Started By
Message

What major plot points do you think the Sequel Trilogy would have taken without Rian?

Posted on 1/31/20 at 10:28 am
Posted by Mando
Boston
Member since Dec 2019
573 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 10:28 am
What direction do you personally think the Trilogy was going?

I think it was setting Snoke up to be the big bad as Plagueis.

In the second film we see Luke training Rey but it's obvious old age as taken it's toll on Luke, however he isn't close to the clown we saw in Last Jedi. He went in seclusion to best determine how to go forward and has a plan to defeat Snoke. Big reveal of the film is Snoke as Plagueis. Luke Sacrifices himself at the end of the movie to save Rey against Plagueis and Kylo. Rey is clearly undermatched against Kylo and he was on the verge of killing her before Luke intervenes. Kylo betrays his master at the end of the film and kills Plagueis.

Third film: No clue but I think this setup would allow JJ to really put together something great.
Posted by JetsetNuggs
Member since Jun 2014
13910 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 10:40 am to
I liked TROS but I agree. I don’t see why they couldn’t have just made Snoke into Plagueis.

Plagueis apparently discovered how to cheat death, so it could’ve been that it didn’t matter that Kylo killed him in TLJ. He could’ve just kept jumping bodies or something.

Snoke even says that he can’t be betrayed and he sees that Kylo is about to strike down his true enemy. It would’ve been an awesome reveal in TROS.
This post was edited on 1/31/20 at 10:41 am
Posted by blueboy
Member since Apr 2006
56318 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 11:13 am to
quote:

In the second film we see Luke training Rey but it's obvious old age as taken it's toll on Luke, however he isn't close to the clown we saw in Last Jedi. He went in seclusion to best determine how to go forward and has a plan to defeat Snoke. Big reveal of the film is Snoke as Plagueis. Luke Sacrifices himself at the end of the movie to save Rey against Plagueis and Kylo. Rey is clearly undermatched against Kylo and he was on the verge of killing her before Luke intervenes. Kylo betrays his master at the end of the film and kills Plagueis.

None of this was ever going to happen, but it's because of Kennedy, not Johnson. Sucking off the Chinese also had a lot to do with it, but shite like Laura Dern being forcefricked into the movie, Leia becoming Jedi Mary Poppins and Rey being invincible were always going to be a part of it because of Kennedy.

Posted by Freauxzen
Utah
Member since Feb 2006
37263 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 11:30 am to
Snoke = Plageius for sure

Rey = A Real Skywalker for sure






And most importantly....


Ackbar would not have been randomly killed off screen. I'm confident we see Ackbar in the second film without Johnson.
Posted by Warfarer
Dothan, AL
Member since May 2010
12125 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 11:34 am to
personally i would have said the following:

1. rey finds luke and when he sees how powerful she is he decides to train her.
2. we find out that luke did what he did to Ben and ben flips to dark side but the other students follow him because of his name and strength and become the knights of ren.
3. snoke is revealed as plagueis. rey and luke go after him and kylo, luke sacrifices himself to save ben and proves that he did love him and fricked up.
4. ben turns on snoke and gets rey out as she is losing to him. The go back and lick their wounds.
5. Hux comes in happy as hell as he is the new ruthless leader of the FO.

ep 9 is rey and ben gathering people and lining up a plan to attack and take out hux and snoke and break the FO.
Posted by LuckyTiger
Someone's Alter
Member since Dec 2008
45200 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 11:35 am to
After seeing RoS I think Abrams would have made a shitty trilogy.

Not as bad as Rian Johnson of course, because nothing in the universe is as bad as Rian Johnson, but shitty nonetheless.

I thought RoS was very bad.
Posted by RedPants
GA
Member since Jan 2013
5413 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 11:48 am to
quote:

Plagueis apparently discovered how to cheat death, so it could’ve been that it didn’t matter that Kylo killed him in TLJ. He could’ve just kept jumping bodies or something.

Which is exactly what they did with his apprentice, Palpatine.
Posted by The Pirate King
Pangu
Member since May 2014
57676 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 12:01 pm to
quote:

but shite like Laura Dern being forcefricked into the movie, Leia becoming Jedi Mary Poppins and Rey being invincible were always going to be a part of it because of Kennedy.


