Train to major us city

It takes forever and isn't even that much cheaper. Not worth it unless you're just bored out of your mind

You can take Amtrak from BYI to Penn Station NY. If you book enough in advance, one way is $30. 3 hours and just relax. The tolls by themselves are approximately $50 to drive car

Yeah it can be nice for places like the north east but I assumed this baw was talking about traveling from Louisiana

quote:

---

I’ve looked into going from Boston to New York on Amtrak many times. It’s somehow always more expensive than flying, so I’ve never done it.

---

We looked into doing Jersey to Boston by train before a fall Canadian cruise. It was much more expensive than flying. Ended up just driving instead.

I've done it several times . Dallas to Chicago-always 5 or 6 hours late
Denver to Aspen
Dallas to San Antonio 8 hours when I can drive it in 4.
Nyc to Hartford
Boston to Portland, Maine
Boston to Providence
Providence to Hartford
Portland, or to seattle

East coast trains are good. The ones out of Dallas are very slow and always several hours late departing and arriving. West coast trains were good but the distances we traveled weren't that far.

Done a bunch, mostly short/day trip in coach or business car seats, and a few overnight and multi-day trips in a sleeper car. A few from NOLA, some west coast, some mid-west centered around Chicago, a decent bit on the NE corridor, and even both versions of passenger rail in South Florida, Sun Coast and Brightline. Chicago to anywhere within a few hours is good and cheaper than driving when factoring in tolls, gas, parking. The Northeast Corridor has great service, except for driving a few times would always train rather than fly.

It's generally great, I find it way more relaxing than flying and definitely more relaxing than driving between major cities IF...the trip is less than 4 or 5 hours and you are going from city center to city center.

I've taken the amtrak from NOLA several times, main issue is lack of short trips although the Mobile train will change that.

Few years ago was in Baltimore for conference but wanted to do dinner and one night in DC. Left Sheraton Inner Harbor at 3:30pm , caught $10 lyft that got me to Penn Station Baltimore in 10 mins (also could have taken bus that was 15 mins but running late), took 3 minutes from car to be in my b-class train seat with plugs and wifi, with train ride and metro connection to Dupont Circle was walking in my hotel for the night at 5:00 pm. At that time of day in the DMV driving would have taken twice as long, plus I only paid a small metro fare instead of probably $80/night on each end for parking.

I have gone one-way from NYC to Boston. It was pretty cool. 30+ minutes late taking off though. Which I hear is pretty common.

You can bring your own alcohol on board and drink it, so that was fun.

Nola to Chicago. 19 hours of pain or 90 minutes on a plane. Don’t do it.

Unfortunately, long train trips (longer than 8-10 hours) in the US are for those who enjoy the experience, not to save money or time. I do enjoy the experience, with a sleeper car, and would do it more often if I had the time, sometimes the money (its often expensive), and more destinations from NOLA. For instance if there was daily service to Houston or Dallas that left in the morning I would occasionally take it, work on the train most of the day, then have a few "train happy hour drinks from my bag" before arriving.