston, Texas
Member since Jun 2013
6586 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 12:40 pm to
quote:

Take away Jameis Winston and Jimbo becomes over rated very quickly. I am glad we did not give him that crazy contract


Lol I love this argument. Jimbo recruited and developed Jameis. People act like that doesnt matter. Take away the QB of any championship team and they dont win a championship. Absolute dumbest argument I have ever heard. Take away Deshaun Watson and Dabo doesnt have a championship, he must suck. Lol
Posted by ElderTiger
Planet Earth
Member since Dec 2010
7015 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 12:51 pm to
quote:

A search firm handed him Herman. He had 4 months to negotiate and Texas beat him in 10 min


I understand all the anti-Alleva sentiment regarding his hiring prowess...or lack thereof. But a Tom Herman hire 2 years ago would have been a nightmare. Herman’s dream job was Texas. Whenever that job came open, he would have bolted leaving LSU in worst shape than we are now.
Posted by Adam Banks
District 5
Member since Sep 2009
32013 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 12:58 pm to
quote:

Lol I love this argument. Jimbo recruited and developed Jameis. People act like that doesnt matter. Take away the QB of any championship team and they dont win a championship. Absolute dumbest argument I have ever heard. Take away Deshaun Watson and Dabo doesnt have a championship, he must suck. Lol



Its a bit of a legitimate argument when comparing say Jimbo and Dabo. Dabo had success without watson last year and jimbo has fallen off. Its also reasonable when deciding who to prioritize herman or jimbo.

Its absolutely crazy when trying to justify orgeron who had 0 success prior to his hire.
This post was edited on 8/23/18 at 2:57 pm
Posted by Hoops
LA
Member since Jan 2013
6561 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 12:59 pm to
quote:

thats ironic considering that LSU fans are obsessed with beating bama and Herman did it with tOSU's third string QB in 2014.


Funny way to spell Zeke
Posted by Starchild
Member since May 2010
13550 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 12:59 pm to
quote:

F King Alexander is at the top of my list to hit the road


If only I could actually get excited about prospect of this. Very little chance probably. Regardless, the sooner Joe is gone the better so I’d be content with that even
Posted by tgerb8
Huntsvegas
Member since Aug 2007
5998 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:04 pm to
quote:

Would you rather spend 7.5 a year for Jimbo 
Or 
Would you rather spend 5.4 a year on Orgeron and Einsminger


Obviously I'd rather 7.5/year for Jimbo but that wasn't the deal that got him to College Station.

I'd slightly rather O and Ensminger at 5.4/year than 10 years with or without Jimbo for 75 mil.

The only issue with that trade off is the fact that those werent anywhere near the only two options.
With the Flecks, Kiffins even Arandas out there you shouldn't settle for a proven loser at a university like LSU. But apparently that's Alleva's M.O.
An "experiment" with an unknown commodity like Aranda at HC is a much better move (IMO) than hiring a proven loser for cheap. If recruiting/continuity was the big selling point - you're probably even better off with bringing Frank Wilson back for a shot.

I wasn't really aware of Alleva's history (minus the lacrosse debacle) at Duke. 13 wins in nine years? It's laughably tragic that he is still employed at this level. But no wonder he hired Orgeron. He was probably the only option with a record worse than his own.
Posted by Alt26
Member since Mar 2010
28470 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:06 pm to
Hell, you don't have to go back to his tenure at Duke. Just look at what he did with the LSU basketball program.

He hires Trent Johnson, which, in year one looked like a great hire. Johnson had success at two other stops (Nevada and Stanford) and even won the SEC in year 1. After that it was a complete free fall. The Johnson hire COULD have been forgivable except when after 3 years of mostly losing basketball it became clear Johnson wasn't going to work out at LSU Joe didn't pull the plug. He waited until Johnson himself left in early April, thus putting LSU behind the 8 ball in its search for a new coach. After 10 days he hires a guy he could have hired within 10 seconds (Jones), someone for whom there was literally no national demand outside of LSU.

