- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Out of these borderline HoF QBs, which was the best at their peak?
Posted on 12/18/21 at 8:37 am
Posted on 12/18/21 at 8:37 am
Andrew Luck
Phillip Rivers
Eli Manning
Russell Wilson
Carson Palmer(not near HOF, but had a high peak)
I lean Rivers, personally.
Phillip Rivers
Eli Manning
Russell Wilson
Carson Palmer(not near HOF, but had a high peak)
I lean Rivers, personally.
25
Posted on 12/18/21 at 8:40 am to VaBamaMan
Talent wise Rivers. He had some Marino in him, for good and some bad.
Posted on 12/18/21 at 8:41 am to VaBamaMan
Wilson by a wide margin
Posted on 12/18/21 at 8:41 am to VaBamaMan
Russell Wilson
Posted on 12/18/21 at 8:44 am to VaBamaMan
Only one of them had Jim Nantz send it to CBS' 60 Minutes very week after a game ending interception pass.
This post was edited on 12/18/21 at 8:46 am
Posted on 12/18/21 at 8:47 am to VaBamaMan
quote:
Andrew Luck
Cam Newton
This post was edited on 12/18/21 at 8:54 am
Posted on 12/18/21 at 8:47 am to VaBamaMan
I don’t think Wilson is borderline. His resume is very, very similar to Big Ben and his career is far from done.
Posted on 12/18/21 at 8:55 am to Bench McElroy
Andrew luck carried a mediocre colts team to the AFC championship game
Posted on 12/18/21 at 8:55 am to VaBamaMan
Eli.
Not close.
Not close.
Posted on 12/18/21 at 9:02 am to Diseasefreeforall
He probably won't make it but Luck behind center made Indy a very good team. Without him they were mediocre at best.
Posted on 12/18/21 at 9:04 am to VaBamaMan
Why is Russell being considered here??
Posted on 12/18/21 at 9:10 am to lepdagod
quote:
Why is Russell being considered here??
You don’t think he belongs on the list? I think he’s the best of those choices.
Posted on 12/18/21 at 9:22 am to High C
quote:
You don’t think he belongs on the list? I think he’s the best of those choices.
I mean everyone else on the list is retired … I think he the best of the group though
This post was edited on 12/18/21 at 9:23 am
Posted on 12/18/21 at 9:31 am to VaBamaMan
Eli and Wilson are not borderline. Both are comfortably in the HOF.
Wilson had the highest peak and will have more HOF caliber years which, I think, will give him not just the highest but also longest peak.
While I think Manning is safely in the HOF and Rivers is borderline, I think Rivers peak was higher and while I think Rivers has a better shot at HOF (due to longevity) than Luck, I think Luck had a higher two year peak.
Wilson had the highest peak and will have more HOF caliber years which, I think, will give him not just the highest but also longest peak.
While I think Manning is safely in the HOF and Rivers is borderline, I think Rivers peak was higher and while I think Rivers has a better shot at HOF (due to longevity) than Luck, I think Luck had a higher two year peak.
Posted on 12/18/21 at 9:40 am to VaBamaMan
Post Season-
Eli & Wilson have a combined 17 playoff wins & will be enshrined in Canton. Not sure about the other 3.
Luck= 4-4
Rivers= 5-7
Palmer= 1-3
Eli & Wilson have a combined 17 playoff wins & will be enshrined in Canton. Not sure about the other 3.
Luck= 4-4
Rivers= 5-7
Palmer= 1-3
Posted on 12/18/21 at 9:45 am to VaBamaMan
quote:
Phillip Rivers
Posted on 12/18/21 at 9:47 am to VaBamaMan
I’d say at their absolute best, it’s Luck (barely) but his peak was so short it almost doesn’t matter. Rivers is next.
Palmer is up there too. He might be the answer had he not played for the Bengals.
Palmer is up there too. He might be the answer had he not played for the Bengals.
Posted on 12/18/21 at 9:58 am to VaBamaMan
Luck put up some impressive numbers on some shitty colts teams
Posted on 12/18/21 at 10:06 am to VaBamaMan
Russ
Posted on 12/18/21 at 10:08 am to VaBamaMan
Rivers. Always liked that dude.
If he had played a full career, Luck woulda been a first ballot HoF'er. Neck Beard just couldn't stay healthy.
If he had played a full career, Luck woulda been a first ballot HoF'er. Neck Beard just couldn't stay healthy.
Page 1 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News