Settle a debate: which is nerdier, WoW or Magic the Gathering?

Magic is without a doubt more nerdy. Period.

quote:

---

MorbidTheClown

---

Pssh youre definitely an Alliance Human Warrior build guy

no idea what either of those are.

Thank goodness.

So, my answer is both.

Normal chicks will play D&D but no estrogen is really that into Magic the Gathering or WoW. At least D&D gives a squire a shot at improv and getting laid. Never seen that from the latter.....

All the kids online say Magic is just Boomer Yu-Gi-Oh anyways.

There's no wood worth laying in that grove, baw.

Looks like some of the "talent" of the upper midwest.

Card games, P&P, and tabletops are infinitely nerdier than MMOs. Not that there's anything wrong with nerdy interests at all.

I will say Magic the Gathering is more nerdy. I've never played it though.

I've played WoW for years. I luckily have only been friends with pretty normal people on there. I have certainly come across some nerdy people who pretty much live in the game though. That's scary and depressing to me.

When I first started playing, one of our guildies was a mid 20s guy. His problem was he put the game before his life. He was pretty poor I think. He would sell motorcycle parts to pay for his subscription. Parts of his bike that he actually used for transportation, and he was no longer able to ride said motorcycle. Dude had serious issues.

Nerds are fine. People like I described above are the sad ones.

magic.

magic is better for what its worth too.

i don't know enough about either to have an opinion.

i also think there are much worse things they could be doing with their time, so they get a pass in my book.

Magic because it is done in public. At least WoW you can be a nerd in private.