NYC trip in May. Recommendations?

If you want to go to a Yankee game don’t worry about it taking too much time. We went to one during the last year of the old Yankee Stadium while the new stadium was being built across the street. We took the subway from Manhattan and it drops you off right by the stadium. It was a night game but we had late dinner reservations and left before the game was over.

The subway to the Yankee game was not that bad even though it passes through Harlem. I was comforted by the fact that half the people in there were wearing Yankees gear and it was obvious they were going to the game.

Go to Serendipity III, even if its for a quick dessert. Very eclectic place and famous for Frozen Hot Chocolate.

Yankees game is good to check off the list. Subway ride is long but not a deal breaker.

Visit Grand Central Station. Go see the Flatiron Building.

Walk through Times Square, get a slice of Jr.'s Cheesecake.

We spent some time in SoHo last time I was there and enjoyed it more than TS, but TS is a must on your first trip.

Ride the subway everywhere. Anyone saying don't ride it has never left Louisiana. Keep your wallet close and enjoy yourself. It is a great city

I always recommend New York in One Day Guided Sightseeing Tour (not the hop on-off crap they tout in Times Square). $89 per adult gets you a professionally guided tour on a small bus w about 20 folks. Has over 1,000 5 star reviews on TripAdvisor. You see all the major highlights of Manhattan, quick stops at several, and get a boat ride to see the Statue of Liberty. Lasts from about 10 to 4, with a stop for lunch.

My first visit was for over a week. Started day 1 with this tour, and it helped check off some things in an efficient manner and helped me get the lay of the land for individual exploring. You will never make it to all the tour spots in two days on your own.

That sounds like a great idea, will definitely look into the guided tour since its not taking up that much time.

I used the subway plenty the last time I was there. I do understand that crime is an issue, but come on. Hundreds of thousands of people use it every day.

I appreciate that you’re looking out for posters, particularly those not familiar with the city, because thats what this board is for . I suppose my argument is that “do not use the subway” is a bit extremist. Is there a risk? Of course. But you’re far more likely to have a quick drop off to your destination than being attacked.

quote:

---

Every time I turn on the NYC news up here

---

That is your first issue.

The train is fine, just be aware of your surroundings as you always should be. Use google maps and click the bus/train and it will give you exact stops and when you need to switch trains.

Trying to take a cab or Uber during prime traffic hours will take 2-3 times longer.

That is my attitude about the subway in New York. I take them regularly but I am always cognizant of my surroundings and keep my head on a swivel.

Others here will be better with standard tourist recommendations. Since it's your first time in the city, I doubt you'll go, but let me know if you're planning on Brooklyn. Dad and sister live there, so I've gotten to know it well (Williamsburg, specifically).

I don't spend too much time in Manhattan, but I have a couple cousins in West Village, so that's where I hang mostly. In the neighborhood, Blind Tiger is a great craft beer bar, LB is my favorite cocktail bar, Joseph Leonard is my favorite restaurant, and John's is my favorite pizza (think many agree). Speaking of pizza, I maintain the most-underrated slice in Manhattan is NY Pizza Suprema. It's on the SW side of MSG / Penn Station, so it's easy to miss, but I try going for a slice whenever I fly into EWR.

Regarding the Subway conversation, I'd approach it like any other big city - just be aware of your surroundings. Personally, I've never felt unsafe on the MTA, but I tend to stick to the Subway during daylight and prime dinner hours.