They don’t care how it’s done, you must have representation regardless of what it does to the final product. (See CNN complaining Trump’s emergency task force for the coronavirus wasn’t diverse enough).

It’s how those types think.
Posted by Mando
Boston
Member since Dec 2019
573 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 12:12 pm to
quote:

Warfarer


That is a great second movie. Take notes Rian
Posted by Scoob
Near Exxon
Member since Jun 2009
20373 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 12:22 pm to
quote:

After seeing RoS I think Abrams would have made a shitty trilogy.

Not as bad as Rian Johnson of course, because nothing in the universe is as bad as Rian Johnson, but shitty nonetheless.

quote:

Snoke = Plageius for sure
My problem with all this, is that I think Abrams put the wrong tone out.

Snoke raised his voice a few times in TFA, which to me lessens his impact. If he's Plaqeius, I'd have wanted him to be soft-spoken and ominous, not irritable and cranky.
Same thing goes with his ginormous hologram- it's like he's overcompensating for something. Less is more, when you're really the Big Bad.

Since they took out the New Republic in the first movie, I really don't know where you go afterwards to make this good. It didn't need to be the TLJ shitshow, but options were already very limited by that.
Posted by ThuperThumpin
Member since Dec 2013
7309 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 12:30 pm to
quote:

After seeing RoS I think Abrams would have made a shitty trilogy.

Not as bad as Rian Johnson of course, because nothing in the universe is as bad as Rian Johnson, but shitty nonetheless.

I thought RoS was very bad.


Its hard to say. I agree RoS was terrible but I think it could have been decent or at least not as bad if the story he was trying to tell had been stretched out of two movies. It was so badly edited and so many major plot points were not fleshed out or not explained at all.
Posted by ZappBrannigan
Member since Jun 2015
7692 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 12:40 pm to


Sith is really just the Super Adventure Club from a long time ago.





Posted by LuckyTiger
Someone's Alter
Member since Dec 2008
45200 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 12:42 pm to
quote:

My problem with all this, is that I think Abrams put the wrong tone out. Snoke raised his voice a few times in TFA, which to me lessens his impact. If he's Plaqeius, I'd have wanted him to be soft-spoken and ominous, not irritable and cranky. Same thing goes with his ginormous hologram- it's like he's overcompensating for something. Less is more

This was a huge problematic theme running throughout Abrams’ SW movies with RoS in particular, from my POV.

If Abrams was using paint as a medium he would have been throwing buckets of paint onto a canvas and watching it splatter.

Chopped, rushed, crammed, spread all over the place in breadth but wholly lacking in depth, poorly conceived with hints of desperation, poorly executed with no deftness. Just a big, loud, explosive, colorful mess.

And I’m not even getting into the preachiness and the cringing dialogue.
Posted by Midget Death Squad
Meme Magic
Member since Oct 2008
24544 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 1:37 pm to
Rose Tico gets her taco plowed by a group of Finn clones, then declares her love of them all, because, you know...









This post was edited on 1/31/20 at 1:42 pm
Posted by BlackAdam
Member since Jan 2016
6450 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 3:34 pm to
I think it was set up for Rey to be Luke's daughter.
Posted by RobbBobb
Matt Flynn, BCS MVP
Member since Feb 2007
27898 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 5:29 pm to
quote:

without Rian

without Rian? Hell how about not starting the trilogy with a reboot of the 1st Star Wars movie?

Ep 7: How about instead of Snoke, we get Darth Plagueis? Who is was forced out of his re-animation process because not only did a Skywalker bring balance to the force, but Luke is kicking butt all over the galaxy. Its now or never for the Sith Lord

Plagueis has Leia killed and comes to Ben to get him to blame Han for not being there to protect her. Han and Leia are still together, but he charters out the Falcon, and is gone. A lot. Ben confronts Han at the funeral and reveals his dark side toward him

As lead instructor at Lukes Jedi Academy, Ben begins recruiting the Knights of Ren from former and current students, while Luke is away as head of the council putting out fires. Han contacts Luke, who races back just in time to confront Kylo and the Knights, but massive destruction ensues with Han being gravely injured as the Knights flee to a Plagueis stronghold

Ep 8: Han recovers after being placed in carbon freeze for surgery, and sees the conflict in Luke. He tells him to seek out a girl that he met on his travels named Rey. She was very strong with the force, but clueless as to why. She could be a valuable asset if they need to confront Kylo again

Luke finds Rey and instantly senses her to be a Palpatine. He also recognizes the good in her, and trains her without telling her everything. Meanwhile, the Knights are subduing governments across the galaxy and forcing them to join the First Order

While Luke is away, Han, Lando, Poe and others are tasked with leading the charge against Plagueis and his now formidable army. Ben senses his fathers involvement and leads a mission to destroy his base. Luke also senses this and takes Rey to save Han. They arrive too late and find Han dying. Rey confronts Kylo and they frick each other up

Ep 9: Luke anticipating a rebellion on this order has hidden Jedi assets across the galaxy, who are activated and ensnare Plagueis and the Knights in a ever tightening circle of defeats

As Luke and Rey confront Plagueis, Kylo and the few remaining Knghts, Plagueis tells Rey about her heritage and convinces her to turn on Luke. As she is about to strike the final blow to Luke, Ben recognizes that Leia was killed by Plagueis and intervenes

As the Rey/Ben light saber battle intensifies, a severely injured Plagueis attempts to flee and regroup, but Lukes final act to is sever Plagueis head from his body, thereby ending the ability to reimage himself again

That distraction allows Rey and Ben to talk out a plan. Ben has to go into hiding, because of all the destruction Kylo has caused. No one ever has to know that Rey turned briefly to the dark side. They give Luke a Jedi burial with Ben in disguise and Rey assumes head of the council, with Luke as her guiding spirit
Posted by TheeRealCarolina
Member since Aug 2018
17925 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 6:58 pm to
I read that the last alternate ending that was filmed for TROS was Rey giving her last bit of life to Kylo and he was the one who was at Tattooine at the end saying “Ben. Ben Skywalker”

If you switch to that and don’t change a single other thing about the movie makes it much better than what we got. It would also set the franchise up moving forward - decades or more later in the timeline.

But no, because, Kathleen Kennedy.
Posted by hashtag
Comfy, AF
Member since Aug 2005
27477 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 7:04 pm to
Well, based on what JJ did with the Force Awakens, I can only imagine that Episode 8 would have been called the First Order Strikes back. And, the plot would've basically been identical to the Empire Strikes Back.
Posted by Scoob
Near Exxon
Member since Jun 2009
20373 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 9:31 pm to
You know what, don't blame Rian, blame Kathleen Kennedy and the other top folks at Lucas/Disney.

Rian did what probably 2/3 of people on this board would do, in that situation. Maybe not in actual storyline, but seriously: consider how amazed he had to have been.

Lucasfilm: Here, Rian, you have complete control of this film, go make it.
Rian: Ok, thanks. How's it all going to end?
Lucasfilm: We don't know
Rian (winking): oh I get it, no leaks, don't tell even me. Fine. Who should I not kill? Snoke, obviously...
Lucasfilm: don't kill Rey or Kylo. Or Leia. You can do anything else you want.
Rian (a little confused): and Luke, of course.
Lucasfilm: no, do whatever with him too, he's not important
Rian: but... this is Star Wars. I'm not a huge fan, and even I know Luke is the hero.
Lucasfilm: not anymore he's not. We're "progressing" from that. Just set it up so that Rey wins, you can do anything else you want.
Rian (thinking you've got to be fricking kidding, you spent 4 billion to get the rights to this, you're spending over 300 million to make each movie, and you don't have the slightest clue where you're going): Ok, ... I'll make you a movie you won't forget (you stupid fricks)
Posted by arcalades
USA
Member since Feb 2014
19276 posts
Posted on 1/31/20 at 11:42 pm to
a better discussion would be without Kathleen.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram