Favorite team:
Location:Brooklyn
Biography:
Interests:Sports
Occupation:Record Shop / Label
Number of Posts:10086
Registered on:3/16/2010
Online Status:
 Online

Recent Posts

Message
quote:

This doesn’t apply to international players in Sivka’s position


They know this.

They have a NBA drafted international player on their mens basketball team right now.


Niang was selected by the Cleveland Cavaliers in the 2025 NBA Draft but instead played in Italy with Virtus Bologna before being cleared for the 2026–27 college season.


Sankey has not "threatened" them about Niang either.



LSU also has an International men's basketball player on their team that went through the NBA draft as well.

The SEC is also not threatening LSU about that specific player.

It's because they involve different exceptions for international players that do not contract with the NBA --- which I personally think should be cut out too but it's why the SEC isn't threatening LSU or Kentucky about those players.

quote:

Sankey have a problem with local judges granting TROs?


YES. Obviously, that's why he lead the charge to pass the new NCAA 5 for 5 rule designed to nip BS like the Chambliss redshirt year in the bud in the future.

Not much more he can really do in that regard since there's decades long precedents of litigation over redshirt years.


What he can also do is try to prevent SEC programs from opening new cans of worms like the RJ Luis case that, again and again and again, has nothing to do with 5 For 5 rule exceptions.

I get that you're angry about Chambliss but it's causing you to simply not see the differences in levels of threats to the NCAA/SEC rules going forward and why those different levels are getting different responses.

On the bright side, the season is almost over and you won't have think about Chambliss so much.






quote:


And you continue to pretend to be too dumb to grasp the underlying question of who determines eligibility. Chambliss is ineligible, the NCAA denied him a medical waiver on his made up medical condition. A housecat OM judge overruled them. That's the issue. I don't want these cases determined by local, biased judges but the current worst case scenario of some schools being held to the rules while others are allowed to violate eligibility and openly tamper with other school's recruits is untenable.




1) The 5 for 5 rule is now in place to address the decades long history of players like Chambliss suing for extra medical redshirt years

2) cases like RJ Luis or Bediako have nothing to do with 5 For 5 and therefore threaten to open a whole new can of worms

3) You and Sankey do not want an endless series of local judges granting TROs into eternity. So, you and Sankey both want to specifically stamp out anything that will not be covered by 5 For 5 in the future even if you can't do anything about all the ones granted for this calendar year.

If you can't understand that simple logic -- regardless of what your opinion on it is -- you really shouldn't be calling other posters dumb.
The biggest confusion of SEC communications and posters on this board is not specifying whether these cases are related to the 5 For 5 rule or not.

Edwards case is based on successful challenges to the 5 For 5 rule applying back to the high school class of 2022 and the argument that certain pro camps or whatever would not have happened had they known they had a year of eligibility remaining.

RJ Luis' is not.

That's why there is a different response. Edwards case is certainly part of huge mess but would set no future precedent since it only applies to this specific between year in 5 For 5.


Luis' -- like Bediako's -- would challenge the entire NCAA rules about NBA/NFL contracts going forward since they have nothing to do with the 5 For 5 exception.


Seems there tons of posters that do not know how different these cases are:

Avila at TCU is based on challenges to the 5 For 5 rule applying to the high school class of 2022

RJ Luis' is not.


That's why there is a different response. Avila's case would set no future precedent since it only applies to this specific between year in 5 For 5.

Luis' -- like Bediako's -- would challenge the entire NCAA rules about NBA/NFL contracts going forward since they have nothing to do with the 5 For 5 exception.

re: Why did LSU remove RJ Luis?

Posted by wm72 on 11/20/26 at 2:07 pm to
quote:

So, they came to the conclusion that they would not punish LSU. But, then cannot control their members from voting LSU out


The logic is pretty simple.

SEC can't punish LSU by any kind of suspensions, fines or whatnot due to the TRO.

But, since they want SEC programs themselves to honor an agreement to stop pursuing/honoring these kind of local TROs that blur any pro eligibility rules beyond what is addressed by 5 For 5, the SEC wouldn't necessarily be "punishing" LSU as a member as much as voting to part ways if LSU does want to follow those guidelines.


(Reminder that this specific Luis case is different than all the others because it is not based on the 5 For 5 rule being applied retroactively to the Freshman 2022 class)








The letter may need to address that B.J. Edwards pursued a fifth season of eligibility for this season through lawsuits challenging how the NCAA's "Five-for-Five" rule was applied to the high school graduating class of 2022.

Isn't he more comparable to the football players arguing that the only reason they "went pro" was not knowing lawsuits would eventually give them an extra year of eligibility?

re: Why did LSU remove RJ Luis?

Posted by wm72 on 11/20/26 at 1:16 pm to

Yeah, the SEC bylaws state that members can vote for whatever reason to expel a program.

The TRO meant the SEC couldn't, say, suspend Wade for playing Luis.

However, it would have nothing to do with whether or not members could simply vote to expel LSU from the conference for whatever reason they stated.

The conjecture in the article posted is that LSU leadership thought there was no chance of other members voting for simple expulsion and then found out there was.


Sankey completely blew a gasket last winter over the Bediako TRO. He argued in court that it could lead to an infinite series of local judges issuing TROs over the boundary between NFL/NBA and college. The Alabama Supreme Court echoed Sankey's argument in ruling against Bediako.


It's still puzzling why LSU would try the exact same case just a few months later, especially after the SEC scrambled to shore up even more specific rules against it.

I would guess the differences:

1. whether applying the new 5 For 5 rule to last year's seniors would have given them an extra year.


2. Big 10 and SEC are trying harder to enforce the NO NFL/ NBA PRO boundary than some other conferences, especially the Big East.


Sankey has been blowing a gasket about it since the Alabama/Bediako BS where he successfully argued that it was going to lead to "an infinite series of unevely applied local court cases to obtain TROs". Alabama Supreme Court eventually echoed his argument in their dismissal of Bediako appeal.


re: Wins against current top 25 teams

Posted by wm72 on 11/20/26 at 9:23 am to
quote:

The only reason South Carolina and Ole Miss are still ranked is to prop up Alabama.


Perhaps South Carolina is ranked because they're one of the very few teams that has 3 wins over Top 25 teams?


Almost every SEC fan on this board has argued for the committee to place more weight on SOS.

The SEC schedule is tough because of exactly what that graphic shows: how many teams on SEC conference schedules are more than capable of beating good teams on their day.

Georgia's a performance metric juggernaut right now.

Bama and Auburn are getting huge metric numbers bumps from their games against UGA.

Bama's other metrics are strong based on dismantling Kemtucky, soundly beating LSU ( very significantly both in Away games) and the S. Carolina game.

It's really not the mystery people are making it out to be.

It will also change some, if sayTennessee beats LSU soundly, for example.
Funny seeing the "just based on objective reason and law" arguments completely flip flop when it involves Oats instead of Wade.
Tennessee is simply lagging behind in all the efficiency metrics right now.
Win out impressively and that will change.

Fans of programs with good basketball like Tennessee should be aware of the significance of those metrics in seeding, which rhe football committee is now using too since the stink SEC fans made about SOS.

quote:

That means every team between them the pollsters think are better than LSU but worse than Texas. That’s a tight window considering LSU was a few seconds away from winning.


Great point. It underlines how much the polls move on rewarding wins.

On the other hand, the analytics for Texas @LSU or Georgia @Alabama plugged out 2 almost equal teams.
Izan Alamansa is ok to play for Gonzaga but it’s an evil thing to play RJ Luis go right ahead.

quote:



Alamansa played for Real Madrid in Europe.


Played 48 games for NBA G league team. Which he voluntarily entered. From 2023-2024

Went back to Europe.


Played in the NBA Summer league. In 2025



This inconsistency regarding foreign players is what the Bediako case was arguing.



Funny how vehemently LSU fans were against it then and so many Alabama fans for it.



This was the premise of the Bediako lawsuit.
quote:

You mean a few weeks later when a local redneck judge in Mississippi gave Chambliss a 6th year?

Or in June and July, when multiple pro players in basketball and football joined SEC teams?


Whatboutisms that are BS but apples to oranges.

Chambliss = redshirt injury loopholes. BS but very different BS with long precedent of being litigated on a case by case basis (unlike NBA contracts)

June and July multiple pro players = Every single one of them arguing for an exception granted on still being eligible under the new 5 For 5 rule. (which does not apply in the least to Luis who's 24 and 6 years out of being a Freshman now)

quote:

He committed to LSU. Will wade had no way of knowing a Baton Rouge judge would rule him eligible.



He committed to LSU after an offer LSU made to him as an ineligible 24yo who had signed multiple NBA/ G League contracts.
quote:

Now show me where the NCAA punished Alabama for Bediako.


That everyone from the NCAA to Sankey / SEC leaders to every single fan on this board blew a gasket arguing what utter BS the Bediako situation was actually makes it worse to try the exact same thing a few months later.

Especially since that ended with Bediako being declared ineligible as per the clear rules against NBA/G League contracts.

And every one argued that Alabama deserved stiffer penalties and should have been left out of the NCAA tourney if he had continued to play.


If LSU needs to let Luis play 3 games in January while dealing with a media shite show distraction and then declare him ineligible for the rest of the season just so they can say they did what Alabama could do, FINE by most fans.


Otherwise, bringing up Bediako emphasizes how blatant it is to try that exact same thing again.