Started By
Message

Explain the difference please

Posted on 9/27/26 at 6:52 pm
Posted by Yippie_Ky_yae
Member since Jun 2019
4876 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 6:52 pm
Posted by Big Jim Slade
Member since Oct 2016
6450 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 6:53 pm to
The call obviously depends on what side the Saints are on.
Posted by Friedbrie
Colorado Springs
Member since Jun 2018
1643 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 6:53 pm to
different teams
Posted by MetArl15
Washington, DC
Member since Apr 2007
14265 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 6:54 pm to
The Lions one was a bad call. The Saints one wasn’t. The inconsistency suggests bad refereeing across the league.
Posted by gaetti15
AK
Member since Apr 2013
16179 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 6:56 pm to
quote:

The Lions one was a bad call. The Saints one wasn’t. The inconsistency suggests bad refereeing across the league.


100%

I just dont get it
Posted by NawlinsTiger9
Where the mongooses roam
Member since Jan 2009
41406 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 6:56 pm to
The only difference is that we lost 1 game on the receiving end of the rule and then lost another game on the giving end
Posted by FournetteForEver7
Member since Nov 2015
2614 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 6:57 pm to
They called the nfl office to get the ruling
Posted by TurdAndChavis
Member since Aug 2019
268 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 6:59 pm to
I want answers!
Posted by IvoryBillMatt
Member since Mar 2020
13284 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 7:01 pm to
quote:

The Lions one was a bad call. The Saints one wasn’t. The inconsistency suggests bad refereeing across the league.


We were told how stupid we were...that the rule was if the QB had started lifting the ball up with the intent to pass the ball.

OK. That's the rule. Shough didn't fumble.
This post was edited on 9/27/26 at 7:03 pm
Posted by lsusteve1
Member since Dec 2004
49886 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 7:03 pm to
quote:

The Lions one was a bad call. The Saints one wasn’t. The inconsistency suggests bad refereeing across the league.


Gene the rules expert explained the differences even though there was NONE

Script followed
Posted by NorthshoreTiger76
Pelicans, Saints, & LSU Fan
Member since May 2009
85032 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 7:04 pm to
They both should have been fumbles
Posted by Tiger985
Member since Nov 2006
8045 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 7:08 pm to
The league would say Goffs hand was going forward so the fact that Goff ball went backward is irrelevant. Because his throwing motion started before he was hit.

Shough arm was not going forward so his was just a fumble.

Reality is they were both fumbles but that's the distinction the league will make
Posted by Bayou
Boudin, LA
Member since Feb 2005
44299 posts
Posted on 9/27/26 at 7:54 pm to
I thought Shuck's arm was in the act of passing AND going forward. How else did the ball go forward?
Posted by ShoeBang
Member since May 2012
22586 posts
Posted on 9/28/26 at 6:08 am to
If the call was right week 1 then they got it wrong week 3

If the call was wrong week 1 they got it right week 3

They should have to pick one and explain. They are either bad at their jobs or liars, but there’s no other explanations that would make sense to anyone that’s not literally retarded
Posted by Athis
I AM Charlie Kirk....
Member since Aug 2016
17322 posts
Posted on 9/28/26 at 9:54 am to
Posted by Ryan3232
Valet driver for TD staff
Member since Dec 2008
28438 posts
Posted on 9/28/26 at 10:40 am to
quote:


The Lions one was a bad call. The Saints one wasn’t. The inconsistency suggests bad refereeing across the league.
This is what I'm angry about. Prior to the Lions game, I would have never batted an eye at the fumble call on Shough in this play.

However, the way our "rules expert" Mike Pereira explicitly stated that "Goff had already started his throwing motion with the intent to throw it forward." This makes me want to sit him in a chair and ask, if that is what the rule book says, how can you not see that Shough was in his throwing motion. And honestly, he was further in the progression than Goff was.

There shouldn't be RULES that are open to interpretation. It's why people think the NFL is part of a gambling conspiracy when shite like this happens.
Posted by geauxpurple
New Orleans
Member since Jul 2014
18426 posts
Posted on 9/28/26 at 11:31 am to
There are two commonalities-
Both plays were identical and both calls screwed the Saints.
Posted by Chad504boy
4 posts
Member since Feb 2005
182167 posts
Posted on 9/28/26 at 11:33 am to
quote:

If the call was right week 1 then they got it wrong week 3

If the call was wrong week 1 they got it right week 3

They should have to pick one and explain. They are either bad at their jobs or liars, but there’s no other explanations that would make sense to anyone that’s not literally retarded



More clues, both calls were correct as called on field. Only 1 was OVERTURNED to a completely wrong call.
Posted by BZ504
Texas
Member since Oct 2005
15061 posts
Posted on 9/28/26 at 1:17 pm to
Mike Pereria needs to hang it up. He was completely wrong in the Detroit game. I would to hear his explanation of how those situations are different.
Posted by goatmilker
With Chinese expect nationalism
Member since Feb 2009
79036 posts
Posted on 9/29/26 at 6:08 pm to
Well the intent was different you see so really we can say wtf we want to.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

Facebook•X•Instagram