re: Black mirror season 4 SPOILERS thread that NOBODY asked for

quote:

---

That's sort of the feeling I got from it as well. The whole point was that they were on a mission for a teddy bear(s). I didn't get the whole "counting to one thousand and throwing rocks at the robot dog" thing. I may have missed it though...was that something that was mentioned? What made the dog hibernate (or battery die??). I also would've liked to have gotten SOME kind of look into the people (city?) she was talking to, just to get a feel of what life was like there in this dystopia. But all in all, not a bad episode really.

---

I believe that that was her way of rationing her candy and keeping herself awake so she didn't fall out of the tree. Of course, she could have just used pieces of bark if she was worried about running out of candy.

ETA: And yes, she was trying to continually force it to wake up to use its battery.

quote:

---

Crocodile. Thought this one was kinda stupid, and I kinda hated it.

---

quote:

---

Metalhead. This episode was decent.

---

Man I just don't understand this at all. I thought metalhead was an absolute waste of my time and would go in the bottom tier rung of BM episodes that I have zero desire whatsoever to see again. It was pointless. I posted a bit more about it either earlier ITT or the other BM S4 thread but why do we give the slightest frick about these people? We know nothign about them, their backstory, who they are, anything about the world they're in. The only thing to "root" for is the lady living, because we're humans after all, but other than that so what?

Crocodile on the other hand was riveting. Some people may not like the ending and think it's a copout or whatever, but the whole episode was a slow paced trainwreck that you felt coming on but had to keep going. It was one of my favorites of this season and would probably put it in an upper tier (not top tier, but upper) of all BM episodes.

quote:

---

Crocodile on the other hand was riveting. Some people may not like the ending and think it's a copout or whatever, but the whole episode was a slow paced trainwreck that you felt coming on but had to keep going. It was one of my favorites of this season and would probably put it in an upper tier (not top tier, but upper) of all BM episodes.

---

This. Crocodile was a serious slow burn, that kept getting better the more I thought about it.

I posted my gripes about metalhead on page 7, and it's mainly waht you said. It's like the writers started iwth an idea "hey let's have some killer badass robot dogs" and that's all they had. Then just sloppily threw together the rest of the story (not that there was much of one). It was lazy writing that did nothing to draw the viewer in.

quote:

---

That's great and all, but they're still in teh game trapped right? Granted they aren't "controlled" by anyone and have free will to travel around and explore and talk to people and all that, but they're still friggin trapped for eternity right?

---

I'd rather be trapped there than trapped on earth

quote:

---

As for Metalhead and the throwing rocks thing. I guess I can buy that it was to drain the battery, but I didn't get the whole "count backwards from a thousand" thing. And did she count from one fewer each time, or am I making that up?

---

Yea she was definitely trying to drain the battery but I have no idea why she counted from 1000 each time. Why not throw another rock down just after it crouched back down? And how can it run miles and miles over mountains and not run out of battery but not be able to handle having to "wake up" throughout the night?

And where did she get rocks up in a tree? Might have been obvious in the episode but I can't remember.

And I think she counted from 1000 each time. They just skipped to the next rock throw a little quicker each time.

quote:

---

why didn't the dog shoot her in the tree?

---

his gun arm was the one that was detached

quote:

---

They made it seem like the limbs could be detached with little force

---

ehh i dont think so. it got crushed from a vehicle falling off a cliff, i dont think she could've pried off parts with a log or something

quote:

---

Why TF were the stuffed bears so important that a dog was guarding them. Why TF were the worth dying for? I know she was getting them for her kid, but come teh frick on. Food or medicine I understand and is what I'm sure most people assumed she was going for, but a teddy bear? If these dogs were as prevalent as they made them out to be, why weren't they better prepared? Robots that don't have the cognitive abilities of humans should be a cake walk, especially if you've had dealings with them in the past as they made it seem to be.

---

most of these are valid concerns and im 99% sure that these things were discussed by Brooker and Co. when writing. why did they have to track the bears to a warehouse instead of stealing one from an old department store? how did the 3 humans survive so long despite being so incompetent? why even have a gate on your compound if the dogs can just walk up and open it? lots of odd things like that, but it didn't detract enough for me to hate it. it wasn't trying to be a mentally stimulating BM episode, it was just a cool, well-made cat and mouse game with a very scary cat

I think they museum guy said the bear was the crime. Consciousness put in inanimate objects needed at least like 5 reactions or something like that.

quote:

---

The doctor she went to told the mom to trash it. She just stored it bc she herself was addicted to the monitoring and tracking aspect so she couldn't give it up. Much like an addict that quits but keeps substance around in some hiding place "just in case"

---

It should have been confiscated and destroyed of it was shown to cause death like every other device or drug tht causes death.