Would this be a good enough schedule for BYU to make the playoffs if they go undefeated?

Yes

That's seven power 5 teams on the schedule. Of course it's good enough.

Maybe if USC goes on a tear and ends up winning their division

I would think so

5 or so teams in the SEC would go undefeated against that schedule. It’s a good crappy schedule. If BYU dominates against everyone and the metrics and eye test say they are definitely a top 4 team then sure let them in. They are 3-0 right now but haven’t dominated.

honestly it depends. Is it good enough...yes, but alot is going to depend on what oregon does and who wins the big 10.

Lets say USC or one of the other schools in the pac 12 on the list win the conference and have a loss to BYU...they are in.

but honestly lets say the following happens

bama and uga meet undefeated in sec champ game. Its a close game. Both prolly get in.

Ohio State doesnt lose anther game or Michigan goes undefeated( ) or penn state does

then clemson runs through the weak acc

cinci goes undefeated

byu goes undefeated

oregon goes undefeated


who gets it? wont be BYU, no matter what. so like i said, unfortunately they do not control their own destiny.

Why not? Look at Bama's rent-a-wins.

Mercer
Southern Miss
New Mexico State

Miami (ahem)

i dont think so. no signature wins. no conference championship

Yes

95% chance my daughter attends BYU - great on campus vibe and one of the best looking student bodies in America

The committee will come up with all kinds of excuses to deny them if they finish undefeated even though they'd be fine putting USC, OU, or Texas in w/the exact same schedule.