Favorite team:Notre Dame 
Location:Chicago, IL
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:8849
Registered on:5/22/2014
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
+200 or so on most sites. Implied odds of about 1 in 3 chance.

ND is next at between +400 - +450 or so (so a bit under 1 in 5 chance).

Honestly, Miami sitting at +1000 is pretty damn good value right now. If I were to lay money, that's where I would do it.
One of UGA, Notre Dame, Miami, and maybe Alabama will be your national champion. I don't think it's that wide open.

You need balance and (importantly) depth to win 3 - 4 consecutive games against top 10 - 12 teams. Only a handful of teams have it every year, and those are your 3 - 4 that fit the criteria this year. Each of them have their individual issues they could improve upon (Alabama's OL play, Miami's pass defense, etc.), but they have the tools to get it done. I don't think Utah or Wake or whoever else has the powder to climb the mountain.
quote:

Texas lost to two unranked teams


And has wins against teams ranked #9, #14, and #25, and both their losses are now ranked

quote:

Bama lost to two top teams (according to you)


Best win is now #16 with another win against #21 and oh yes, also has two losses

quote:

UCLA has beaten no one


They now have a better win (#13 Oregon) than any of Alabama's wins and they also haven't lost a game

quote:

ND has mid 50’s SOS


No, it's somewhere between 20 and 40 depending on the metric, and we have a win against an actual top 10 team and a single loss - one loss, not two - against another top 10 team

quote:

And the beat goes on. Just like I said, any order has holes in it


Nope - there is one very clear, very glaring outlier in all this. Your team isn't that good, and you are receiving favorable treatment for the third out of four years. You are, once again, going to get belted when you run up against your ranking as you are, once again, playing like shite yet again under DeBoer late in the season. Good luck. I hope we see you all early in the playoffs.

re: CFB Playoff Rankings 11/17

Posted by AbuTheMonkey on 11/17/26 at 9:58 pm to
quote:

If I’m wake forest I’m frickin pissed


They admittedly still control their own destiny, and I think that's all they can ask for at this point.

That's a damn good football team, but their best win is Louisville at this point (which was a last minute affair), and even with all the hoopla around them, they still lost by multiple scores at home to a Miami team that was missing Toney for long stretches of the game. They have been dominating since early October, but their best win in that stretch is SMU (second best is probably Virginia or Cal). They went to double OT against Purdue early in the year.

They still have to prove something against a genuinely top tier team other than being semi-competitive.
quote:

quote:
Undefeated resume vs 2 losses.

Good point. Put UCLA in front of Bama too then right? Oh wait no they dont cause theres no consistent logic behind what they do


UCLA now has a better win than any of Alabama's wins, is undefeated, and is somehow still ranked behind Alabama.
In particular I loved Yurachek's comment about "Coming off a big emotional road win, they struggled offensively but pulled it out", etc., etc.

Miami and Notre Dame just both played the biggest games of their season and absolutely put belt to arse to teams that are definitely better than (in Duke's case) or at least as good as (in Boston College's case) fricking Vanderbilt. Oh, and all six of your SEC wins lost last weekend, and all you have left is two pretty good but not great wins against two teams who very well might not finish inside the top 25 at all.
UGA
Utah
UCLA
Notre Dame
Texas
Miami
Tennessee
Alabama
Indiana
BYU
Wake Forest
Texas Tech

That should be your top 12. You could flip Texas and Notre Dame, and I'd have no problem. There's actually not much wrong with the current slotting, including the SEC teams in the 21 - 25 slots, with the very large, very glaring exception of Alabama being about 5 - 6 spots too high.

This is the third year in the last four where an undeserved Alabama team is receiving favorable treatment. It's not an SEC problem at this point - it is very specifically an Alabama problem.

re: QB Transfer Portal Market

Posted by AbuTheMonkey on 11/15/26 at 1:59 pm to
It’ll be interesting to see if Louisville ponies up to keep Kienholz. Also have to think some teams are gonna to come after Gio Lopez. Chiles from
Northwestern and the kid from Texas State are also going to be interesting to watch.
quote:

quote:Alabama was one play away from beating Georgia And covered the spread this weekend on the road. Maybe that constitutes dropping like a rock. Who knows with the playoff committee. Seems to change weekly


The only thing propping you up to #3 with two losses was your strength of resume. All 3 of your ranked wins lost this weekend, and at least 1 and maybe 2 of them are about to drop out of the top 25. And Kentucky has at least one more L in them. By all rights you should drop to 6 or 7 on Tuesday.
quote:

Acting like it’s a 3 team race is absurd. This season has more parity than ever.


I thought there were about 6 - 7 teams that had the talent and depth to actually get it done in like mid-September. You all were definitely one of them before Sayin went down. LSU is out. Alabama hasn’t proven to be complete enough, and they’re about to drop like a rock after this weekend. Texas is still definitely in the mix but honestly Arch kind of stinks.

Georgia or Notre Dame or Miami will be your national champion. Bookmark this.
A healthy Notre Dame is going to give anyone they play problems. Probably Miami, too.

The rest of the country really has no shot.

re: Dropping Indiana five spots is dumb

Posted by AbuTheMonkey on 11/11/26 at 10:50 pm to
quote:


quote:
They'll be in 100% if they win this weekend, but they have to win this weekend. They'll likely finish up on that 9 or 10 line with the schedule, but they'll definitely be in.


You hearts desire isn't reality.

You were mad and confused when Alabama was ranked #5 then #3 and you're going to be even more confused and angry when they won't drop because the commitee doesn't respect either of their losses and sees Alabama at worst as the second best team when healthy


You're responding to my response on Indiana, not Alabama.

And no, the Committee does not see Alabama "at worst as the second best team when healthy". They evaluate the results as they come.

You could say the exact same thing, for instance, about Miami if they had Toney and their two starting corners healthy or if their OL was completely healthy (they aren't at the moment).

You could definitely say the same thing about Notre Dame if ND weren't missing five defensive starters - and seven at one point during the Miami game, including 2 of the TD scoring drives in the second half, in which ND was down its top 5 overall pick, clearly first-team All-American corner in Leonard Moore and his #3 backup (#2 is already sidelined with an injury) - during the latter half of the year (one of the five is likely to be a first round safety and another of which is a corner who has gotten first and second round grades and two of the others are the starting DT's both of which will play in the NFL and yet another of which is the defensive captain and likely 4th - 5th round NFL pick at MLB). Or that ND lost the BYU game when its 1st / 2nd round graded DE got ejected second play of the game. ND, were it to make the playoff, will get all but two of those guys back for the playoff run.

There are countless examples all over the top 10 - 15 teams just like that - Alabama isn't special in injuries or time missed and in fact has probably been more healthy than some of the other top tier teams. Injuries are part of the sport, and the Committee evaluates depth of talent as much as it does the top line given its criteria.

What I actually meant was that Alabama's shine on their three wins are quite likely to come off as the weeks roll on - particularly for Kentucky, who isn't all that good and was fortunate as hell to win two very tight games against LSU and South Carolina and will likely lose 1 - 2 more as they come down the stretch. A top 12-ish win is going to turn into a top 25-ish win very quickly there. South Carolina will almost certainly get at least one more loss. LSU will likely get at least one more loss and potentially two but if they don't, then God bless them because they will have conquered a damn gauntlet. And Alabama has no more games that are going to sniff the big game test left. How will Alabama's resume stack up with two top 25-ish wins and two losses against all the teams around them? Not particularly well. The Committee just set them up for that - by not putting Alabama at 7 or 8 or whatever, they have ensured that they can keep the resume intact as they slowly drop them over the coming weeks even after they keep winning over the dogshit of the SEC + Chattanooga.

It is the opposite of what they did with ND last week and USC this week - effectively, prove it, and we will move you. Alabama has proven it enough to get in without a doubt (assuming no loss in the last three), but they are going to get fricked with by the Committee as the end of the season nears, particularly if Tennessee continues to win. It will be the Indiana treatment in slow motion.
quote:

quote:
I'd be a bit concerned if I were an Alabama fan. The Committee is setting them up for a bit of a rug pull.

Best wins are going to be Kentucky, LSU, and South Carolina. UK is definitely staring at least one and potentially 2+ more losses. South Carolina is definitely taking another L.

Alabama is in the unenvious spot of having to root for LSU to beat Texas and especially Tennessee, else they'll be a 10 - 2 team with maybe only 2 top 25 wins and none in the top 15. They'll be staring at a 7 or 8 seed with that resume.


What is there to be concerned about? We will get a home game first round if we are 7 or 8.

If we get into the SECCG we'll have a chance to play for a top 4 seed and get a bye. If we get in and lose then we'll probably be in the same situation as we would be if we would have not gotten into the SECCG.


"Bit of a rug pull", not that you all would get dropped five spots in a week like IU, but that it may be a slow bleed of 4 or 5 spots even as you keep winning until the conference title games. Lose that, and you may be looking at a road playoff game to start depending on what happens around you.

Not that I have a particularly strong feeling towards Alabama as a program or this team in particular one way or the other - more of what I see as a pattern of how the Committee has operated, especially this year. Lots of football to be played yet, though.
quote:

They're getting punished for the lack of quality scheduling as other teams behind them get quality wins.

They'll keep dropping as I don't think they have any quality win possibilities left.


They'll be in 100% if they win this weekend, but they have to win this weekend. They'll likely finish up on that 9 or 10 line with the schedule, but they'll definitely be in.
I'd be a bit concerned if I were an Alabama fan. The Committee is setting them up for a bit of a rug pull.

Best wins are going to be Kentucky, LSU, and South Carolina. UK is definitely staring at least one and potentially 2+ more losses. South Carolina is definitely taking another L.

Alabama is in the unenvious spot of having to root for LSU to beat Texas and especially Tennessee, else they'll be a 10 - 2 team with maybe only 2 top 25 wins and none in the top 15. They'll be staring at a 7 or 8 seed with that resume.
quote:

LSU / Alabama is always one of the biggest draws of the year, but pretty revealing it’s outdrawing ND / Miami in primetime.


I think there is some network inertia or stickiness going on here as well (trying to remove my ND fan bias).

For what it's worth, BYU / Notre Dame three weeks ago (9.2M) also outdrew Notre Dame / Miami (9.1M) this weekend. That was also an ABC game. I would have never expected that.

For an additional point of reference, Notre Dame / Miami last year drew 10.8M. That was also an ABC game.

I think there is a gravitational pull to ABC / ESPN games for the casual viewer that there isn't quite yet - and may take a long time to get there, if ever - for NBC games (whether for ND or the Big Ten). Really it's yet another demonstration of the power of the Disney family of networks in the sport right now.
The big advantage that IU had that LSU has not was that a bunch of JMU guys came over with Cignetti when he took the job - they had a core that knew the system and had been developed by his staff. That's a big time advantage that hasn't proven to be very replicable by almost anyone else except maybe Morris at Oklahoma State (hence why they are playing so much better this year).
quote:

They enroll at that juco to stay eligible like Rudy

Similar to Tulane they have a athletics career track to get them in


We haven't had a player at Holy Cross in at least a generation. That is not a thing at all.
quote:

quote:
quote:
he'd never get the talent needed at Notre Dame to win it all.

They changed their policy due to him leaving like that.

despite making it to the national championship game and ran into a buzzsaw....sounds like a kiffiny decision.

I don't have enough talent to win a title, despite being in a title game, or a couple playoff wins away

Umm, not sure what you're trying to argue.

Kelly's Notre Dame team made the national championship game due to name and record. It was undefeated (for what that's worth with their schedule). That was the best team he'd been able to assemble.
Alabama beat them 42-14, in a game they stepped off the gas in the second half.
Same Alabama team won tight games vs UGA in the SEC Championship, and earlier LSU on the road. Had lost to A&M with Manziel in a close game.

Kelly understood- his best team at Notre Dame would not survive in the SEC. There was a talent ceiling. He played a home and home with UGA and lost both, started playing ACC teams and faced Clemson. He beat them once in 3 tries, the covid year. That was a home game, Clemson was missing their QB, and it went to 2 OTs. That was the only "top" team Notre Dame beat while he was there.

No, he wasn't getting enough talent to win a title there


Kelly's best ND team was probably 2015; that team when healthy took Clemson (who lost a reasonably tight game against Alabama in the title that year) in Death Valley down to the very last play. That team was a walking hospital by the second half of the year, though.

2012 schedule was a good schedule - top 15 or so SoS at the end of the year (prior to playing Alabama). We played Pac 12 champion Stanford (back when they were good), Big XII co-champion Oklahoma, Miami, Michigan, Michigan State, BYU, and USC, among others.
quote:


They basically canned all that the day after they fired Kelly, though it was never as strict as Kelly wanted you to believe.


That's right - it was stricter than many big-time college football programs, but it was not that strict.

Weis recruited his arse off and got results on the recruiting trail. Kelly apparently delegated a lot of it to his assistants.

The big change since Freeman came on board (though we started doing this a bit in Kelly's later years) besides $50+M NIL pool is that we now allow undergrad transfers; obviously, with the way the sport was trending, that was an "adapt or die" change.

One thing that is still definitely a component for ND's recruiting philosophy is behavioral stuff - that hasn't changed.

Freeman has been the right guy at the right time for a lot of reasons (in my opinion), but I'll also say that the professionalization of the sport over the last five+ years has benefited ND a ton for all sorts of reasons...one of them being that with 18 - 22 year olds getting paid big money, there is an expectation for them to not act like knuckleheads off the field. That seems to be the case across the sport - a lot less idiotic behavior is tolerated by all big programs than twenty or thirty years ago - but ND has really benefited from that.

If there were ever institutional limits, it was more on the social side - South Bend was a tough place if you wanted to go out and find some fun. That's gotten a lot better than it used to be, but it really doesn't matter that much any more if you're on a seven figure NIL deal.
quote:

The ball wasn't secure before the ND player knocked it out. Honestly, that's probably the only reason the player was even able to break up the pass. Had Lofton secured it, I don't think the ND player would have even been able to knock it out.


Correct - there was a bit of a bobble before Talich even knocked it out.

Only Mario Cristobal and Michael Irvin’s coked up arse seem to think it was a catch.