Jones coaches two seasons. Improves LSU's program, but still fails to make the NCAAT. So what does Joe do? Give him a raise and 2-3 year extension on a 5 year contract!! Why? To keep the wolves at bay from trying to steal Jones?

The Jones waste of time became 100% clear at the end of the 15-16 season when he couldn't even make the NCAAT with a loaded team. Joe could and should have let Jones go then. BUT, due to the stupid and unnecessary extension given a few years earlier, it was economically more burdensome to do that...which allowed the program to completely bottom out in 16-17.

THANK GOD Wade (a) reached out to LSU wanting the job and (b) Eddie Nunez lobbied hard for him. Otherwise, Joe was likely poised to offer the job to Rick Pitino. Once Rick said "no", Joe would have run to Houston to steal Mike Davis away from Texas Southern and proudly had a press conference once again touting a guy no one else wanted.

Of course, that would have been only the third time he had done that at LSU seeing that he made a "Johnny Jones" hire in Orgeron. But rest assured, he had LSU's best interests in mind by refusing to get into a bidding war for Herman, only to get into a bidding war with himself to overpay Ed.

Bob Broadhead wrote a book following his time as LSU's AD about hiring two successful coaches and the zoo that surrounded LSU athletics. Joe could write a book about how to fail upwards.
Posted by AnotherRound
Member since Oct 2012
2865 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:07 pm to
quote:

Lebowski


quote:

Solo Cam


to both of you, seriously. There is really nothing more to add here.

Posted by TigerDM
Baton Rouge
Member since Aug 2013
1606 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:08 pm to
It is yet to be seen how good a coach Herman is,
but with all things being equal he was going to Texas.

Jimbo is Les Miles with really good offense and poor defense instead of the opposite. That's why their best years were together. Jimbo was mediocre at FSU except for the Winston years, that why he was so ready to jump at another job.
Posted by TigerMac81
Bossier City, LA
Member since Dec 2007
3218 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:09 pm to
I'm curious to see what transpires in "The Swamp" this year. Downvote if you like, but when Herman said no I think they should have at least talked to Dan Mullen to see whether he had any interest. He did about as much as anyone has ever done in Starkville, and his offensive approach coupled with Aranda's defense might have been interesting to watch. I would never hope for an LSU loss, but if Mullen and the Gators should lay a beat-down on the Shrimp Boat Captain, perhaps it will be a final nail in Dukey Joe's coffin.
Posted by jTy
Fayetteville, AR
Member since Jan 2018
99 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:09 pm to
quote:

UCLA and Nebraska best Florida for a coach


Had Joe merely done his job Chip Kelly was available less than 2 months after he hired Ed.
Posted by clamdip
Rocky Mountain High
Member since Sep 2004
17949 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:12 pm to
quote:

Anyone else still having trouble believing we hired Orgeron? I still feel like its twilight zone time.

:raises-hand:

It boggles my mind how someone as continually incompetent as Alleva is in such a well paid, high profile position.

We hired Ed Freaking Orgeron.
Posted by illuminatic
Manipulating politicans&rappers
Member since Sep 2012
6962 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:13 pm to
quote:

I'm so tired of the bitching about our coaches and AD. If you don't agree with it, stop going to the games and spending money. Otherwise, nothing will change. 

And that goes for politicians too. If you don't like the way things are, make your voice heard.


So stop bitching because nothing will change but make your voice heard.
Posted by boxcarbarney
Above all things, be a man
Member since Jul 2007
22790 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:13 pm to
quote:

good thing history never repeats itself!!!...


