re: LOST "The End" S6.E17&18

quote:

---

No Kwon baby

---

there was a baby in the womb, just as on the island

quote:

---

No Sayid and Nadia

---

there was no sayid and nadia on the island

quote:

---

Kate, Sawyer, etc. all appearing as they did on the island.

---

because, as christian said, it was the MOST IMPORTANT TIME OF THEIR LIVES

quote:

---

Hey hey hey, hold on now. Let's not kick a man when he's down. Dude is still in purgatory.

---

i thought i saw him peeking out of the wreckage during the credits

I think it's painfully obvious that everyone at the church would look how they look in the flash-sideways. It makes the most sense. You're not going to make anyone look older than they were in flash-sideways. Was Aaron supposed to grow from a baby that was just born into a three year old or 30 year old at the drop of a hat? The same people who are complaining that he wasn't older would be freaking out. Book it. And why would they want to show Ji Yeon if she had not even been born yet in the flash-sideways.

All much ado about nothing.

look i completely understand what you're saying. i'm going to call it the total recall angle

i think it was the same as about 95% of seasons 3-6: a bunch of shite they added just to entertain the audience

i mean the fact that we're having this argument is major proof that the writing wasn't exactly air tight

quote:

---

i thought i saw him peeking out of the wreckage during the credits

---

quote:

---

the series ended when lost flashed on the screen

---

Agreed, not to be repetitive but this is how they ended the show for Kimmel's audience. If showing the plane wreckage was important to the show I think they would have shown this to the audience.

quote:

---

Someone earlier said that Jack met Nadia. I don't remember this. I don't think Jack ever saw Nadia.

---

Technically they never spend any screen time together. That said, Sayid and her get married and are living in LA for like 10 months or something before she gets killed. I suppose it is possible that Jack never met Nadia but it just seems unlikely since I believe they attended Christian Sheppard funeral.

quote:

---

Was I the only one that thought Ben might stab Hurley and grab the bottle of water to try and steal control of the island?

---

I could so see Ben grabbing the water and taking off running.

However, when you think about it, Ben just wanted to be close to Jacob, not become Jacob. So, he got to become close to Hurley.

quote:

---

I would buy that it was Desmond's perspective before I would buy that it was Jack's. Especially when you consider Penelope was there.

---

Desmond never knew Boone or Shannon.

And Penny brings up a good point. Half the cast never knew Penny, but Jack did. Even more evidence that it's Jack's perspective.

quote:

---

was intriguing

---

not explaining stuff is not intriguing

if you wish to see me discuss this in detail, i'll link you a thread i made last week about this in reference to a russian movie i watched