- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Hall of Fame QBs
Posted on 5/3/19 at 12:52 pm
Posted on 5/3/19 at 12:52 pm
I love comparing all time great QBs. Below is my list of active QBs that are Hall Fame bound:
Hall of Fame Lock:
*Tom Brady
*Drew Brees
*Aaron Rodgers
*Ben Roethlisberger
On the cusp of the Hall of Fame:
*Philip Rivers
*Matt Ryan
*Russell Wilson
Not in yet. Work still left to do:
*Cam Newton
*Eli Manning
Recent star QBS that fell short:
*Donovan McNabb
*Tony Romo
All time great that deserves to get in:
*Ken Anderson
Thoughts?
Hall of Fame Lock:
*Tom Brady
*Drew Brees
*Aaron Rodgers
*Ben Roethlisberger
On the cusp of the Hall of Fame:
*Philip Rivers
*Matt Ryan
*Russell Wilson
Not in yet. Work still left to do:
*Cam Newton
*Eli Manning
Recent star QBS that fell short:
*Donovan McNabb
*Tony Romo
All time great that deserves to get in:
*Ken Anderson
Thoughts?
This post was edited on 5/3/19 at 3:14 pm
21
Posted on 5/3/19 at 12:57 pm to PetermanFanClub
I would put Eli in the "On the cusp of HOF" list and put Ryan and Wilson as "Not in yet. Work still left to do." The rest of the list looks about right.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 12:57 pm to PetermanFanClub
Eli is either in or not at this point, right?
No need for further data to make a determination.
No need for further data to make a determination.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 12:58 pm to PetermanFanClub
quote:Agree
Hall of Fame Lock:
*Tom Brady
*Drew Brees
*Aaron Rodgers
*Ben Roethlisberger
quote:Wilson is the only one on the cusp
On the cusp of the Hall of Fame:
*Philip Rivers
*Matt Ryan
*Russell Wilson
quote:Newton unlikely. Eli is in based on Super bowls
Not in yet. Work still left to do:
*Cam Newton
*Eli Manning
quote:Neither deserve to be in
Recent star QBS that fell short:
*Donovan McNabb
*Tony Romo
Posted on 5/3/19 at 12:58 pm to PetermanFanClub
I think Eli gets in because he won two super bowls with a well respected franchise among the NFL
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:00 pm to PetermanFanClub
I don't love Eli but the guy has two improbable Super Bowl wins. The most memorable super bowl play ever as well. He'll get into the Hall of Fame.
This post was edited on 5/3/19 at 1:05 pm
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:06 pm to ReauxlTide222
Eli can only hurt his chances at this point. He’s well past his prime. His career record is now only a couple of games above .500
Another 5-11 season, and Eli is going to have a losing record as a starting QB. That’s not going to help.
Another 5-11 season, and Eli is going to have a losing record as a starting QB. That’s not going to help.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:06 pm to PetermanFanClub
I don't think 2 SBs are enough for Eli. Remember, Jim Plunkett won 2 SBs for the Raiders and he never came close to the Hall.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:10 pm to PetermanFanClub
Well Eli’s first SB was the biggest SB upset ever by beating what was supposed to be the greatest NFL team of all time. Plus he’s a Manning. That can only help not hurt.
I personally don’t think he should be in (never had a season where he was a clear cut top 5 QB) but he’ll be in.
I personally don’t think he should be in (never had a season where he was a clear cut top 5 QB) but he’ll be in.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:21 pm to PetermanFanClub
LOL Ryan and Wilson have nothing over Cam.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:24 pm to VerlanderBEAST
quote:
LOL Ryan and Wilson have nothing over Cam.
Russell Wilson is a better QB than Cam Newton.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:25 pm to 1BamaRTR
In only one season (2011) did Eli finish in the Top 10 in Passer Rating. Never an All-Pro (1st or 2nd Team). His 4 Pro Bowls are fewer than McNabb (6 total) and equal to Russell Wilson, Tony Romo, Rich Gannon, Boomer Esiason, Jeff Garcia, Michael Vick, Drew Bledsoe. None of these but Wilson have a chance.
But his 2 SB MVPs are pretty unique.
Still think he needs a miracle season to cinch it.
But his 2 SB MVPs are pretty unique.
Still think he needs a miracle season to cinch it.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:28 pm to Ghost of Colby
I understand it was a different era but on stats alone Joe Namath was bad as well.
He has a losing record all time
He has a losing record all time
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:29 pm to PetermanFanClub
Rivers and Manning were traded for each other, their numbers are almost identical 118/116 wins, 54656/55981 yards, 374/360 TDs.
Yet you have the QB with two Super Bowl MVPs below the other?
Yet you have the QB with two Super Bowl MVPs below the other?
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:31 pm to VerlanderBEAST
The only thing Cam does better than Ryan and Wilson is run the ball. And Wilson is certainly no slouch at running. Besides, QBs make the Hall on their arms, not their legs.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:41 pm to TigerintheNO
Personally, I think we put too much value on SBs when evaluating QBs. I mean, I love Terry Bradshaw, but he is not in the Top 20 all time QBs.
Rivers - 8 Pro Bowls
Eli = 4 Pro Bowls
Rivers - 96 career passer rating
Eli = 84 career passer rating
Rivers - 7 seasons Top 10 Passer Rating
Eli = 1 season Top 10 Passer Rating
Rivers was also 1 x Comeback Player of the Year and 2 x PFF All Pro.
Rivers - 8 Pro Bowls
Eli = 4 Pro Bowls
Rivers - 96 career passer rating
Eli = 84 career passer rating
Rivers - 7 seasons Top 10 Passer Rating
Eli = 1 season Top 10 Passer Rating
Rivers was also 1 x Comeback Player of the Year and 2 x PFF All Pro.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 1:54 pm to PetermanFanClub
Rivers >> Roethlisberger
roethlisberger is overrated. hes not terrible, but i dont think hes that great
roethlisberger is overrated. hes not terrible, but i dont think hes that great
Posted on 5/3/19 at 2:33 pm to PetermanFanClub
McNabb > sCam
This post was edited on 5/3/19 at 2:33 pm
Posted on 5/3/19 at 2:47 pm to LB84
quote:
I don't love Eli but the guy has two improbable Super Bowl wins. The most memorable super bowl play ever as well. He'll get into the Hall of Fame.
I don't love him at all either, but he did twice what Joe Willie Namath did.
Posted on 5/3/19 at 2:49 pm to PetermanFanClub
quote:English bad
Hall Fame
Page 1 of 4
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News