- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: Eric Reid takes a knee....on Veterans Day weekend
Posted on 11/13/17 at 10:37 am to Tiger_Stripes
Posted on 11/13/17 at 10:37 am to Tiger_Stripes
It's a lack of respect. Saying your position is more important than the position of others.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 10:39 am to CanIPlay636
How hard is it to obey the law?
Posted on 11/13/17 at 10:48 am to atltiger6487
quote:
apples and oranges. Forgetting to take off a cap is completely different than intentionally kneeling.
Not sure why you left it out, by I stated explicitly that I had no idea why it remained in place. He could have forgotten...though let's be honest, if you're at a live sporting event and you "forget" to take off your cap you're either not paying any attention at all or you're making a point. But I have no idea WHY it stayed on...
quote:
Sorry, but intentional, public disrespect for our great country is disgraceful. This isn't some "snowflake" issue where we're looking to be offended. This strikes at the core of freedom-loving, patriotic Americans.
No...it is snowflake behavior. It's just that it's your issue. I assure you, nuts on the left feel just as strongly that THEIR issue is so life effecting that their offense is completely rational and warranted.
My point is that I'm an adult. I also believe in true liberty. So, as long as someone is doing something that does not directly effect me in any real way, I don't care if they do it. I'm with Jefferson when he wrote:
quote:
The legitimate powers of government extend to such acts only as are injurious to others. But it does me no injury for my neighbour to say there are twenty gods, or no god. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg. ... Reason and free enquiry are the only effectual agents against error
If some guy decides to not stand for the anthem, or burns a flag, or does any number of things which I personally do not agree with but neither pick my pocket nor break my leg, then I generally pass them by and let them do their thing. Their behavior, whether I agree with it or not, does me no direct harm.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 10:50 am to GeauxTigerTM
quote:
If some guy decides to not stand for the anthem, or burns a flag, or does any number of things which I personally do not agree with but neither pick my pocket nor break my leg, then I generally pass them by and let them do their thing. Their behavior, whether I agree with it or not, does me no direct harm.
The old just think about me shite and frick everything else.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 10:51 am to CanIPlay636
quote:
How in the hell does an autopsy proves someone was trying to take a gun
an autopsy can reveal all types of info - how close was the gun fired? At what angle? Based on where the policeman and the victim were positioned, they can determine a lot about what likely happened.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 10:52 am to Run DMC
Why are people so pissed off about someone taking a knee?
Do you want to take a knee and offend someone? Please do. Taking a knee has always been considered a sign of subjugation. Robert E. Lee could have taken a knee to surrender his arms. That was deemed disrespectful to the soldier. When you curtsey before the queen, its a subtle - take your knee. When someone kisses the ring or bows their head, it another form of 'take a knee'. Taking a knee has never been a sign of disrespect.
This umbrage expressed towards taking a knee is not about the act, rather it is towards the person. People have been wrapping themselves in the flag and using the respect and gratitude people have towards veterans to couch their specious arguments. Talk about why it is a disrespectful to take a knee. What's the precedent for your argument?
This country allows you to burn the flag. Wear it as a bra/bikini, shorts, or T-shirt. You get to setup July 4 party with an old glory table cloth and paper napkins that you can soil and throw in a trash can. Many countries have relaxed their attitudes about the way people use their countries colors - thanks to the way Americans freely, jingoistically use the colors and the flag. Anyone trying to set boundaries about how the flag can be used, does not fully fathom the impact of the way the flag has been used over the last 50 years.
If you argue that a private work place has its own rules. Damn right they do. However, they have different rules for different employees. Third stringer might get kicked away faster than a starter. If someone on the practice squad had taken a knee, we might have never heard about it and the team may have kicked them off. Why is everyone hell bent on imposing their morality on others for every trivial instance. Media Matters is asking companies to boycott Hannity. Now Hannity's fans want to boycott companies that pulled ads. We need to get a grip and use this boycott for serious issues. If you do not agree with Hannity's interview with Roy Moore, what did you expect Sean to do. Call someone from a party he supports a pedophile? Why are people breaking their Keurig coffee makers?
Look at the issue that Kaepernick professed to highlight. If it is meritless, by all means criticize. However, police do not get blanket immunity just because they wear the badge. This country has investigated and prosecuted crimes by its veterans and police. There were many opportunities over the last 150 years to be a colonial power, instead we chose to espouse our principles. It should not be that hard to investigate if a segment of population says that they are discriminated against. Our principle should be to eliminate discrimination in our midst. Trying to sweep the issue under the carpet in the name of the flag or veterans is immoral and unprincipled.
Do you want to take a knee and offend someone? Please do. Taking a knee has always been considered a sign of subjugation. Robert E. Lee could have taken a knee to surrender his arms. That was deemed disrespectful to the soldier. When you curtsey before the queen, its a subtle - take your knee. When someone kisses the ring or bows their head, it another form of 'take a knee'. Taking a knee has never been a sign of disrespect.
This umbrage expressed towards taking a knee is not about the act, rather it is towards the person. People have been wrapping themselves in the flag and using the respect and gratitude people have towards veterans to couch their specious arguments. Talk about why it is a disrespectful to take a knee. What's the precedent for your argument?
This country allows you to burn the flag. Wear it as a bra/bikini, shorts, or T-shirt. You get to setup July 4 party with an old glory table cloth and paper napkins that you can soil and throw in a trash can. Many countries have relaxed their attitudes about the way people use their countries colors - thanks to the way Americans freely, jingoistically use the colors and the flag. Anyone trying to set boundaries about how the flag can be used, does not fully fathom the impact of the way the flag has been used over the last 50 years.
If you argue that a private work place has its own rules. Damn right they do. However, they have different rules for different employees. Third stringer might get kicked away faster than a starter. If someone on the practice squad had taken a knee, we might have never heard about it and the team may have kicked them off. Why is everyone hell bent on imposing their morality on others for every trivial instance. Media Matters is asking companies to boycott Hannity. Now Hannity's fans want to boycott companies that pulled ads. We need to get a grip and use this boycott for serious issues. If you do not agree with Hannity's interview with Roy Moore, what did you expect Sean to do. Call someone from a party he supports a pedophile? Why are people breaking their Keurig coffee makers?
Look at the issue that Kaepernick professed to highlight. If it is meritless, by all means criticize. However, police do not get blanket immunity just because they wear the badge. This country has investigated and prosecuted crimes by its veterans and police. There were many opportunities over the last 150 years to be a colonial power, instead we chose to espouse our principles. It should not be that hard to investigate if a segment of population says that they are discriminated against. Our principle should be to eliminate discrimination in our midst. Trying to sweep the issue under the carpet in the name of the flag or veterans is immoral and unprincipled.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 10:55 am to atltiger6487
quote:
actually he doesn't.
The only "right" he has is that the GOVERNMENT can't punish him for his speech.
But when he's on the field, he's an EMPLOYEE of his NFL team. The First Amendment does NOT extend to private entities. Employers can, and do, limit their employee's speech.
McDonald's wouldn't want an employee showing up for work in a Trump or Hillary shirt, or a pro-life or pro-choice hat. They can, if they want to, limit their employees' speech when they're at work.
Again, it's shocking how little people understand our Constitution.
Actually it isn't that cut and dry. Standing for the national anthem is considered by the courts to be a political act. If the government is unable to make you stand for the anthem, then it is unlikely that your employer is able to do so. McDonald's can't make you wear a Trump shirt (or Hillary shirt) if you don't want to.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 10:56 am to old man tiger
quote:
The old just think about me shite and frick everything else.
No...it's the allow others to do what they want so long as it does me no harm bit. Actual harm...not perceived harm.
Or are you equating Jefferon with some 1960's "if it feels good do it" bullshite?
You either like the notion of freedom or liberty, or you don't. Actual liberty sometimes means having people behave in a way that you do not agree with and allowing them to continue, because then YOU get the right to do your thing without them stopping you.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 10:58 am to GeauxTigerTM
quote:
You either like the notion of freedom or liberty, or you don't.
I'm paying to see a football game....not your right to demonstrate liberty or freedom.
Take it somewhere else. These guys are exploiting their platforms.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:09 am to RedTigerRulz
quote:
I'm paying to see a football game....not your right to demonstrate liberty or freedom.
Honest question...why would you even notice?
Thinking back to the game on Saturday, I basically looked at the flag in the north endzone and glanced around a bit at the rest of the stadium while I happily sang. Even had I been down on field level, I'm not sure I'd have noticed if a handful of players (if college players were even in the stadium for the anthem, which they are not) were kneeling. I'd have to basically stop my own enjoyment of the moment to go look for something I almost certainly would not have seen without being prompted to notice.
Kind of reminds me of Chris Jackson in the NBA. Most people either never knew it or forgot, but he wasn't making some Kaepernick public stand at first. Rauf was a quiet guy and when he converted to Islam he decided he didn't want to stand anymore. Never told anyone. So be it. So for weeks he did some stretches or whatever while the anthem played and literally no one noticed or cared. Then some media guy happened to notice and asked him about it and it became a story because he explained why. Then...camera were on him for his "protest." After that, when people suddenly lost their shite because someone was doing something they didn't agree with (see this thread) he got indignant about it and it became a big fricking deal.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:09 am to RedTigerRulz
quote:
I'm paying to see a football game....
Then why do you give a shite about what goes on during the pre-game?
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:14 am to Green Chili Tiger
quote:
Then why do you give a shite about what goes on during the pre-game?
Put on a uniform homey and serve...then you might understand.
If you have served and feel this behavior is fine...shame on you.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:17 am to GeauxTigerTM
quote:
You either like the notion of freedom or liberty, or you don't. Actual liberty sometimes means having people behave in a way that you do not agree with and allowing them to continue, because then YOU get the right to do your thing without them stopping you.
look, I'm basically a libertarian, so your general concept is fine. But there's a time and place for political statements.
I don't want my server at a restaurant to be wearing a Trump or Hillary hat. I don't want my cashier at Kroger to be wearing a pro-life or pro-choice shirt. I don't want the singer at a concert to promote a political or social issue. I don't want my doctor to have posters on his walls about his personal political beliefs.
And I don't want athletes to protest the national anthem -- at a football game.
Freedom? Of course. All these people can promote political/social/religious issues as much as they want -- but do it on their own time. Not when I'm a paying customer.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:18 am to RedTigerRulz
quote:
Put on a uniform homey and serve...then you might understand.
Such a TERRIBLE argument...unless you want to follow this logic down the line with all other jobs which we can now not talk about unless we have worked in them?
Teachers? LEO's? Officials? Lawyers? Doctors?
quote:
If you have served and feel this behavior is fine...shame on you.
Oh...so you can't talk about it if you haven't served, and you also can't be fine with it even if you have. Nice.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:18 am to DocBugbear
quote:
Actually it isn't that cut and dry. Standing for the national anthem is considered by the courts to be a political act. If the government is unable to make you stand for the anthem, then it is unlikely that your employer is able to do so. McDonald's can't make you wear a Trump shirt (or Hillary shirt) if you don't want to.
absolutely false.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:21 am to Minden tiger
It all started with that though. Remember the St. Louis Rams coming out of the tunnel before their game with their hands in the air? All of these high profile cases in which the cops have supposedly been the aggressors have gone to court and not a single cop has been indicted. Whether it’s Michael Brown, Freddie Grey, Alton Sterling, Eric Garner, or Travon Martin, none of the accusations made by the witnesses have held any weight in the court of law. None of them! Not a single one! I’m not sure many of you remember how much of a high profile case the death of Freddie grey was, but it was a big deal. The prosecutor actually gave out charges before any investigation whatsoever. The police were actually told to stand down so that the citizens would have the ability to vent. People lost their businesses and their property to idiots protesting something that was completely false.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:22 am to GeauxTigerTM
quote:
Oh...so you can't talk about it if you haven't served
you're free to talk about it...it simply has no validity.
You're ok with attention whores....I get it.
I'm not....sorry
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:23 am to YellowShoe
quote:
Look at the issue that Kaepernick professed to highlight. If it is meritless, by all means criticize. However, police do not get blanket immunity just because they wear the badge. This country has investigated and prosecuted crimes by its veterans and police. There were many opportunities over the last 150 years to be a colonial power, instead we chose to espouse our principles. It should not be that hard to investigate if a segment of population says that they are discriminated against. Our principle should be to eliminate discrimination in our midst. Trying to sweep the issue under the carpet in the name of the flag or veterans is immoral and unprincipled.
you're completely missing the point.
Nobody is trying to "sweep the issue under the rug." Kaepernick can protest all he wants -- on his own time.
The complaint here is that NFL players shouldn't protest when they're on the job. We want to be entertained, not subject to anyone's protests - about ANY issue (even one I might agree with).
Play the game - protest on your own time.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:24 am to atltiger6487
The autopsy proved he was trying to take the gun from the cop because of the bullet hole through the door of the Tahoe, and the gun powder on Michael browns shirt. He reached in and tried to grab the gun from the officer. To prevent the thug from getting the gun the officer shot, and through his door no less.
Posted on 11/13/17 at 11:29 am to atltiger6487
quote:
I don't want my server at a restaurant to be wearing a Trump or Hillary hat. I don't want my cashier at Kroger to be wearing a pro-life or pro-choice shirt. I don't want the singer at a concert to promote a political or social issue. I don't want my doctor to have posters on his walls about his personal political beliefs.
And I don't want athletes to protest the national anthem -- at a football game.
I'm with you entirely until you get to the game. And there's a actual reason. Those first professions you mentioned don't feel the need to make their job partially political before doing their duties for you in their line of service, right? The NFL does in this way...however minor you may think being told to stand for the anthem is.
Dead on in regards to the cashiers and wait staff. As for the doctor, this happens a ton if you're talking about social issues. I'm not a religious guy but I live in South LA...so if I allowed my personal beliefs to force me to "boycott" all doctors that have a cross on their wall or some Bible verse on their desk, I'd run out of options fairly quickly.
quote:
Freedom? Of course. All these people can promote political/social/religious issues as much as they want -- but do it on their own time. Not when I'm a paying customer.
I asked earlier...unless you're looking for it...how does it actually effect you? And even if you're actually AT the game and sitting directly behind someone doing this, how does this REALLY effect you in a real, meaningful way? I think this REALLY is important, because I think people have decided that being offended by something is the same thing as being actually injured...
Popular
Back to top


0






