Question about the opening scene in Inglorious Basterds..

Landa being an evil, jew hating Nazi, I'd say they probably wiped the family out for hiding Jews from them.

Doubt he kept his word.

I always assumed he let them live.

Landa was evil, but by his own admission he took his role very much as a "job" and the job was done, albeit except for Shoshanna.

I always wondered if he recognized her in the restaurant later on.

Such a damn good movie.

I've always imagined that he let them live.

I get that he's very sadistic and could easily have killed them but I also see him as someone that you might could take him on his word. If you're on his side.

You can throw in Call for Tommy Lee Jones while you're at it.

quote:

---

I always wondered if he recognized her in the restaurant later on.

---

I've heard people wonder about this but I think this one is pretty clear he didn't. That's part of the suspense/tension of the scene but I don't think he lets things go on nearly as long as they do with her if he did. Definitely never would have allowed Hitler to enter into her theatre.

quote:

---

Such a damn good movie.

---

For sure.

quote:

---

Him drinking the milk in that scene is what has always stuck with me.

---

I've wondered if that is a nod to Anton Chigurh and his drinking milk scene 2 years before in No Country. Not exactly the same but it says something similar about the two and I can see Tarantino putting it in for that reason.

I think he enjoyed the reputation he had and I think he let them live to share how savagely the killed the jews. He was happy that the farmer had heard of him.

I don't think he loved the Nazis, I think he enjoyed the thrill of the chase. That's why he was almost excited when Shosanna got away. He didn't even try to shoot her or have his men shoot at her because he wanted to continue looking.

German military officers had a very strong sense of tradition and honor that dated way back. obviously this "honor" got very twisted and perverted once the racial stuff from the Nazis was introduced to it, but it still hung on, in a way, throughout the second world war. it's the same reason that the war fought in the west was much less nasty than the war in the east.

LaPadite was caught lying, but he also sort of "came clean", he was adhering to his own moral standards (and Landa would have respected that), and he wasnt of a lesser racial stock (Jewish, slav, etc). I think Landa would have probably spared him.

that's my hot take based on applying history to a fairy tale.

quote:

---

Landa being an evil, jew hating Nazi, I'd say they probably wiped the family out for hiding Jews from them.

---

I don’t know how much of a believer in the Nazi ideology Landa actually is. Landa is partially based on Reinhard Heydrich, who Landa himself mentions in this scene. Heydrich himself didn’t really believe in Nazism and was more just a depraved sadist who Hitler let go nuts on the people of Europe to spread fear.

But Landa is the type of person who enjoys the hunt more than the kill. He likes seeing people squirm and being powerless to stop him. I do think that Landa is telling LaPatite the truth that he likes the nickname the Jew Hunter and is lying to the Basterds that he reviles it.