Robert E. Lee questions

quote:

---

Did he feel remorse for joining the CSA?

---

I actually asked him this yesterday. He said "nah, dog."

I doubt he thought there would be statues.

Even if he didn't regret fighting for the CSA and for Virginia specifically, he still fought for the losing side. I've never read much about his life after the Civil War, so maybe someone else can enlighten me on what Lee was thinking in his final days. Specifically, I'd like to know what he thought about his time in the Confederacy.

And the whole erection of statues and the "Lost Cause" came up many decades after his death. I don't think a lot of Confederates and Southerners were eager to talk or think about monuments during their time.

quote:

---

he had to know that someone would probably make a statue of him at some point...and further down the road people would want to knock it down.

---

i would think an intelligent man would think time heals all wounds...not that people get more offended as time goes by

quote:

---

would think an intelligent man would think time heals all wounds...not that people get more offended as time goes by

---

Still can't hunt Pokémon at Auschwitz without pissing people off.

quote:

---

Did he feel remorse for joining the CSA?

---

It has widely been discussed that common sentiment and identity in those days was that people considered themselves residents of their towns and sovereign states FIRST and U.S. citizens a distant second.

Lee and Beauregard, while proud of their U.S. Army positions, and their connections to West Point and the army, were Virginian and Louisianan above even that.The Civil War profoundly changed that, and the 10th Amendment has been weaker since. I don't have all the history on that, but many mark the Civil War as the beginning point of the much more powerful government in Washington than previously.

quote:

---

Still can't hunt Pokémon at Auschwitz without pissing people off.

---

Why would you want to hunt Pokemon at Auschwitz anyway? Probably catch nothing but Gastly all day

Plus if I am not mistaken Lee designed portions of the levies and other structures around New Orleans when he was in the predecessor to the Corp of Engineers before he took over VMI before the start of Civil War.

quote:

---

Plus if I am not mistaken Lee designed portions of the levies and other structures around New Orleans when he was in the predecessor to the Corp of Engineer

---

Should be really erect monuments to these people?

I don't think the lower 9th is building a GW Bush statue anytime soon.

quote:

---

It has widely been discussed that common sentiment and identity in those days was that people considered themselves residents of their towns and sovereign states FIRST and U.S. citizens a distant second.

---

Exactly. As Shelby Foote said in the Ken Burns documentary, before the Civil War, people the phrase was "The United States are..." afterward it became "The United States is..."

After the war, Lee believed that the issues that caused the war had been settled - and that God had made his decision and passed judgment.

He asks his former soldiers to lay down their arms, and they do. Many believe that if Lee had not been as prestigious as he was, and held in such high esteem by his men, the great peace that followed the war would not have happened.

He still believed that his loyalty was to his state, telling a friend ""I cannot desert my native state in the hour of her adversity. I must abide her fortune, and share her fate."

But he also wanted the country to remain united. During his time as president of Washington College (now Washington and Lee University) he wrote to a bitter Confederate widow, "Dismiss from your mind all sectional feeling, and bring [your children] up to be Americans."

Mitch has single handedly destroyed a great part of the Legacy of a once great city. People are starting to hate part of our own state. This could be the straw that breaks the camels back. The sad thing is, he is doing it for what he sees as his own political gain. He is being paid. And he has his eyes set on running for a national office.