- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Cookie cake is not as good as I remember it
Posted on 6/12/22 at 8:05 pm
Posted on 6/12/22 at 8:05 pm
Early 90s birthday parties that had a cookie cake were GOAT. Nothing better than a square slice of cookie cake with the vanilla and chocolate frosting when you’re a sugar-hyped 10 year old.
My wife wanted a small one for her birthday and I obliged, of course. We hadn’t had one in years, if not decades.
The cookie portion is just not what I remembered. Very thin and kind of oily. It tastes okay but it’s so sweet that after a few bites I was done. I just remembered the actual cookie part of the cake being better.
Bought it from from Great American Cookie Company, if that makes any difference. Expensive for what it is. Like $38 for the smallest one.
Also wife was happy so that’s all that really matters.
My wife wanted a small one for her birthday and I obliged, of course. We hadn’t had one in years, if not decades.
The cookie portion is just not what I remembered. Very thin and kind of oily. It tastes okay but it’s so sweet that after a few bites I was done. I just remembered the actual cookie part of the cake being better.
Bought it from from Great American Cookie Company, if that makes any difference. Expensive for what it is. Like $38 for the smallest one.
Also wife was happy so that’s all that really matters.
13
Posted on 6/12/22 at 8:19 pm to LSUZombie
Their m&m chocolate chip cookies are fire
Posted on 6/12/22 at 8:27 pm to LSUZombie
Which location did you purchase from? Great American cookie cake has been my staple b-day cake for years and I absolutely love them. Always put a few pieces in the fridge to get cold and indulge for breakfast.
Posted on 6/12/22 at 8:29 pm to 9BREES9
Juban location.
They had them stacked up for people to pickup so they’re certainly not hurting for business. Also you can now get it in various cookie flavors, which is interesting
They had them stacked up for people to pickup so they’re certainly not hurting for business. Also you can now get it in various cookie flavors, which is interesting
Posted on 6/12/22 at 9:42 pm to LSUZombie
Cookie cakes are trashy
Posted on 6/12/22 at 9:44 pm to LSUZombie
quote:
Nothing better than a square slice of cookie cake with the vanilla and chocolate frosting when you’re a sugar-hyped 10 year old.
Ice cream cake
Posted on 6/12/22 at 10:19 pm to LSUZombie
$38 for a cookie cake?
Posted on 6/12/22 at 10:36 pm to LSUZombie
I've made them myself and they come out better. Those store bought ones have some sort of after taste.
Throw some parchment paper down on the counter. Get a big roll of cookie dough. Roll it out with a rolling pin. Put on a pizza pan and bake. Cheaper and better.
Throw some parchment paper down on the counter. Get a big roll of cookie dough. Roll it out with a rolling pin. Put on a pizza pan and bake. Cheaper and better.
Posted on 6/12/22 at 11:05 pm to LSUZombie
They are always disappointing. Gummy overly sugary cookie glop and cheap icing.
Posted on 6/13/22 at 6:56 am to LSUZombie
I’ve always grabbed from the Southland Mall location in Houma. Never been disappointed; now that could be bc not many people frequent that mall so they can focus on how to properly make the cakes 
Posted on 6/13/22 at 8:18 am to LSUZombie
A Duncan Hines box cake is better than that shite.
Posted on 6/13/22 at 8:29 am to LSUZombie
If I’m going to splurge calories on something sugary cookie cake doesn’t even make the list. Chips Ahoy are much better.
Posted on 6/13/22 at 8:39 am to HeyCap
quote:
Chips Ahoy are much better.
Chips Ahoy…those are arguably the worst store brand cookies. Weird flavor that doesn’t take like a cookie along with this unsatisfactory chewiness to them.
Posted on 6/13/22 at 8:48 am to caro81
The icing they use on those cookie cakes is the absolute worst.
Posted on 6/13/22 at 9:19 am to LSUZombie
Sam's does a double decker cookie cake for around $20- Great buy for the money.
Posted on 6/13/22 at 9:24 am to moontigr
quote:
The icing they use on those cookie cakes is the absolute worst.
What's wrong with Crisco and powdered sugar?
Posted on 6/13/22 at 12:39 pm to GentleJackJones
quote:
Chips Ahoy…those are arguably the worst store brand cookies. Weird flavor that doesn’t take like a cookie along with this unsatisfactory chewiness to them.
That was my point. The worst mass manufactured cookie is >> mall cookie cakes.
And chewy? Who would by anything other than original? Salty? Yes. Not chewy.
Posted on 6/13/22 at 1:00 pm to HeyCap
Still love a great American cookie cake.
The icing always gets scraped off though
The icing always gets scraped off though
Posted on 6/13/22 at 1:05 pm to LSUZombie
There is a lot of variance in them. The recent ones I've had have been cooked way too long. You get that one that is still questionably just dough. 
Posted on 6/13/22 at 2:37 pm to LSUZombie
quote:
Cookie cake is not as good as I remember it
Try the Sam's double layer cookie cake and get back to me
Page 1 of 2
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News