I'm sure he told LSU he was a changed man when he interviewed for the job. And if the Rant has taught me anything, it's that when a man said he's changed we have to ignore his past transgressions and take him at his word.
This post was edited on 8/23/18 at 1:30 pm
Posted by Palm Beach Tiger
Orlando, Florida
Member since Jan 2007
29872 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:18 pm to
Ed O and Jimbo are mutually exclusive in this. I am not an ed orgeron supporter either. But Jimbo only won 6 games last year because a makeup game against a cream puff got put back on the schedule. I had no problem taking Jimbo, I had a huge problem with committing 10 years to a guy who just barely got bowl eligible last year at Florida St.
Posted by Manswers
Michigan
Member since Feb 2009
3619 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:47 pm to
quote:

It’s also a valid argument to say that, comparatively, it was a far worse idea to make Orgeron the HC.


This. The Orgeron hire only makes sense if: (1) He's just a placeholder for Aranda; (2) We actually hire Aranda as HC by 2020; and (3) Aranda actually turns out to be an elite HC.

Skip that. The Orgeron hire makes no sense.
Posted by SammyTiger
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Feb 2009
66832 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:48 pm to
quote:

Giving him the richest contract in college football history isn’t really what poaching a coach looks like.


How else do you poach coaches?

Posted by Dave England
Member since Apr 2013
5107 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 1:55 pm to
quote:

Giving him the richest contract in college football history isn’t really what poaching a coach looks like.

That's exactly what it looks like.
Posted by GeauxTigerTM
Member since Sep 2006
30596 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 2:01 pm to
quote:

I'm sure he told LSU he was a changed man when he interviewed for the job.


Not to derail the fantastic point of the thread, but this is a good jumping off point to another issue which drives me crazy. This notion of mere saying he's changed and having that matter.

Look...I really dislike the guy. I mean, a lot. I've disliked him from before his stint at ole Miss, and like nearly EVERY LSU fan at the time, laughed at those idiots for hiring him there. It was like we had sent them this big, stupid Cajun Trojan Horse to frick up their program. We universally saw what a terrible hire and coach he was then.

With that said...while I'd never like the guy I could have respected him as a head coach...had he bothered to earn that respect. After his interim gig at SC did not get him the head job, had he gone out and asked his agent to find him a small school where he could build or rebuild a program to actually prove to the college football world that Ole Miss had been a fluke and he was ready to run his own program again and was successful there...he'd have earned some respect. Had he parlayed THAT successful job into a mid-major and built that program into his own image and done well there, he could have PROVEN he was a changed coach. He'd have EARNED interest and interviews from Power 5 big time schools...

And had he done that, while I still would have disliked the man, I'd have had far less issue with Alleva tapping him to replace Miles, because he'd have a PROVEN track record of success AFTER running Ole Miss' program into the ditch.

But that's not what he did, is it? After being passed over by Pat Hayden at SC for the coaching job, he pouted publicly about it and then simply took his coach's whistle and went home. Literally. From there he began schmoozing local radio and TV personalities and making inroads with local high school coaches...still while not a coach anywhere, which in retrospect seems kind of odd, doesn't it? Unless there was a plan...

Then Miles hired him as the DL coach...and my a-hole clenched.

From there, it was a mid-season firing of the most successful coach in LSU's history and suddenly the guy who had not gotten a gig after his 6-2 interim run at SC and ZERO head coaching experience since then was interiming LSU. And even THEN it seemed unthinkable that he'd be given the reigns and most assumed he'd have to nearly run the table to even be considered. And then that didn't happen...and Alleva hired his arse anyway.

So...instead of ACTUALLY changing and proving he had become a better coach, all he had to do to get our Top 10 job was to "SAY" he had...and that seems to have been enough for both or idiot AD and a large portion of our fan base.
Posted by Dave England
Member since Apr 2013
5107 posts
Posted on 8/23/18 at 2:05 pm to
I find it hard to blame Coach Orgeron. Look, he felt entitled to a top-tier college football head coaching job. Many coaches do. He had the cunning to go out and get it, right out from under the nose of his then-boss. That takes serious gumption, a great quality in a leader.
first pageprev pagePage 3 of 5Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram