Started By
Message

Is it illegal to plead guilty to a crime you didn’t commit?

Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:35 pm
Posted by OysterPoBoy
City of St. George
Member since Jul 2013
42437 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:35 pm
If it looks like to do so may be the best option?

Posted by UncleLester
West of the Mississippi
Member since Aug 2008
8853 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:36 pm to
Isn’t that what a “No Contest” plea is for?
Posted by Corner Pocket
Member since Feb 2024
176 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:38 pm to
quote:

Isn’t that what a “No Contest” plea is for?


No contest is when you plea guilty but still maintain your innocence
Posted by SallysHuman
Lady Palmetto Bug
Member since Jan 2025
12029 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:39 pm to
I watch Law and Order... I think they call that an Alford Plea...
Posted by Ghost of Colby
Alberta, overlooking B.C.
Member since Jan 2009
14771 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:39 pm to
Whatcha do? Seems like you’re in a pickle.
Posted by Shexter
Prairieville
Member since Feb 2014
18919 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:40 pm to
quote:

Is it illegal to plead guilty to a crime you didn’t commit?


There's more to prison life than rampant, free loving butt sex. It's not a 24/7 orgy like they advertise.

I know you wanna get in there bad, but please rethink. The whole prison thing is a pain in the arse.
Posted by OysterPoBoy
City of St. George
Member since Jul 2013
42437 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:41 pm to
quote:

Isn’t that what a “No Contest” plea is for?


I forgot about that one. Is it treated the same as a guilty plea?
Posted by UncleLester
West of the Mississippi
Member since Aug 2008
8853 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:46 pm to
quote:

I forgot about that one. Is it treated the same as a guilty plea?


I took one semester of “Business Law” 20 years ago in College and my old lady always has on these Cold Case Mystery shows in the background.

So, I would double check what I said.
Posted by SallysHuman
Lady Palmetto Bug
Member since Jan 2025
12029 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:46 pm to
Posted by thegambler
Louisiana
Member since Oct 2012
2010 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:54 pm to
Dirty lawyers and prosecutors talk innocent folk into doing this all the time
Posted by Obtuse1
Westside Bodymore Yo
Member since Sep 2016
29876 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:58 pm to
It actually is since the statement is perjury and potentially obstruction. I imagine it is only ever prosecuted when someone is taking the blame for someone else intentionally.

There are no contest (nolo) pleas as well as Alford pleas. They are slightly different and without going into it the main substantive difference is an Alford can be used as evidence against someone in a subsequent civil case.
Posted by Gravitiger
Member since Jun 2011
12138 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 3:58 pm to
I don't know if the guilty plea itself is illegal, but if you lie in the course of allocution, that would be perjury. I imagine it could also meet the elements of obstruction of justice or making false statements to LEO or something like that.
Posted by Odysseus32
Member since Dec 2009
9543 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 4:03 pm to
De facto perjury
Posted by SallysHuman
Lady Palmetto Bug
Member since Jan 2025
12029 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 4:04 pm to
So what did you do, Oyster?
Posted by SoFla Tideroller
South Florida
Member since Apr 2010
38494 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 4:06 pm to
At some point you would have to give a sworn statement; opening you up to perjury charges. However, if you're already voluntarily going to prison that's probably not much of a deterrent.
Posted by GRTiger
On a roof eating alligator pie
Member since Dec 2008
68648 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 4:08 pm to
Yes, if you admit to a crime that you didn't commit in court, you are committing perjury and treason.
Posted by TigerReich
Member since Dec 2024
461 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 5:19 pm to
You would be perjuring yourself under oath, which is a felony.

“No contest” or “nolo contendre” where we are in LA, is neither an admission of guilt nor innocence. Generally, you are just acknowledging that there may be sufficient evidence to otherwise convict you or you don’t give a shite so you’ll take the charge.
Posted by forkedintheroad
Member since Feb 2025
1294 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 5:25 pm to
If they know you didn't commit the crime, why are they putting you in a position to plead?
Posted by Violent Hip Swivel
Member since Aug 2023
7600 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 5:27 pm to
It depends on whether or not you want to risk a jury trial.

Judges are lazy. Having to deal with a trial makes them pissy, and they won't hold back if a jury finds you guilty.
Posted by Dawgfanman
Member since Jun 2015
25623 posts
Posted on 10/31/25 at 6:09 pm to
quote:

Yes, if you admit to a crime that you didn't commit in court, you are committing perjury and treason.


Doing this is tacitly encouraged by prosecutors all the time. Plea deals and such
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram