Started By
Message

Section 31 is a Star Trek attempt at Modern Star Wars.

Posted on 1/25/25 at 11:20 am
Posted by Napoleon
Kenna
Member since Dec 2007
73261 posts
Posted on 1/25/25 at 11:20 am
The new Star Trek: Section 31 series, which the focus is on covert operations within the Federation, seems to stray far from the traditional Star Trek formula and veer closer to the tone and style of modern Star Wars stories. While both franchises share a science fiction foundation, the new Section 31 show aligns more with Star Wars in several key ways, especially in its focus on action, moral ambiguity, and shadowy organizations.

One of the defining features of Star Trek has always been its optimistic exploration of the future, where diplomacy, science, and reason are often prioritized over conflict. The series, especially in its classic form, is centered around the idea that humanity has evolved beyond war, prejudice, and greed. It’s a utopian vision of the future, where problems are solved through understanding and cooperation. Section 31, however, seems to emphasize a darker, grittier tone, akin to the underworld and morally gray narratives found in Star Wars stories like The Mandalorian or Rogue One. The concept of a secretive, shadowy organization working outside the official Federation mandates taps into a more cynical, anti-heroic narrative—a staple of modern Star Wars media.

Additionally, the Star Trek franchise has always emphasized intellectual engagement, prioritizing exploration and philosophical dialogue. Even in its action-heavy episodes, there was an intellectual depth that made it distinct from other sci-fi shows. Section 31, by contrast, focuses heavily on espionage, covert missions, and personal stakes, pushing it more toward action-driven narratives similar to Star Wars. Star Wars has increasingly embraced these action-focused, high-stakes missions with intense pacing, often sidelining the more reflective, philosophical elements that marked classic Star Trek.

Another shift is in the series' character development. Section 31 seems likely to center on morally complex characters who operate in the shadows, questioning their own loyalties and motivations. This contrasts with the traditional Star Trek ethos, where characters often embodied clear ideals, and conflicts were resolved through mutual understanding. The recent Star Trek series have been shifting toward more morally ambiguous figures, but Section 31 appears to take this to its extreme, much like the conflicted characters in Star Wars' underworld, such as bounty hunters or rebels.

Section 31 represents a departure from the intellectual, utopian values of classic Star Trek. It leans into the action-packed, morally ambiguous, and gritty narrative style found in modern Star Wars stories. While both franchises share a common sci-fi root, Section 31 is a more modern take that aligns more closely with the darker, action-oriented direction seen in Star Wars, highlighting the ongoing evolution of the Star Trek franchise toward a broader, more contemporary storytelling approach.



TL:DR -
A strong asian woman who is Hitler with tits tries to attone for her past by becoming a CIA space Buccaneer with a crew that contains a token black tough co lead, a waybe brady looking changling, a microscopic alien driving a Vulcan android, and some other red shirts.
It's a decent Disney Plus star wars show as it's slightly less ... bad that must star wars. But Trek fans hoping for the second coming of DS9 are left out.
Posted by TigerFanatic99
South Bend, Indiana
Member since Jan 2007
34929 posts
Posted on 1/25/25 at 11:41 am to
quote:

A strong asian woman who is Hitler with tits tries to attone for her past by becoming a CIA space Buccaneer with a crew that contains a token black tough co lead, a waybe brady looking changling, a microscopic alien driving a Vulcan android, and some other red shirts.


You had me at tits.

quote:

Section 31, by contrast, focuses heavily on espionage, covert missions, and personal stakes, pushing it more toward action-driven narratives similar to Star Wars.


I could enjoy this if they made it very mature and gritty. Think like the last few seasons of Seal Team.
Posted by drizztiger
Deal With it!
Member since Mar 2007
45152 posts
Posted on 1/25/25 at 11:43 am to
quote:

and some other red shirts
Do any of them have last names?
Posted by Froman
Baton Rouge
Member since Jun 2007
38678 posts
Posted on 1/25/25 at 12:34 pm to
That was a surprisingly good read. I didn’t know much about this show but it sounds interesting, despite not being like a typical Star Trek.
Posted by SouthEasternKaiju
SouthEast... you figure it out
Member since Aug 2021
43130 posts
Posted on 1/25/25 at 1:45 pm to
24%
Tomatometer (All Critics)
33 Reviews

20%
Popcornmeter (All Audience)
500+ Ratings


Finally. Balance in the universe.
Posted by roadGator
Member since Feb 2009
154864 posts
Posted on 1/25/25 at 1:52 pm to
Damn.
Posted by Thracken13
Aft Cargo Hold of Serenity
Member since Feb 2010
18562 posts
Posted on 1/25/25 at 7:08 pm to
was wondering if anyone had seen it - just saw it tonight.

the books about it were pretty good
Posted by CU_Tigers4life
Georgia
Member since Aug 2013
9251 posts
Posted on 1/25/25 at 7:18 pm to
This was so bad I can't review it with any fairness. Just about every review I've read online have been extremely critical. If you're a fan of traditional Star Trek which I associate with TOS-DS9 I can't imagine many people with like it.

It's like they threw a bunch of shite together and tried to make a sad version of the Guardians of the Galaxy or Suicide Squad which has been mentioned.


Section 31 was created from the DS9 series and there were designed to be so secretive that they were judge, jury and executioner designed to protect the Federation as they see fit including from themselves. This movie version is a joke.
Posted by gizmothepug
Louisiana
Member since Apr 2015
8521 posts
Posted on 1/26/25 at 12:57 am to
I was looking forward to it but I couldn’t even finish it, beyond terrible.
Posted by CAD703X
Liberty Island
Member since Jul 2008
91751 posts
Posted on 1/26/25 at 8:43 am to
quote:

It's a decent Disney Plus star wars show as it's slightly less ... bad that must star wars.
wait Disney owns the star trek ip now or did I misread this??
Posted by Seldom Seen
Member since Feb 2016
48737 posts
Posted on 1/26/25 at 9:04 am to
quote:

You had me at tits.




I didn't even make it that far he lost me at strong asian woman.
Posted by Pandy Fackler
Member since Jun 2018
21114 posts
Posted on 1/26/25 at 9:08 am to
quote:

TL:DR -
A strong asian woman who is Hitler with tits tries to attone for her past by becoming a CIA space Buccaneer with a crew that contains a token black tough co lead, a waybe brady looking changling, a microscopic alien driving a Vulcan android, and some other red shirts.
It's a decent Disney Plus star wars show as it's slightly less ... bad that must star wars. But Trek fans hoping for the second coming of DS9 are left out.


Got any pics of those tits?

Posted by Napoleon
Kenna
Member since Dec 2007
73261 posts
Posted on 1/27/25 at 2:16 pm to
No.
What i meant was How could you root for a person that killed her entire family to become emporer and then made the only person who loved he a disfigured slave? She was regarded as the most evil and bloodthirsty Terran Emporer.
What i don't get was i thought Emporer Spock reformed the Terran Empire according to DS9. why was it still required for the emporer to kill her entire family to ascend?
Posted by TheTideMustRoll
Birmingham, AL
Member since Dec 2009
10357 posts
Posted on 1/27/25 at 3:04 pm to
quote:

the new Section 31 show aligns more with Star Wars in several key ways, especially in its focus on action, moral ambiguity, and shadowy organizations.


I know when I look back at the original Star Wars trilogy, it's the moral ambiguity of the whole thing that really stands out to me.

Sigh. frick Disney.
Posted by Sam Quint
Member since Sep 2022
8061 posts
Posted on 1/27/25 at 3:28 pm to
quote:

Hitler with tits


****slowly deletes PornHub search history****
Posted by Donkus
Shreveport
Member since Feb 2013
1479 posts
Posted on 1/27/25 at 3:40 pm to
The Vulcan avatar, especially the wife version, is now my most hated character in all of Star Trek. This movie is going to join Picard season 1 & 2 into the worst properties attached to the Star Trek name. I'm still in disbelief that I watched the whole thing.
Posted by Philzilla
Member since Nov 2011
2185 posts
Posted on 1/27/25 at 5:36 pm to
This isn’t good. More Star Trek in the title than the movie.
Thank god Michelle Yeoh won an Oscar and the series was cancelled.
Posted by SouthEasternKaiju
SouthEast... you figure it out
Member since Aug 2021
43130 posts
Posted on 1/27/25 at 5:58 pm to
They've been trying to 'modernize' Star Trek since 2009.

Save for S3 of Picard, it's all been trash.

All of it.
Posted by StansberryRules
Member since Aug 2024
4543 posts
Posted on 1/27/25 at 8:48 pm to
Star Trek was historically never trying to reach a huge mega audience. It had a specific vision and appealled to a particular niche of sci fi fans.

Hollywood has been trying to turn it into a generic blockbuster scifi action franchise, which meant making it extremely loud, extremely stupid, and embarrassingly trend chasing.
Posted by SouthEasternKaiju
SouthEast... you figure it out
Member since Aug 2021
43130 posts
Posted on 1/27/25 at 9:02 pm to
Star Trek has always had its solid core of loyal fans. Problem is studios have bought into the model of dumping those loyal fans in order to try to chase a mythical, global market , or the “modern audience”. It’s a formula which is repeating over and over, to dismal results.

Doctor Who. Tolkien. The Witcher…

It’s like these studios are trying to remove what makes these franchises unique, to cater to the general population, which is having the opposite effect. The people who found and enjoyed these shows, did so organically.

Turning everything into generic sci-fi show is ruining modern entertainment..

first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram