Rather 150 yard ace or eagle 440 yard par 4

Hole in one

That being said, I have an albatross on a 500 yard par 5 that is much more impressive to me than my hole in one from 136. Hit driver, 4 hybrid. It came off weird, very low and hot. The green is like a big back stop and it hit just before the green, hopped once, hopped again and landed in the hole. Annnnnnnnnnd of course my 5 year old daughters were the only ones that saw it. Couldn't happen in a tournament for a super skin.

Hole in one>albatross>eagle on a par 4

Obviously an albatross is the most difficult and least likely but an ace is perfect. 1 is the perfect score. Makes it better than anything else IMO

Ace.

Ace. Never had one.
No albatross either, which seems to be even harder than an ace.
Have several eagles on par 4's.

Hole in one.

I don't think the "have you eagled a par 4, or double eagled a par 5" question gets brought up that much. It's definitely harder to do, but a HIO clearly means more to most people.

HIO on a par 4 would be the ideal but impractical answer.

Having plenty of par 4 eagles and only one Ace...

Hole in one easily.

I had one Ace and it cost me $150.00 bucks in the clubhouse afterwards lol

Had one double eagle at Thrash park.

Ace by far

I made a Double Eagle before making an ace and the ace felt better

On two occasions I came close to an Ace on a Par 4.

One was right outside Orange Beach on one of the Robert Trent Jones courses. We were playing a 375 yard hole with a severe dog leg right where are you couldn’t see the green from the tee as there was essentially a forest in between. in a straight line, it was probably more like 310 to 320 yards. It was in a scramble and one of our guys had placed the ball right down the middle where we had about another 150 into the hole. I was driving last and decided to try to hit a slice over the trees to get it closer to the hole.

One of the guys I was playing with was very familiar with the course and thought for sure I had put the ball in the trees. I thought I cleared the trees, but I didn’t know by how much. One more thing, there was a huge sand trap in front of the green.

When we got in the cart my playing partner was sure that we should look in the trees. When we made the turn around the trees, we saw the foursome in front of us all standing on the edge of the green looking towards us. As we got closer, one of them asked if one of us was playing with a Wilson titanium golf ball. I told him I was.

They explained that the ball had just cleared the sand trap, bounced up around 10 feet in the air, rolled down towards the hole, and took a peek inside the cup before rolling just off the green. We had about a 12 foot putt coming back for eagle and one of my playing partners made it. The foursome on front had no idea where the ball head come from, but they thought it was going to roll right into the cup.

On another occasion, I was playing in another scramble at Bayou Barriere in Belle Chase. I forget the hole, but it was about 315 yards, with a very slight dog leg left. The hole was protected by bunkers with just a slight gap in between the bunkers. I managed to hit a nice little draw that hit in front of the bunkers but went right in between the gap. We yelled four and the group in front of us started cheering for it to go in. When we got up to the green, the foursome ahead said it missed by about 2 or 3 inches. The ball wound up about 10 to 15 feet from the cup and we all missed the eagle putt coming back.