re: Williams, Daniels, Maye, JJ (lol), Bo, or Penix Jr.? Who ends up having the best career?

Williams has a mentality made of glass. Anyone with eyes saw that coming from a mile away. We'll see if he can mature, but it's not looking good.

Daniels looked very good past night. If he can work on his progressions, he will be very good. He does look scrawny so he definitely can't be taking unnecessary hits.

THAT KID

quote:

---

I barely heard him talked about on college football shows, social media, etc...

All the hype is coming from NFL media crowning him the next Patrick Mahomes.

---

I think he is gonna be a huge bust, but you just weren't paying attention if you didn't hear about him in college. He won the heisman ffs. I certainly saw way too much of him before all the draft hype started. Been sick of that dude for a while.

quote:

---

Trade out of #1 for a kings ransom

---

if they had a smart GM they would've done this. but their GM and admin are insanely stupid.

Agree mostly with the list, maybe a couple exceptions.

Daniels - I think he'll turn out the best because he quietly does all the things that makes an NFL QB be successful. Mainly, he doesn't turn the ball over. Look at his time in college and he makes the smart play and doesn't try and overextend his abilities. Turnovers in the NFL are the key indicator of losing. The numbers are stark.

Maye / JJ / Penix - No real idea yet, haven't seen enough of any of them. Penix may have injury issues that shortens his career, but you can't really predict that.

Bo - WIll be around a long time because of his natural abilities, but unlike Daniels, he doesn't do the things well that align with NFL success. He turns the ball over too often and isn't accurate enough when he needs to be.

Williams - The guy is a head case with great arm talent. He makes the great unscripted splash plays that makes everyone fall in love with him, but really struggles on your typical "system" and game management. He's just bad at the basics. Maybe he can clean that up, but he'll have to mature quickly.

quote:

---

What I found the most interesting is that the consensus was that Daniels wouldn’t bust and the overall consensus was that Williams would.

---

we're on tigerdroppings. That wasn't the consensus everywhere else.

quote:

---

Maye has everything you need to be a top 3 QB but I wonder if he is a system QB. He also makes a ton of terrible decisions.

---

He is in arguably the worst situation

Well we are but fans of teams aside from LSU we’re saying the same.

It isn’t like this was an only LSU narrative

quote:

---

Daniels- Lots of potential to be elite
Maye- BUST, just does not impress me much
Bo- will be shockingly good in a few years
Penix Jr.- Teddy Bridgewater type of career
Williams- the next Dak Prescott
JJ- another Zac Wilson

---

So far I’m doing well with my projections outside of Penix and JJ

Problem is, nothing long-term will be answered after the season, and Penix and JJ won't have anything to judge.

Maye is in a shitty situation in NE, hard to really know with him being thrown into that fire.

I think that its safe to say that Daniels is the real deal though, and barring injury, he will have the best career.

Bo has look promising as well.

Williams is basically what everyone thought it he is.