- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Magnolia tree
Posted on 2/28/24 at 9:15 am
Posted on 2/28/24 at 9:15 am
pros/cons of Magnolia trees
Posted on 2/28/24 at 9:35 am to bluewing
I live them and think they are some of the most beautiful trees out there. Many hate the leaves they shed but that doesn’t bother me because I have a lawnmower. The Little Gem magnolias are great.
Posted on 2/28/24 at 9:36 am to bluewing
quote:
pros
Bloooms
quote:
cons
Leaves
Posted on 2/28/24 at 9:48 am to bluewing
nothing but pros. spring flowers, great smell, beautiful leaves, native to our area, hard wood tree, doesnt drop branches.
Cons are the cones but a mover takes those out
Cons are the cones but a mover takes those out
Posted on 2/28/24 at 9:59 am to bluewing
Cons - leaves, cones, red seeds, wasps, low clearance
Pros - not as ugly as some other trees
Pros - not as ugly as some other trees
Posted on 2/28/24 at 10:18 am to bluewing
I love Magnolias. I was going to plant a Magnolia Stelatta "Jane Platt" one this year. I love the pink and white blooms.
Posted on 2/28/24 at 2:03 pm to bluewing
Cons: leaves, cones, bare ground underneath, shallow/above-ground roots.
Pros: beautiful tree, blooms, southern icon
Pros: beautiful tree, blooms, southern icon
Posted on 2/28/24 at 2:47 pm to bluewing
I had one that was near my driveway and I got tired of it dropping leaves that blew into the garage. I left the one in my yard.
They can be grown with branches down to the ground and they look like huge topiaries. I wish I knew about this earlier.

They can be grown with branches down to the ground and they look like huge topiaries. I wish I knew about this earlier.

Posted on 2/28/24 at 3:24 pm to bluewing
I grew up in the Lower 9th Ward in an old shotgun house and the neighbor right next door had 2 HUGE magnolia trees right on his side of the fence of the property line.
I hated those trees with a passion as a kid since I was the one who had to rake up all the damn leaves, pick up all the damn cones they eventually dropped and washed lots of bird crap off cars once they ate the red seeds the cones made. My dad died when I was 8 and I took over a lot of his chores.
They drop leaves year round and it's not like you can pile them up and they will compost since they are thick and waxy leaves. They take forever even after mulching with a mower.
I remember begging my mom to have someone cut the limbs on our side of the fence, but she wouldn't------until I moved out at 17 and it fell on her and my 2 sisters to deal with it. THEN they got cut----damn trees looked like a couple of "P's" when they were done.
I hated those trees with a passion as a kid since I was the one who had to rake up all the damn leaves, pick up all the damn cones they eventually dropped and washed lots of bird crap off cars once they ate the red seeds the cones made. My dad died when I was 8 and I took over a lot of his chores.
They drop leaves year round and it's not like you can pile them up and they will compost since they are thick and waxy leaves. They take forever even after mulching with a mower.
I remember begging my mom to have someone cut the limbs on our side of the fence, but she wouldn't------until I moved out at 17 and it fell on her and my 2 sisters to deal with it. THEN they got cut----damn trees looked like a couple of "P's" when they were done.
This post was edited on 2/28/24 at 3:28 pm
Posted on 2/28/24 at 4:49 pm to bluewing
Cons- they're messy as hell
The old lady in the neighborhood said they belong in the woods. I agree
The old lady in the neighborhood said they belong in the woods. I agree
Posted on 2/28/24 at 5:04 pm to ABucks11
I was once told that Magnolia is a giant shrub.
Letting it grow to the ground, "mounding" hides what is an awful mess behind a thick green wall.
If you don't have the room for that, be prepared for a mix of mess and work, follow very soon thereafter by more mess, in perpetuity.
But they are beautiful. And worth it, in my opinion
Letting it grow to the ground, "mounding" hides what is an awful mess behind a thick green wall.
If you don't have the room for that, be prepared for a mix of mess and work, follow very soon thereafter by more mess, in perpetuity.
But they are beautiful. And worth it, in my opinion
This post was edited on 3/4/24 at 10:29 am
Posted on 2/29/24 at 7:07 am to luvdoc
^^^This. Don't force the tree to be what it is not, and you won't have nearly as much mess. Yes, they do shed, but most falls within the drip line. Do not remove the lower branches, or select the right tree for the space.
Posted on 2/29/24 at 9:19 am to bluewing
Regular magnolias are very messy.
Little Gems do not drop as many leaves and they do not get as large as the regular magnolias.
Little Gems do not drop as many leaves and they do not get as large as the regular magnolias.
Posted on 2/29/24 at 8:25 pm to bluewing
Got 2 in the front yard. Pain in the arse.
Posted on 3/2/24 at 5:38 pm to TDsngumbo
I recall they are very dusty. They have pretty flowers but create a lot of cleanup
Posted on 3/2/24 at 6:59 pm to sosaysmorvant
I was against them, but the Mrs. insisted on 2 magnolia trees. We compromised on little gem magnolias and they are great trees. The leaf drop is very manageable, and they are gorgeous bloomers.
Posted on 3/4/24 at 7:59 am to bluewing
They are pretty. But the leaves are terrible. They fall year round.
Popular
Back to top
