Started By
Message

OSHA mandate shouldn't survive judicial review

Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:15 am
Posted by Thundercles
Mars
Member since Sep 2010
5080 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:15 am
Granted, who can trust the courts anymore. But I did a lot of searching and finally found someone who was able to break down the merits of why it won't last. The whole article is a really good read.

Congress didn't give OSHA authority to mandate vaccines

quote:

Congress did not place vaccines within OSHA’s purview. OSHA is establishing the vaccine mandate through an “emergency temporary standard.” This highly unusual process allows OSHA to bypass public notice and comment. Federal agencies, including OSHA, typically must submit major rules to public scrutiny before finalizing them.

Congress tasked the Department of Health and Human Services with determining the safety, efficacy, and appropriate use of vaccines. Congress authorized the Food and Drug Administration to determine whether vaccines should be allowed in interstate commerce. It empowered the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to recommend who should receive such vaccines.

Congress did not give HHS the authority to impose a general vaccine mandate. While HHS has regulatory jurisdiction over vaccines, it has no power to impose a general vaccine mandate. If it had, the president would have directed HHS to tell employers to require their workforces to be immunized.

quote:

If Congress had authorized a mandate, it would not have encrypted it and concealed it in an obscure subsection of the OSHA statute. Congress does not, as then-Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia wrote, “hide elephants in mouseholes.”

In charging ahead with a legally dubious mandate, the Biden administration is repeating a familiar pattern. Last summer, the CDC renewed an eviction moratorium that faced certain judicial doom. The agency nevertheless issued the moratorium on Aug. 3. The high court enjoined it on Aug. 26.


It's also explained that the Supreme Court decision in 1905 in favor of vaccine mandates supports the right of an individual states to mandate a vacccine and confers no authority to the federal government. Fake president Biden knows this and is simply putting these rules out to pressure companies to force it on their own while it takes a few weeks to get struck down. Dems are really turning people against them more and more.
Posted by LSU316
Rice and Easy Baby!!!
Member since Nov 2007
29311 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:19 am to
quote:

simply putting these rules out to pressure companies to force it on their own while it takes a few weeks to get struck down.


This I believe is 100% true.

However, if the USSC takes this case and strikes down the OSHA rule saying that it will take an act of Congress to mandate the vaccines....how fast do you think Congress would have that bill passed? There are people on both sides of the isle that want it. There is no doubt it would pass in the House. The Senate would be more tricky but I think it would get done.
Posted by cajunangelle
Member since Oct 2012
147054 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:19 am to
by the time any of this comes out in the MSM news; we will be well into the great reset and nobody will GAF---- it will be so over it will be like regular everyday living.
Posted by Aubie Spr96
lolwut?
Member since Dec 2009
41170 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:22 am to
If I had a dollar for every unConstitutional thing this gov't has done since 9/11.......
Posted by ICyou21
Member since Sep 2021
113 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:22 am to
OSHA standard can get more shots in arms, the economic and public health benefits that could be gained today are worth the risk of a judicial defeat later.

What a joke
Posted by Thundercles
Mars
Member since Sep 2010
5080 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:22 am to
I truly don't think it has the Congressional support. I haven't heard a peep about it. I believe if they thought they could do it, they would have and instead cooked up this hail mary.

It seems like it would be unpopular enough in enough districts to become a huge issue for congressmen supporting it.
Posted by RangeRat
Member since Oct 2021
104 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:24 am to
I have zero faith in the "judicial" system. There are volumes of things that gov does that SHOULDN'T be allowed but happens anyway
This post was edited on 11/1/21 at 11:25 am
Posted by Taxing Authority
Houston
Member since Feb 2010
57357 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:39 am to
quote:

OSHA mandate shouldn't survive judicial review

Neither should have Obamacare.
Posted by Pettifogger
Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone
Member since Feb 2012
79262 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:41 am to
quote:

It's also explained that the Supreme Court decision in 1905 in favor of vaccine mandates supports the right of an individual states to mandate a vacccine and confers no authority to the federal government. Fake president Biden knows this and is simply putting these rules out to pressure companies to force it on their own while it takes a few weeks to get struck down. Dems are really turning people against them more and more.



Well, not only is he pressuring, he's providing cover for companies that want to do this but are scared of the employee/public backlash.

Posted by sms151t
Polos, Porsches, Ponies..PROBATION
Member since Aug 2009
139851 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:41 am to
I do not have issue with a mandate if the company itself sets it. That is just simply a term of employment and policy and procedure. I do have a huge issue if the government issues it, as that violates a civil right and segregates people from the governmental level. I guess to me it would be like Apartheid.
This post was edited on 11/1/21 at 11:43 am
Posted by keakar
Member since Jan 2017
30082 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:42 am to
quote:

I have zero faith in the "judicial" system. There are volumes of things that gov does that SHOULDN'T be allowed but happens anyway



this ^^^^^^^

if anyone thinks SCOTUS cares or intends to follow the rule of law or the constitution they are beyond naïve.

SCOTUS will rubber stamp every unconstitutional action this government wants to do
Posted by xxTIMMYxx
Member since Aug 2019
17562 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:43 am to
I started a thread on the OT about starting to protect yourselves from this nonsense
Posted by Thundercles
Mars
Member since Sep 2010
5080 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:45 am to
quote:

I do not have issue with a mandate if the company itself sets it.


I agree with you. I believe companies should have the right to do so. It is disgusting to me that the government is threatening companies with practical bankruptcy unless they comply.
Posted by xxTIMMYxx
Member since Aug 2019
17562 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:46 am to
quote:

I do not have issue with a mandate if the company itself sets it. That is just simply a term of employment and policy and procedure. I do have a huge issue if the government issues it, as that violates a civil right and segregates people from the governmental level. I guess to me it would be like Apartheid.


JC. The government is behind all of this. They are blackmailing companies with fines and low esg scores. This is no different than the government getting big tech to censor people. They are subverting the constitution
Posted by FooManChoo
Member since Dec 2012
41712 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:46 am to
quote:

I truly don't think it has the Congressional support. I haven't heard a peep about it. I believe if they thought they could do it, they would have and instead cooked up this hail mary.
This.

Democrats love to break or change rules to get what they want, but they are also happy to avoid negative press and use the current rules to get what they want when they know they will get it. They know it's a loser going through Congress, which is why Biden is forcing it through a regulatory agency.
Posted by teke184
Zachary, LA
Member since Jan 2007
96059 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:47 am to
They want the Constitution to go away.

And if that happens, they will find that the number of people willing to fight them and fight dirty will go up significantly.
Posted by sms151t
Polos, Porsches, Ponies..PROBATION
Member since Aug 2009
139851 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 11:47 am to
Do you believe that a company has the right to run its business in the way it seems fit?

You do not have to work for that company or use the service it provides.


With the government forcing it, there is no option.
Posted by Pezzo
Member since Aug 2020
1966 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 12:35 pm to
its going to get ugly no matter the case
Posted by BFIV
Virginia
Member since Apr 2012
7740 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 12:46 pm to
quote:

I truly don't think it has the Congressional support.


That's probably because Congress doesn't want to be forced to get the jab, either. Rules for thee, but not for me.
Posted by Wtodd
Tampa, FL
Member since Oct 2013
67493 posts
Posted on 11/1/21 at 12:53 pm to
quote:

OSHA mandate shouldn't survive judicial review

It shouldn't survive spellcheck
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram