Anyone gone down The Ranch Fairy rabbit hole...

I’ve seen a few of his videos.

I did last year. Kinda weird guy but agree about shooting heavy arrows.

Oh no doubt, i’ve been killing deer for years with light stuff. I’ve recently gotten into public land hunting Kansas and Missouri and his logic is sound for those types of hunts, specifically quartering shots.

quote:

---

While I agree with somewhat heavier arrows since I shot them for a while, I don’t agree with his approach. The videos I’ve seen he basically says your dumb if you don’t shoot heavy.

---

I've watched several of his videos, and he can definitely be abrasive about it.

However, what's equally as funny to me is how defensive the "flapper" guys get when anyone starts talking about heavy arrows. It's nothing but a "fad" according to them.

Not sure how an argument based on physics is a "fad", considering it's been a trad thing for a long time.

I switched from a 400ish grain setup to a 530 grain setup last year. I lost some distance and speed for sure (not saying much for an 11 year old Diamond), but it's still plenty fast enough for the shorter shots (30 and less) I'm typically going to see, and I've noticed that my bow is quieter and my shots group better. That likely has as more to do with the fact that I started building my own arrows as it does the heavier arrow, but that was a side effect of going heavier that I'm happy to have found. Now I have another thing to spend time (and money) doing...lol!

quote:

---

will guys that talk about the importance of sharpness. I never understood it really until I listened to that.

---

Haven’t watched the videos but will just to see what it’s about. I have shot heavy 2117 Easton aluminum out of a recurve and shot pencil thin beemans and killed deer with both. One thing a mentor preached to me is the importance of shooting razor sharp broadheads and I can remember stropping a bear razor head till it was scalpel sharp.
He used the analogy of how a slice with a razor while shaving would not quit bleeding but that a jagged cut with a piece of scrap metal would quit fairly quick!! Also cutting vessels and arteries is doubled if you add blades was his thought “4 is better than 2”.

I personally don’t care for his personality but I’ve learned several things on his channel, including knock tuning and a process of how to find an arrow your bow shoots well. I also didn’t put much of an emphasis on maintaining my broad heads before his shows, too.

I was told about Ed Ashby when I got into bow hunting and the high FOC and heavier arrow science all made sense to me. I think questioning the status quo is good for the sport.

To the “you don’t need that to kill a whitetail” crowd, other than velocity I don’t understand the con(s) of an overkill arrow... It’s not like a you’re gonna damage more meat with a heavier arrow or something so if you can live with a drop of speed why not.

quote:

---

To the “you don’t need that to kill a whitetail” crowd, other than velocity I don’t understand the con(s) of an overkill arrow... It’s not like a you’re gonna damage more meat with a heavier arrow or something so if you can live with a drop of speed why not.

---

With a 700 grain arrow you better know the exact yardage of the deer you’re shooting at beyond 30 yards, that’s the only downside.

quote:

---

Add in the fact that shooting flatter enables you to
More likely hit your spot vertically better, the argument for ‘more ethical’ is questionable at best.

---

Ethics in archery (and hunting in general) is a tricky subject, anyway. There is no universal ethic when it comes to hunting.

Let's be honest--you can get a pretty flat trajectory with an underspined arrow and a budget broadhead. So which is better at that point: the budget arrow that flies quick, or a "heavy" arrow built to Ranch Fairy Standards?

I don't think either is wrong without context. Both will kill if shot placement is correct. But one has a better chance of getting a kill on a less than perfect shot.

I've killed pigs with Gold Tip Hunter 400s with a G5 on them. Nothing wrong with lighter, faster arrows. But I don't know that I would argue that they are more ethical.

quote:

---

With a 700 grain arrow you better know the exact yardage of the deer you’re shooting at beyond 30 yards, that’s the only downside.

---

I agree, I only take 25 yards or in shots at whitetail. A hog I’ll shoot at 30.

Even with close yardage shots, my speed dropped so much that being off 5 yards off matters a lot. I shot a yearling high shooting for 25 and it was at 20. Could have been lethal had I shot it again immediately but I hesitated.

I’m going to try the ez v site to see if it would be a good fit for what I’m after. I currently use a single pin and in hunting situation I don’t want the pressure of getting the exact yardage and adjusting for it on top of the pressure of executing the shot.

My arrows are coming out the bow 235 FPS roughly.

I increased my setup because of his videos. It's all Ashby stuff that's been around for a while. I got to 20% FOC and 600 total arrow weight and I'm happy. An EZ V sight is definitely in my future.