Started By
Message
locked post

The 10 best underrated restaurants in the NOLA Metro

Posted on 2/17/12 at 11:42 am
Posted by TulaneLSU
Member since Aug 2003
Member since Dec 2007
13612 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 11:42 am
In situations where there are adequate amounts of food, security, and housing, people usually maintain an instinctive conformity. Instinctive conformity transforms over time to become rationalized conformity, as people of similar minds agree to agree and compromise for the sake of armistice. In the world of online forums, this phenomenon is heightened because all interactions are concrete because they are written to be seen and later reviewed. Friendships are forged, alliances with and against others are made, and there is a formatted milieu where some things become acceptable and others unacceptable.

On this forum, we see it frequently. One example: north Louisiana people love Johnny's and believe it's the state's best pizza. South Louisiana people make fun of it and say it's an average conveyer belt pizza. The truth? I've not had it, but I bet it's between the two extremes that have formed as a result of both neighborhood and geographical bias and alliance conformity.

Here are ten restaurants I think that do not get their due on this forum. You are, as always, free to make your own list. But chances are, we'll just have complainers and Monday morning top ten listers.

10) East of Italy - Admittedly, even I forget about this place, but can you blame me? It's all the way out at the lake near the Lakefront Arena and there's really no reason to go over there. But in that early 1990s strip mall is a gem of an Italian restaurant with great sandwiches and good pizza. I am upset I didn't mention them in the 10 best sandwiches in the NOLA Metro thread.

9) Atchafalaya - Clancy's, Patois, Gautreau's, and Coquette get a lot of love for doing the Creole neighborhood bistro well, and they do. But Atchafalaya does a good job and is rarely mentioned.

8) Dish oh Hayne - Quite frankly, I don't know if I've ever read anyone mention it on this board. And it reminds me that I need to finish the Top 10 restaurants in NOLA listed by neighborhood threads. The shrimp and grits are the best in town.

7) Casa Garcia - El Gato Negro gets some love and Superior gets ridiculous (and IMO undeserved) attention. But Casa Garcia does Tex Mex far better than anyone in town and is very rarely mentioned.

6) Panchitas - Meanwhile, Kenner and Mid-City Latin upstarts are the talk of the forum, and for good reason in most cases, but lost in the talk is Panchitas, which is one of the best Mexican and Latin restaurants in New Orleans. I don't understand why it's not mentioned more often.

5) Munch Factory - Someone on the forum recommended me eat here several months ago. I did and immediately fell in love with it. The African American Creole bistro has never been done better.

4) Upperline - In the same situation as Atchafalaya. I went six months ago and thought it was fantastic. I wonder if it went through a rough period a few years ago and its reputation suffered as a result because, besides Tiger Attorney, I haven't noticed it mentioned here.

3) Shogun - While bad sushi restaurants like Ninja and overrated restaurants like Horinoya get a lot of the press here, Shogun continues to make the city's best sushi.

2) Castnet Seafood - I believe is was JasonL who alerted me to this place recently. I made a trip to the East just to eat here. Wow. It's every bit as good as the Kenner seafood joints and cheaper. Beastin in the east all I have to say about that.

1) Sal and Judy's - Has anyone ever mentioned this restaurant here? It is in a land far, far away. Nonetheless, it's among America's best Italian restaurants.
This post was edited on 2/17/12 at 11:43 am
Posted by iAmBatman
The Batcave
Member since Mar 2011
12382 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 11:44 am to
Posted by REG861
Ocelot, Iowa
Member since Oct 2011
37774 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 11:45 am to
Agree on Atchafalaya. Great stuff. I've been wanting to go to Sal and Judy's. Heard great things. Don't know enough about the other ones on here
Posted by TheHumanTornado
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since May 2008
4068 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 11:49 am to
Sal and Judy's is my favorite restaurant in Louisiana. Period.
Posted by Fun Bunch
New Orleans
Member since May 2008
127798 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 11:51 am to
I have constantly doubted Shogun, until I went with a friend who knew one of the sushi chefs. He's a young hotshot that is probably going to be moving on soon. We sat in front of him and told him, make whatever you want.

It was the best I've ever had.
Posted by Powerman
Member since Jan 2004
170583 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 11:52 am to
quote:

9) Atchafalaya

The gumbo there is the best I've had in the city and by a pretty wide margin

Posted by baytiger
Boston
Member since Dec 2007
46978 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 11:53 am to
quote:


6) Panchitas - Meanwhile, Kenner and Mid-City Latin upstarts are the talk of the forum, and for good reason in most cases, but lost in the talk is Panchitas, which is one of the best Mexican and Latin restaurants in New Orleans. I don't understand why it's not mentioned more often.


