BilJ

quote:

---

The Carr signing was always a fair signing. It was and still is.

---

The signing never made sense for our roster…this is not hindsight, so continuing to say “well compared to the market it was fair” and ignore situation entirely.

Adding a career mediocre QB to an aging roster with limited cap space was stupid. The injuries have made the signing look worse but it was a bad signing to begin with. You can use the injury excuse as to why we didn’t meet the most modest of expectations, but the signing will always be an L for this FO

quote:

---

Have to hand it to Mickey and Jeff, in a lot of ways this was the perfect draft. Of course much depends on Shough, but you raised the floor at literally every position (except WR).

---

I mean when you have holes at every position, if you don’t leave a draft improving depth that’s a problem. Mickey and Jeff should answer why the roster is so bad going into the draft

You really haven’t made a point because you haven’t proven he’s significantly elevated the play of any of the QBs you mentioned

quote:

---

Brees was already developed.

---

But you gave Moore credit for guys he had wayyyyyy less to do with their development than SP vaulting Brees into HOF level play. You don’t see the problem with that ?

Moore hasn’t proven he’s capable of doing it yet, especially as the head man, so putting more trust in him over a guy that has actually done it at multiple stops is bold. It’s ok to believe he can be better but your reasoning seems pretty flawed

quote:

---

Moore was a high level college QB this century. He was in the NFL less than a decade ago. He has been involved with either developing or taking to the next level 3 very good young QBs recently.

Payton is an elite offensive mind and an actual great HC. But he’s developed 1 QB: Bo Nix

---

Ok so let me get this straight, you have one guy that has developed two but you trust a guy that hasn’t done it once yet…more?

You’re going to credit him for guys he had no real hand in drafting or developing but none for Payton and taking Brees to HOF level play?

Thats interesting logic

quote:

---

actually probably trust Moore with QBs than Payton

---

.

Gonna need you to expand on that.

In the late Brees era, maybe you could sell this pick as future development and expensive insurance for a guy that’s had a run of injuries. Plus we had Payton, so I’d trust his qb eye a little more, Kellen doesn’t have the skins on the wall to blindly “trust the process” (really any skins on the wall in that dept)

For this team’s current state, it doesn’t really make sense to use that pick on a dart throw vs. getting a starter to fill one of many holes. Even if he becomes a serviceable back up, he’s probably done little on the field for you.

quote:

---

The actual truth is we really don’t know. T

---

While true, the data shows this was likely a wasted pick.

I would have preferred us to do what the Browns did…ignore this QB class and fill holes.

I genuinely hope I’m wrong, we drafted an outlier, and he balls for us….but he’ll likely end up as the bridge qb we hopefully take in the top 3 next year

I don’t think this proves it was a good pick

Anyway, Milroe gets on the field even if he’s a terrible qb. If Slough busts, he’s off the roster in 2 years

:lol: still can’t defend any of his stances, just throws something completely irrelevant out there

Remember when you thought taysom hill was going to be the long term answer at qb? Seriously, has your fat arse ever been right about anything Chad?