re: It’s pretty much fact the earth flooded around 12,000 years ago (younger dryas)

quote:

---

ANY force related to a forming solar system that could collide and propel a planetary object into a fast orbit.

Another planet, satellite, etc as long as it is in the same vector direction as the initial orbit

---

1. A "forming" solar system is not conducive to life.

2. I don't think you quite understand the way it works. If a planet were accelerated, its orbit would not stay the same.

https://www.lewrockwell.com/2011/12/immanuel-velikovsky/the-earth-without-the-moon/

quote:

---

The Earth Without the Moon By Immanuel Velikovsky
December 3, 2011

---

quote:

---

The period when the Earth was Moonless is probably the most remote recollection of mankind. Democritus and Anaxagoras taught that there was a time when the Earth was without the Moon.(1) Aristotle wrote that Arcadia in Greece, before being inhabited by the Hellenes, had a population of Pelasgians, and that these aborigines occupied the land already before there was a moon in the sky above the Earth; for this reason they were called Proselenes.(2)

Apollonius of Rhodes mentioned the time “when not all the orbs were yet in the heavens, before the Danai and Deukalion races came into existence, and only the Arcadians lived, of whom it is said that they dwelt on mountains and fed on acorns, before there was a moon.” (3) Plutarch wrote in The Roman Questions: “There were Arcadians of Evander’s following, the so-called pre-Lunar people.”(4) Similarly wrote Ovid: “The Arcadians are said to have possessed their land before the birth of Jove, and the folk is older than the Moon.” (5) Hippolytus refers to a legend that “Arcadia brought forth Pelasgus, of greater antiquity than the moon.”(6) Lucian in his Astrology says that “the Arcadians affirm in their folly that they are older than the moon.”(7) Censorinus also alludes to the time in the past when there was no moon in the sky.(8) Some allusions to the time before there was a Moon may be found also in the Scriptures. In Job 25:5 the grandeur of the Lord who “Makes peace in the heights” is praised and the time is mentioned “before [there was] a moon and it did not shine.” Also in Psalm 72:5 it is said: “Thou wast feared since [the time of] the sun and before [the time of] the moon, a generation of generations.” A “generation of generations” means a very long time. Of course, it is of no use to counter this psalm with the myth of the first chapter of Genesis, a tale brought down from exotic and later sources.

The memory of a world without a moon lives in oral tradition among the Indians. The Indians of the Bogota highlands in the eastern Cordilleras of Colombia relate some of their tribal reminiscences to the time before there was a moon. “In the earliest times, when the moon was not yet in the heavens,” say the tribesmen of Chibchas.(9)

---

quote:

---

The variations in the position of the Moon can be read in the variations in the length of the month. The length of the month repeatedly changed in subseqent catastrophic events – and for this there exists a large amount of supporting evidence. In these later occurrences the Moon played a passive role, and Zeus in the Iliad advised it (Aphrodite) to stay out of the battle in which Athene and Ares (Venus and Mars) were the main contestants.

---

---

Https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UkPpR8t1qvk

Wal Thornhill: Blockbuster – Saturn/Earth Connection Confirmed | Space News

ThunderboltsProject Published on Dec 19, 2018 SUBSCRIBE 133K

A new scientific paper provides stunning affirmation of one of the most striking predictions of the Electric Universe/catastrophist hypothesis. The paper, published in the Journal Icarus, reports that the water on Saturn’s moons and in its rings is remarkably similar to water on our own planet, a completely unexpected finding for planetary scientists.

As surprising as this connection between Saturn and Earth is for planetary scientists, the connection was in fact explicitly predicted by one of the great scientific heretics of the 20th century. Nearly three-quarters of a century ago, Dr. Immanuel Velikovsky proposed that within human memory, a period of chaos reigned in the inner solar system. In this scenario, one of the migrating planets was Saturn, and it was Velikovsky’s seemingly outrageous thesis that the water in Earth’s oceans came from the gas giant. In part one of this two part presentation, physicist Wal Thornhill outlines the incredible and ongoing predictive success of the electric universe/catastrophist paradigm.

https://phys.org/news/2018-12-saturn-satellites-earth-moon-phoebe.html

The water in Saturn's rings and satellites is like that on Earth except for moon Phoebe, which is out of this world

December 3, 2018, Planetary Science Institute

By developing a new method for measuring isotopic ratios of water and carbon dioxide remotely, scientists have found that the water in Saturn's rings and satellites is unexpectedly like water on the Earth, except on Saturn's moon Phoebe, where the water is more unusual than on any other object so far studied in the Solar System.

The results, found in the Icarus paper "Isotopic Ratios of Saturn's Rings and Satellites: Implications for the Origin of Water and Phoebe" by Planetary Science Institute Senior Scientist Roger N. Clark, also mean *we need to change models of the formation of the Solar System because the new results are in conflict with existing models. *Robert H. Brown (U. Arizona), Dale P. Cruikshank (NASA), and Gregg A. Swayze (USGS) are co-authors.

The Saturn system D/H values close to the Earth's values imply a similar water source for the inner and outer Solar System, and new models need to be developed where the change from inner to outer Solar System is less.

---

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6fjcPguafug

quote:

---

Wal Thornhill: The Saturn/Earth Connection and Our Place in the Universe | Space News
ThunderboltsProject6,488 views 854 12
SUBSCRIBE 134K
Published on Dec 30, 2018

In part one of this presentation, physicist Wal Thornhill began his analysis of one of the most significant space discoveries in recent memory. The history and origin of the gas giant Saturn, and indeed the entire solar system, including our own planet is not what we’ve been told. Planetary scientists recently made the astonishing discovery that water in Saturn’s satellites and rings is remarkably similar to the water on Earth. As Thornhill explained, this discovery was explicitly predicted nearly three quarters of a century ago, by the scientific heretic Dr. Immanuel Velikovsky. In this episode, Thornhill outlines his own successful predictions for discoveries in the Saturnian system, including Saturn's moon Titan. Part one of this two-part presentation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UkPpR...

---

quote:

---

Planetary scientists recently made the astonishing discovery that water in Saturn’s satellites and rings is remarkably similar to the water on Earth.

---

what does this mean?!?

It is made up of hydrogen and oxygen?

Are there Dr pepper cans floating in Saturn's rings?

quote:

---

what does this mean?!?

It is made up of hydrogen and oxygen?

---

Not trying to give any credence to a crackpot but oxygen and hydrogen have a number of different isotopes.

quote:

---

1. A "forming" solar system is not conducive to life.

2. I don't think you quite understand the way it works. If a planet were accelerated, its orbit would not stay the same.

---

Your Point 1 is irrelevant

Your Point 2 doesn’t take into account changes in the mass of the SUN over time coupled with the changes of the earth’s density + possible impacts

quote:

---

Your Point 2 doesn’t take into account changes in the mass of the SUN over time coupled with the changes of the earth’s density + possible impacts

---

What. The. frick.

quote:

---

There is absolutely no evidence whatsoever of a global flood. None. Zero. Zilch.

---

quote:

---

Where did all the water come from/go?

---

Polar ice caps being hit by an explosion of creating a tidal shift

Followed by the ocean being hit by an explosion of heat leading to a global greenhouse effect melting the icecaps

that was easy

Or you know, civilizations developed around rivers, the Ice Age ended, and there were shite tons of floods. That makes more sense.

quote:

---

that was easy

---

For every problem there is a solution, clear, simple and wrong. --H. L. Mencken