I've still yet to try Panchitas simply because there's like 5 good restaurants right there and we always end up going somewhere else.
Posted by Powerman
Member since Jan 2004
170583 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 11:56 am to
quote:

10) East of Italy

Have you been to Sassafras in the same shopping center?

It's pretty decent NOLA fare. I've eaten there a couple of times and I'm always the only white person in there
Posted by glassman
Next to the beer taps at Finn's
Member since Oct 2008
117808 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 12:10 pm to
quote:

besides Tiger Attorney, I haven't noticed it mentioned here.


Then you don't notice much. Gris Gris, myself and many others have mentioned it numerous times.

ETA: I agree on the Sal and Judy's selection. Personally I like it better than Impastato's and by a pretty largin margin.
This post was edited on 2/17/12 at 12:12 pm
Posted by Napoleon
Kenna
Member since Dec 2007
73155 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 12:18 pm to
Casa Garcia sucks.

I'm sorry, it used to be a favorite, but the last three times I went the food was sub-par and the service was the worst.
The only time I ever felt so bad about a server that I only tipped the change.

Guy didn't bring out my drink the entire dinner, said he was really busy (had two tables), and the manager did nothing to help out.


Of your list its the only place I tried.
Posted by saderade
America's City
Member since Jul 2005
26237 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 12:57 pm to
Disagree on Shogun- always seems to be crowded and is the most popular Metairie sushi restaurant. This spot should belong to Kanno. Agree with other posters about Casa Garcia. Went 2 months ago- not very good.

I want to add in Iris, Meauxbar, and Italian Barrel. Most people in the city have not heard of any of these places.
This post was edited on 2/17/12 at 1:06 pm
Posted by TigerWise
Front Seat of an Uber
Member since Sep 2010
35131 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 1:02 pm to
Casa Garcia is way overrated on this board and sucks. It's a poor excuse for a Mexican restaurant.
Posted by LSU fan 246
Member since Oct 2005
90567 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 1:26 pm to
quote:

3) Shogun - While bad sushi restaurants like Ninja and overrated restaurants like Horinoya get a lot of the press here, Shogun continues to make the city's best sushi.



how do you consider this place underrated?

take away that you think its the best in the city when most of the people in the city dont think the same way.
Posted by Powerman
Member since Jan 2004
170583 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 1:29 pm to
quote:



how do you consider this place underrated?


It's not in New Orleans so it can't be good?
Posted by superloser
bloody tangipahoa
Member since Apr 2009
678 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 1:30 pm to
Sal & Judy's : I used to like it, but I haven't been there in 25 to 30 years. Nuvalari's (I know I misspelled that) is also in that area and is reasonably good Italian.
This post was edited on 2/17/12 at 1:33 pm
Posted by pooponsaban
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2008
13494 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 1:32 pm to
quote:

I have constantly doubted Shogun, until I went with a friend who knew one of the sushi chefs. He's a young hotshot that is probably going to be moving on soon. We sat in front of him and told him, make whatever you want.

It was the best I've ever had.


You attribute that to the knife and not the product?
Posted by Pork Que
New Orleans
Member since Jun 2010
849 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 1:35 pm to
quote:

I want to add in Iris, Meauxbar, and Italian Barrel. Most people in the city have not heard of any of these places


This. I'd include One as well.
Posted by Powerman
Member since Jan 2004
170583 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 1:35 pm to
quote:



You attribute that to the knife and not the product?


With sushi presentation is everything
Posted by Ice Cold
Over Macho Grande
Member since Jun 2004
18871 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 1:47 pm to
quote:

Disagree on Shogun- always seems to be crowded and is the most popular Metairie sushi restaurant. This spot should belong to Kanno. Agree with other posters about Casa Garcia. Went 2 months ago- not very good.
I like Shogun, but Little Tokyo on Causeway is better.

ETA: Saying Shogun is overrated is laughable.
This post was edited on 2/17/12 at 1:48 pm
Posted by etm512
Mandeville, LA
Member since Aug 2005
20996 posts
Posted on 2/17/12 at 2:31 pm to
quote:

Sal and Judy's


Good but not even the best Italian you can get on the Northshore. Plus you have to drive to fricking Lacombe. If I'm going to Lacombe, I'm going to La Provence.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram