Started By
Message

re: Concealed Carry Weapon

Posted on 3/20/17 at 9:20 pm to
Posted by dawg23
Baton Rouge, La
Member since Jul 2011
5065 posts
Posted on 3/20/17 at 9:20 pm to
quote:


Also 100x more comfortable carrying the 43.
I've decided there's a whole generation that is fixated on comfort.

The following isn't aimed (npi) at any one poster:

Comfort isn't (shouldn't be) the primary criterion in selecting a CCW piece. Reliability (goes pew pew every time), shootability (you can get accurate hits at a fairly fast cadence), and capacity (just in case you run into one of BR's 36 street gangs and need more than 7-8 shots) should take precedence over something poking into your skin.

I get the whole "I'm better off carrying a mouse gun than no gun at all" stuff. But that's a silly non-binary choice. You're also better off carrying a "normal size" gun.

J-frames, Shields, and G42/43 make excellent BUGS. Heck, IDPA's new BUG division includes the G19. Anybody can conceal a G19 or M&P compact with a modicum of adaptation to one's wardrobe. I carry a G19 all day, every day.

Tom Givens told us "Don't go looking for trouble unless you're prepared to find it." Not that anyone here is "looking for trouble," but if trouble finds you, you're gonna wish you had more ammo than what a Shield or G43 can hold.

I presume that everyone knows that the average hit rate for cops in gun fights is ~20%. If you're as well trained as the average cop (Federal, state, local, etc.) you're only gonna hit with two shots out of that Shield or G43.

If you can make every shot hit a vital organ in a lethal encounter, I assume that (a) your name is Miculek and (b) you;ll do just fine with a mouse gun.
Posted by ForeverLSU02
Albany
Member since Jun 2007
52147 posts
Posted on 3/20/17 at 9:44 pm to
I've got a compact 45 XDS that I may want to unload if you're interested. Less than 50 rds through it
Posted by Timmayy
Houston
Member since Mar 2016
1592 posts
Posted on 3/20/17 at 9:53 pm to
Yes this is true and I also carry a glock 19. But I also recognize that I am a 1 percenter. The other 99% will not carry, no matter how much we try to tell them to, a full size gun. And it is 100% because they don't believe it is comfortable compared to a single stack. So as long as the person already owns the fullsize gun I do not try to dissuade the person from buying a smaller single stack that they are much more likely to carry. Continually telling them I carry a fullsize gun everyday converts very few people. I do have a minimum that I recommend to people and that's stops right at the 43 and the shield.
Posted by DownshiftAndFloorIt
Here
Member since Jan 2011
66763 posts
Posted on 3/20/17 at 10:41 pm to
The only guns I own that could even be considered as self defense guns are an M9 and a 3" GP100. I'm quite sure I could conceal and carry either one comfortably, but I wear jeans every day and I've lost weight recently so all my clothes are a little big.

I had a shield for a while and that thing is TINY. I think I could carry that thing in athletic shorts.
Posted by Timmayy
Houston
Member since Mar 2016
1592 posts
Posted on 3/20/17 at 10:51 pm to
2.6 pounds for a fully loaded M9 I'm not so sure of the comfort level there. Not saying you can't but I definitely wouldn't want to.
Posted by RoIITide
Member since Dec 2010
852 posts
Posted on 3/20/17 at 11:30 pm to
quote:

I've decided there's a whole generation that is fixated on comfort. 


This is true for me.

I prefer iwb and started with a Sig P250 compact (almost identical to G19 dimensions)...Too bulky and heavy for me.

Next up Ruger lcp.. now surely this would be perfect? Nope, never warmed up to it. I don't shoot it well and it doesn't fit my hand but I knew it wasn't a range gun when I bought it. (but it's a dang good gun that I'll always keep).

So finally tried the Shield that everyone raves about and Bingo. Perfect for me. Very accurate, reliable but most importantly, not uncomfortable to wear. If I ever feel like capacity is an issue, I'll carry the extra mag that came with it. That said, I'd never argue that 8 rounds is better than 18.

No matter what the op winds up going with, odds are he'll get the itch to try something different anyway (different guns, holsters, ammo, etc, etc.) It's all part of finding out what works best for him.

I totally understand your point and I'm not taking issue with it (I'm not one of the downvotes btw)..It's just a compromise that I'm comfortable with.

Just my $.02.
Posted by bapple
Capital City
Member since Oct 2010
11884 posts
Posted on 3/21/17 at 7:27 am to
quote:

Yes this is true and I also carry a glock 19. But I also recognize that I am a 1 percenter. The other 99% will not carry, no matter how much we try to tell them to, a full size gun


Nailed it.

I'm also of the opinion that the 43/Shield/XDs/CM9/PPS are about the minimum in size I'm willing to recommend.
Posted by LSU12223
Member since Sep 2016
1482 posts
Posted on 3/21/17 at 7:33 am to
quote:

Comfort isn't (shouldn't be) the primary criterion in selecting a CCW piece. Reliability

I thought it was kinda understood that the glock would be a pretty reliable gun. You're right reliability should be number one, but if we are talking about blocks as a concealed carried gun, then it's understood that it's reliable didn't realize I actually had to say that...
Posted by bapple
Capital City
Member since Oct 2010
11884 posts
Posted on 3/21/17 at 8:06 am to
Pretty much all the quality single stack guns from well-known manufacturers will be reliable. I think the proven leaders in the segment are the Shield, Glock 43, and XDs. Just shoot the fire out of it when you buy it to check function and then carry confidently, as you would with any carry piece.
Posted by dawg23
Baton Rouge, La
Member since Jul 2011
5065 posts
Posted on 3/21/17 at 8:20 am to
As I said in my post -- my comments wasn't aimed at any one poster (you or anyone else) on this board. They were comments based on posts in a lot of recent threads.
Posted by Cadello
Eunice
Member since Dec 2007
47795 posts
Posted on 3/21/17 at 4:49 pm to
I'd assume if I have to pull my gun, it will be a close encounter.
I own many semis and revolvers. If it's a dangerous situation and I know ahead of time, I'm packing my Colt .45
Zombie Apocalypse: 2 Baretta M-9's with many mags.
If it's just me carrying to carry. It's my Ruger LCR. It's small, fits unnoticed in my front pocket, comfortable and packs a punch.
You carry what you are comfortable shooting and what you can pull and shoot quickly.
Sometimes a second can mean the difference between life and death.
Posted by dawg23
Baton Rouge, La
Member since Jul 2011
5065 posts
Posted on 3/21/17 at 5:17 pm to
quote:

If it's a dangerous situation and I know ahead of time, I'm packing my Colt .45
If I know ahead of time, I just don't go.


Hopefully none of us will ever have to pull a gun.
Posted by Cadello
Eunice
Member since Dec 2007
47795 posts
Posted on 3/23/17 at 10:37 am to
If there's a situation involving family members and they need me ASAP, I'm going.
Posted by SCwTiger
armpit of 'merica
Member since Aug 2014
5857 posts
Posted on 3/23/17 at 11:13 am to
I recently traded a cheap guitar for a Ruger LCP 380. The simplicity of that thing is impressive. Always wondered why people don't like safeties, but now I understand. Trigger pull is pretty hard, I guess because of the double action, but it's easy to shoot when you intend to, and pretty accurate. I only shot it at 15 yards, but if someone's further than that from me, I probably wont be shooting at them.

BTW, I don't cc.
Posted by Easternrio
Member since May 2014
3755 posts
Posted on 3/23/17 at 11:21 am to
I carry Glock 19 appendix every day
Posted by TigerOnThe Hill
Springhill, LA
Member since Sep 2008
6811 posts
Posted on 3/23/17 at 3:39 pm to
quote:

Holy shite this thread is all over the place.
1+

quote:

M&P Shield, Glock 43, Walther PPS M2, Springfield XDs (if you're set on single stack)

Solid recs. I'd add the Kahr CW series for consideration, as well. The trigger has a true DAO feel to it as opposed to a striker mechanism. Nevertheless, the CW series are good guns. The CM9/PM9 are good choices if one's looking for a slightly smaller version, especially for pocket carry. I'll be introducing a CM9 soon to my cc rotation. I'll let the OB know more about the gun as soon as the leather gets here.
Posted by bapple
Capital City
Member since Oct 2010
11884 posts
Posted on 3/23/17 at 3:42 pm to
quote:

I'll be introducing a CM9 soon to my cc rotation.


Love mine. The damn thing just doesn't stop working.
Posted by bbvdd
Memphis, TN
Member since Jun 2009
24966 posts
Posted on 3/23/17 at 3:46 pm to
I've recently bought a G29 with a Galco king tuk and it's extremely comfortable to carry.

I also have a shield and a commander size 1911 that I carry. Well, sometimes I'll carry my Delta Elite as well.

All are IWB.

And no offense Dawg, most (not all mind you) police officers don't have great training. Well, let me rephrase. They have good training, but they don't practice. Most shoot enough simply to be able to pass their requirements.
Posted by sowega dawg
Member since May 2011
3935 posts
Posted on 3/23/17 at 3:58 pm to
I've been shopping around for a new cc recently and was going back and forth between a few firearms.
I didn't realize until yesterday Smith and wesson now make a FDE Shield in 9mm.
That will definitely be my next purchase.

Posted by dawg23
Baton Rouge, La
Member since Jul 2011
5065 posts
Posted on 3/23/17 at 4:54 pm to
quote:

And no offense Dawg, most (not all mind you) police officers don't have great training. Well, let me rephrase. They have good training, but they don't practice. Most shoot enough simply to be able to pass their requirements.
I agree -- most don't practice.

But the bigger issue is that virtually no one shoots as well under the stress of a lethal engagement as they do at their local gun range. Unfortunately (sometimes tragically) people overestimate what their skill level is, and what it's likely to be, under stress. (Google "Dunning-Kruger effect -- people tend to overestimate their skill level -- everybody thinks they're above average."

Cops don't miss 80% of their shots at qualification time. If they did, they'd never qualify. But they (on average) miss 80% in gunfights because people are shooting at them.

I only mentioned this phenomenon in my earlier post to point out that 6-7 rounds in a pistol is actually a pretty small number based on the FBI's annual Uniform Crime Report. According to the most recent report, as well as the 10 previous annual reports, ON AVERAGE (a) it will take more than one pistol round to incapacitate an attacker, and (b) there will be more than one attacker.

We've all read or heard about people running away as soon a a gun is fired (or as soon as a shotgun is racked), but if the attacker is under the influence of certain drugs, or is mentally ill, or belongs to a street gang, etc., etc. he may not stop until you render him/her incapable of continuing the attack. If we start with a 5-shot revolver and miss 80%, we're really in trouble if more than one the dude is trying to kill you.

I realize some people on this board practice more than, and shoot better than, the "average cop." But we all need to guard against overconfidence. (I forget who first said, "Confidence is good, but overconfidence will get you killed.

I shoot 600-700 rounds/week thru my CCW pistol to hopefully reach and/or maintain a skill level where I can survive an attack even if I were to lose the majority of my skill due to stress. I can guarantee you that I'm not one of the overconfident people (anyone who has seen me shoot can probably verify that I have no reason to be overconfident ).
first pageprev pagePage 3 of 4Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram