re: It seems Mamoud khalil will likely win his immigration court hearing.

quote:

---

Yes, an immigration judge is a federal judge. However a federal court judge in New York or New Jersey will hear other aspects of his case, such as his first amendment rights or lack there of.

---

No dummy. It goes to the BIA. You sure do think you know a lot about stuff you know nothing about.

quote:

---

The New Jersey court lacks jurisdiction. That case will soon be transferred rightfully to the Western District of Louisiana, Alexandria Division. Any appeals will the go to the New Orleans based US Fifth Circuit.

Sorry to burst your bubble.

---

Thanks for answering this. It makes sense. As I understand it, you have to exhaust immigration court remedies before you can apply for habeas relief with a federal district court.

quote:

---

he'll soon sit in front of an federal judge.
----
He already has.
Don't be foolish.
----
You probably know what I mean, but maybe you don't

---

I assumed you meant what you said. Apparently I was wrong?

quote:

---

Well he has a habeas case right now pending in New Jersey.

---

I know. I didn't see where the DOJ filed a motion to dismiss as premature because Administrative Remedies (immigration court) hadn't been exhausted.

Watching LSU baseball. Will check when I can.

quote:

---

Maybe it'll get transferred to Louisiana, maybe not. But right now, it's New Jersey.

---

Which is illegal.

quote:

---

I really don't know.

---

I know enough for both of us and you could know too if you have the combination of 45 seconds of free time and an ounce of intellectual curiosity.

My guess is you're flush with the former and lean with the latter.

quote:

---

nah. Executive branch has authority to deport a non-citizen for any reason they want w/out due process.

---

Is this true? I know what the alien act and the sedition act is but didn’t know that’s what it says.

Ignoring my opinions on this particular case, that seems like a lot of unfettered power to give one person

quote:

---

I know enough for both of us and you could know too if you have the combination of 45 seconds of free time and an ounce of intellectual curiosity.

My guess is you're flush with the former and lean with the latter.

---

Well I haven't had an opportunity to research who or what decides where his habeas case is heard. Do you know? I'd like to know, really. Because right now it's set to be heard in New Jersey. Who decides whether or not it's moved?

Pandy I appreciate your tenacity. Here was what I found with AI which suggests that the New Jersey case is subject to dismissal as being premature....

Filing a habeas corpus petition before exhausting all available immigration remedies is generally not allowed. The principle of exhaustion of remedies requires that a petitioner must first present their claims to the highest state court before seeking relief in federal court, and similarly, in the context of immigration, all available administrative and judicial remedies within the immigration system must be exhausted first.

However, there are exceptions to this rule. If the petitioner can demonstrate that pursuing further state or immigration remedies would be futile, result in undue delay, or cause irreparable harm, they may be excused from the exhaustion requirement.

In summary, while exhaustion of remedies is typically required, there are circumstances under which a habeas corpus petition can be filed before all immigration remedies have been exhausted.