Started By
Message

re: The MAGA failed narrative…

Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:48 am to
Posted by Sam Quint
Member since Sep 2022
10227 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:48 am to
quote:


It's a combination of lots of things

1. Normal people just got tired of it all. This is probably the biggest thing.

2. Trump diehards didn't get what they wanted (mass deportation, codifying DOGE, etc.0

3. The admin just kept fricking up (tariffs, birthright citizenship, etc.) in stupid ways.

4. Trump kept focusing on stupid stuff and engaging in his online bullshite, and when normal people told those in the Idiocracy to stop promoting the stupidity, puffery, shite-talking, and just looking like dumb people, they were called pussies or other

5. Iran.

6. The economy (including inflation and affordability). The admin not only didn't do anything to help, it floated all sorts of policies that would protect high prices (50-year mortgages, Trump outwardly telling seniors he'd protect the price of their homes, etc.)

7. Epstein. This wasn't big but a certain diehard group felt absolutely betrayed by the admin and all the 180s.

8. Losing youth support. This is a combination of lots of the above (+ Israel). But MAGA lost the young vote (especially white males) this election.

9. The over-aggression of ICE and immigration policy was terrible for moderate support and Latino support.

one of the more fair and balanced posts i've seen from SFP. mostly agree with all of it except the "over aggression of ICE". the perceived over aggression was mainly a result of media spin, with no consideration that the reason they were so heavily engaged was due to the virtually completely open Biden border.

but yeah, pretty solid post.
Posted by AUCom96
Alabama
Member since May 2020
7443 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:49 am to
The issue to fight is corruption, which can only be fought by putting distance between big money and national politics. It's a monumental challenge and Trump proved not only incapable, but another example of how big of a problem it is.

Until that issue is successfully attacked, no other issue is anything more than empty political cannon fodder.
Posted by Tigersforthee
Member since Dec 2025
1461 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:50 am to
But we did get a closed border and a lot of deportations. And these deportations werent from people apprehended at the border, they were all apprehended in country. You can certainly discuss other things the administration could do better but no other administration in our lifetimes has clamped down on the southern border like this one and thats not something to casually toss aside.
Posted by Jake88
Member since Apr 2005
82541 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:53 am to
quote:

Now imagine if ICE had only gone after illegal immigrants with outstanding felony warrants
That isnt what was promised.
Posted by roadGator
DeBoar’s hollow dome
Member since Feb 2009
161578 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:53 am to
SFP is usually spot on. But that triggers folks.

He’s still has a giant savior complex though.

Posted by Chuck Barris
Member since Apr 2013
3924 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:53 am to
quote:

The admin got too focused on muh fight and it led to disastrous results
Why, it's almost as if Trump is primarily driven by his own personal relationships, whims, and grievances instead of a coherent political philosophy!
Posted by CajunInVirginia
Virginia not by choice...
Member since Sep 2021
346 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:57 am to
MAGA Agends couls have made more progress if not for Thune.
Posted by Chuck Barris
Member since Apr 2013
3924 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:57 am to
quote:

That isnt what was promised.
You're right, but the number of MAGA folks who would've stayed home or switched parties because grandmas who had lived in the country for twenty years without causing any problems weren't being deported would have been a hell of a lot smaller than the number of Latinos who voted Republican in 2024 but stayed home or switched parties in this election.
Posted by SlowFlowPro
With populists, expect populism
Member since Jan 2004
488261 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:58 am to
quote:

and then sent out a bunch of masked

Masking ICE agents was so stupid. It was like they were trying to look like fascist cosplay.
Posted by Robot Santa
Member since Oct 2009
47163 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 7:59 am to
quote:

Why, it's almost as if Trump is primarily driven by his own personal relationships, whims, and grievances instead of a coherent political philosophy!


If only we had decades of his public commentary and behavior to assess his character with.
Posted by SlowFlowPro
With populists, expect populism
Member since Jan 2004
488261 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 8:00 am to
quote:

with no consideration that the reason they were so heavily engaged was due to the virtually completely open Biden border.

There weren't riots in Minneapolis "completely due to the open Biden border"

It was dumb to make such a spectacle in such a blue city. But it made the muh fight people very happy.
Posted by SlowFlowPro
With populists, expect populism
Member since Jan 2004
488261 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 8:01 am to
quote:

Why, it's almost as if Trump is primarily driven by his own personal relationships, whims, and grievances instead of a coherent political philosophy!

This is more trusting/following the wrong people, ie Stephen Miller
Posted by SquatchDawg
Cohutta Wilderness
Member since Sep 2012
21192 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 8:02 am to
quote:

The major issue with both Trump admins is that they're terrible at governance. This is a Stephen Miller problem.


The more you hear of the election post mortum it sounds like Pub leadership and the donor class has zero understanding of what the voters want or just are used to not caring. Just a small bit of strategy in the WH and we’re in a different position. You don’t go for checkmate on the 3rd move.

For example, in SC, trying to push Lindsey light was the dumbest thing ever. I don’t know any Pubs that liked Lindsey and assumed the power brokers knew this. Apparently not.
Posted by AGGIES
Member since Jul 2021
14594 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 8:02 am to
The deal with the ICE raids is that going after abuelas only appeals to a fraction of his supporters, the hard-core Stephen Miller faction.

The majority of the voters would probably accept it and look away if all the other things that they wanted were being handled correctly.

They would only put up with it if they were otherwise happy.
Posted by SlowFlowPro
With populists, expect populism
Member since Jan 2004
488261 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 8:02 am to
quote:

SFP is usually spot on. But that triggers folks.

Nothing in that post is novel and was stated in real time....to a different reception
Posted by Robot Santa
Member since Oct 2009
47163 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 8:03 am to
quote:

Masking ICE agents was so stupid. It was like they were trying to look like fascist cosplay.


If the jackboot fits...

Trump has no political ideology other than self enrichment and using the power of his office to prosecute petty grievances, but Stephen Miller is absolutely a fascist and he is the one in charge of immigration policy, among other things.
Posted by SquatchDawg
Cohutta Wilderness
Member since Sep 2012
21192 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 8:03 am to
Everything here is correct.
Posted by SlowFlowPro
With populists, expect populism
Member since Jan 2004
488261 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 8:04 am to
quote:

The more you hear of the election post mortum it sounds like Pub leadership and the donor class has zero understanding of what the voters want

It's not GOP leadership. It's Trump.

Trump wanted Graham's sister.

Trump and his cronies went after Massie.

Trump promoted shitty candidates like Letlow (who barely won), Paxton, etc. over those more close to the actual GOP leadership.

Posted by Rip Torner
Member since Jul 2023
4838 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 8:05 am to
I’m sorry I thought you supported enforcing the border but the reality is your version of enforcing the border equates to nothing more than empty words. You are exactly the kind of voter Guatemalans are relying on, congrats!
Posted by frogtown
Member since Aug 2017
6157 posts
Posted on 11/19/26 at 8:06 am to
quote:

It's a combination of lots of things

1. Normal people just got tired of it all. This is probably the biggest thing.



I agree. MAGA folk are in denial about this.

I have a term for this. I call it "in your face" government.
first pageprev pagePage 2 of 8Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

Facebook•X•Instagram