Started By
Message
locked post

The 10 best pizzas in the NOLA Metro

Posted on 7/31/11 at 5:58 pm
Posted by TulaneLSU
Member since Aug 2003
Member since Dec 2007
13629 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 5:58 pm
Pizza has historically been an area of poverty on the NOLA dining scene. Chains have long dominated the scene, and only in the last five or so years have we made inroads. The only West Bank and North Shore pizza I have eaten was Mo's.

1) Cafe Nino, Carrollton: The restaurant is a dump, but the pizza maker is a pizza artist who has been at his craft for five decades.

2) Brooklyn Pizzeria, Metairie: Another dump on the inside, but not as dumpy as Nino's. Everything it lacks in aesthetics it makes up for in the pizza. Even in NYC, this place would be a favorite of locals.

3) Mark Twain, Old Metairie: Flashback to the Happy Days and probably the best example of what traditional NOLA styled pizza is.

4) Pizza Delicious, Bywater: I've had it only twice at this take out only joint, but both times the pie was alive.

5) Sbarro's, Canal Place/Lakeside: It receives hate and disrespect from the cultured lovers of pizza, but it didn't become a powerhouse serving bad pizza. A fresh slice of pepperoni from Sbarro's is as good as any slice in NOLA.

6) R & O's, Bucktown: The crust is slightly thicker than a NY style, but maintains a nice dusting on the bottom and perhaps the best red sauce in town.

7) Wit's Inn, Mid-City: The pinnacle of pub fare, pizza should be served instead of burgers. Like MT's, this is another example of good traditional NOLA styled pie.

8) Crescent Pie & Sausage Company, Mid-City: On taste alone, this would be my #3 pizza. But the fact that their pies are so unfilling and expensive drops it way down. The pizzas shouldn't cost a buck over eight.

9) Tower Pizza, Metairie: It feels like the oldest pizza shop in the area. The pizza is good, but I get a headache eating here and the service can be rude when they are crowded.

10) Mona Lisa, French Quarter: Only had it once, but it was very good. The toppings made it.


Bonus 5!!!!!

11) Rocky's: This place doesn't get too much love. I think because it's hidden by a nearby and awful Reginelli's, but they make a delicious pizza. I like to think of it as Prime Papa John's thin crust pizza, the best of all the chains. Toppings are plentiful. Only complaint is their prices are high.

12) Theo's, Uptown: I've heard some say it's the best in the city. It's not, but it is good. The toppings are fantastic, but I don't like the crust.

13) Pizza Amore, Metairie: The thin crust isn't worth getting, but it has, without a doubt, the best deep dish in town.

14) Mo's, Westwego: It ends up on many top five lists, IMO, undeservedly. Because it's large and the only decent place to eat in Westwego doesn't mean it's great. It's good, but the dough is confused. It can't decide if it wants to be NY or a doughy breadstick. Great atmosphere.

15) Louisiana Pizza Kitchen, Riverbend: thin, wood fired crust is delicious.


5 Most Overrated Pizzas in NOLA

1) Slice - bland.

2) Domenica's - not enough sauce or cheese. Like eating bread

3) Reginelli's - barf. Like they emptied pasta sauce for pizza sauce. Way too chunky and too bready.

4) Italian Pie - how has this chain expanded in NOLA?

5) Midway - I feel bad for the guy because he seems nice but deep dish or half deep dish just isnt good.
This post was edited on 3/1/12 at 2:45 pm
Posted by rondo
Worst. Poster. Evar.
Member since Jan 2004
77515 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:01 pm to
1) New York Pizza
Posted by Neauxla
New Orleans
Member since Feb 2008
34447 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:08 pm to
What about:

Reginelli's
Rocky's
Slice
Pie
Italian Pie
Cafe Roma
Desperados
Rotolos
Cafe Fresco
Naked Pizza
Dough Bowl
Figaro's
Angeli





This post was edited on 7/31/11 at 6:16 pm
Posted by Rohan2Reed
Member since Nov 2003
75674 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:09 pm to
you're about to get reamed
Posted by Neauxla
New Orleans
Member since Feb 2008
34447 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:11 pm to
quote:

you're about to get reamed


By him?
Posted by TulaneLSU
Member since Aug 2003
Member since Dec 2007
13629 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:11 pm to
Reginelli's is glorified and dry Papa John's
Slice is bad. I honestly like Domino's more.
Pie. Is that the new place in Metairie? Haven't been.
Italian Pie. Please be joking.
Cafe Roma. Fate hasn't allowed me to eat here yet.
Desperados. Never heard of it.
This post was edited on 2/29/12 at 12:12 pm
Posted by Cosmo
glassman's guest house
Member since Oct 2003
131260 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:14 pm to
Domenica Happy Hour pizza FTMFW
Posted by Lester Earl
3rd Ward
Member since Nov 2003
290662 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:15 pm to
nice list but Cafe Nino is prob closer to #10 or so.
Posted by TigerWise
Front Seat of an Uber
Member since Sep 2010
35131 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:18 pm to
quote:

Message
Posted by rondozombie
1) New York Pizza



+1, best pizza plus good beer.
Posted by Neauxla
New Orleans
Member since Feb 2008
34447 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:19 pm to
quote:

1) New York Pizza


+1, best pizza plus good beer.


meh
Posted by baytiger
Boston
Member since Dec 2007
46978 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:21 pm to
quote:


Dough Bowl
I don't know anyone at Tulane who refers to this place as "Dough Bowl". It's called "Boot Pizza"

that said, it's not half bad
Posted by threeputt
God's Country
Member since Sep 2008
24798 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:21 pm to
I am just going to go ahead and say it ...





















Ready
















wait for it




















The above mentioned establishments do not hold a candle to Johnnys ...
Posted by Neauxla
New Orleans
Member since Feb 2008
34447 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:22 pm to
quote:



Dough Bowl
I don't know anyone at Tulane who refers to this place as "Dough Bowl". It's called "Boot Pizza"

that said, it's not half bad



Well I didn't go to Tulane
Posted by GynoSandberg
Bay St Louis, MS
Member since Jan 2006
74401 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 6:53 pm to
quote:

Reginelli's is glorified and dry Papa John's


I only really care about how a pizza tastes and not how it's made (in this instance, a conveyor oven). With that being said, Reginelli's has some damn good specialty pies.
This post was edited on 7/31/11 at 7:03 pm
Posted by lsumailman61
Gulf Shores
Member since Oct 2006
7964 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 7:30 pm to
Domenica happy hour pizzas are half price!
Posted by LSU fan 246
Member since Oct 2005
90567 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 7:34 pm to
quote:

Mo's, Westwego


holy fricking shite you went to the westbank????????????????
Posted by CE Tiger
Metairie
Member since Jan 2008
41902 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 8:57 pm to
just finished off some Mama Mea's. 3 Large 1 toppings for $18 cant be beat
Posted by VOR
New Orleans
Member since Apr 2009
68727 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 8:58 pm to
quote:

Domenica happy hour pizzas are half price!


Damned good deal.
Posted by Athanatos
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2010
8188 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 9:05 pm to
Didn't Desperados close?
Posted by notiger1997
Metairie
Member since May 2009
61717 posts
Posted on 7/31/11 at 9:19 pm to
I don't get pizza much, but when I do, it is Mark Twain and The Pizza Shop.
Mark Twains is just about the perfect neighborhood pizza place.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 4Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram