re: Medicine Isn't A Science. Practice of the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of disease

quote:

---

I want people to just look at the way this doctor is acting. Just ignoring the simple question. Stalking me. Look at his post history and me going for pages ignoring him. Look at how I clearly explain to him ...

---

Chrome is giving me a little trouble posting links for some reason.

Gags references the 2 studies he posted as proof that germ theory did not exist here. LINK

After making fun of him for a bit, further down the page I post the links to the studies again and elucidate further as to how they are in fact the same study. I also post the source from which the second link gets its anecdote. Further down that page, I post five screenshots from a book about the influenza pandemic of 1918, including this last screenshot, which provides the exact type of evidence that gags is after.



Not surprisingly, he doesn't address it directly, and tries to slyly change the subject with the last post on page 8, and then does it directly with later posts. On page 10 he does more hamstering, while also ignoring the entirety of what he said before. There are other links I can provide upon request, as long as Chrome allows me.

quote:

---

Post the Rosenau links you little bitch. Do it again, for old times sake.

---

Is this it?

It's like all the worst things I say keep getting confirmed by you, as I say them to you and you respond. It's a really terrible display by whatever supposed medical experts. In case we needed more confirmation

Are you saying microbes do not cause disease?

Or, are you saying disease producing microbes are not spread through the air?

quote:

---

Are you saying microbes do not cause disease?

---

I'm saying there is no scientific reason whatsoever to believe microbe causing diseases are spread through air and saliva by humans. All common sense says this would be a very simple experiment done thousands of times and it does not exist. I keep repeating this over and over and over and it hasn't changed. I've looked for them. I've demanded them. But they are interested in other things.

quote:

---

What it did was disprove bacterial theory and then brought up a new explanation which itself can't be proved.

---

Well you seem to be operating on the assumption that science can 'prove or disprove' ideas, which isn't the exact way things work. You build arguments based on both supporting evidence and refuting evidence to make larger claims about the mechanisms by which natural phenomena occur. You seem to struggle with the 'building arguments' portion of science, as you can't maintain a consistent context at all.

quote:

---

is more interested in trying to make me look ridiculous

---

You do a wonderful job of that without my help.

Tldr no proof. I'm talking to someone else now who perhaps has a shred of decency

quote:

---

no the reason you have to believe it is because it's taught from childhood,

---

No, idiot. I’m an engineer. I have to believe physics in order to make things that work.