Started By
Message

Today is the 162nd anniversary of Pickett's Charge...

Posted on 7/3/25 at 7:45 am
Posted by RollTide1987
Augusta, GA
Member since Nov 2009
69159 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 7:45 am
July 3, 1863. Gettysburg, Pennsylvania.

The Battle of Gettysburg had been raging for the past two days and had, by that point, already become the bloodiest battle in American history. But Lee wanted to break what he saw as a tactical stalemate by launching an all or nothing frontal assault on the center of the Union position. The plan that was eventually drawn up on paper involved the massing of Confederate artillery (roughly 150 cannon in all) to fire on Cemetery Ridge. Believing this position to be the weakest point the Federal line, the idea was to soften it up further.

Following this, three divisions of Confederate infantry (roughly 13,000 men in all) were to advance across the no-man's-land between the two armies and split the Union center. This force would be commanded by Lt. General James Longstreet and would consist of the divisions of George Pickett, Dorsey Pender (commanded by Isaac Trimble) and Henry Heth (commanded by J.J. Pettigrew). Should a proper breach in the Union line be made, this assault would be followed up by the divisions of Richard Anderson and Robert Rodes to exploit the breach. Meanwhile, Confederate cavalry under the command of the recently-arrived JEB Stuart would cause chaos and confusion in the rear to prevent Federal reinforcements from reaching the area where the assault was taking place.

The artillery bombardment would last for about 90 minutes but would prove to be ineffective. The infantry assault would go forward in good order and cross the nearly mile of open ground while eating Federal artillery fire for almost the entire march. The left wing of the assault (that of Pettigrew and Trimble) was pulverized in the area of Zeigler's Grove by massed Union infantry under the command of Alexander Hays. Pickett's division had better success against the division of John Gibbon around the low stonewall, with one brigade of Confederate infantry under the command of Lewis Armistead even breaking through temporarily. However, Union reinforcements rushed into the breach and killed or captured every single Confederate who made it over the wall.

In just over an hour the battle was over. The Confederate forces had lost 1,123 men killed, 4,019 wounded, and 1,358 either captured or missing. Union casualties were considerably lighter (268 killed and 1,232 wounded). Additionally, JEB Stuart's end around run of the Army of the Potomac's right flank was stopped by cavalry under the command of George Armstrong Custer, ending that part of the Confederate plan before it had even started.

In short, the engagement which has gone down in history as Pickett's Charge was a total and abject failure. That evening, a remorseful Robert E. Lee told his men that it was all his fault before deciding to withdraw from the field the next day. Pickett's Charge has since gone down into history as the "High Water Mark of the Confederacy," with the engagement taking on near-mythical proportions some 160+ years later.


The field of Pickett's Charge today.
Posted by windhamtiger
Gonzales
Member since Sep 2022
358 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 8:07 am to
Absolutely fantastic analysis and enjoy your post so much on the civil war. Went to visit Gettysburg many years ago in and just was unbelievable. Looking at the emmitsburg road towards the clump of trees that Lee was directing Pickett and his men to head towards this was definitely a time In my opinion, that general Robert e. Lee should have listened to general James Longstreet. Curious as to what the United States would look like today if that had happened. Thanks for posting!
This post was edited on 7/3/25 at 8:09 am
Posted by FreddieMac
Baton Rouge
Member since Jun 2010
24832 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 8:09 am to
Pickett's charge is one of the largest blunders in a long series of blunders by Lee. I know he was a well respected General, but he made some stupid decisions.
Posted by KiwiHead
Auckland, NZ
Member since Jul 2014
35400 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 8:21 am to
Gettysburg is the one time Custer did anything worthwhile. A lot of Civil War buffs like to speak glowingly of JEB Stuart, but overall, I see him as more of a problem for Lee. Stuart has a reputation that is rebutted by actual results especially at Gettysburg. Forrest was far and away a better commander.

Lee had to know that he was facing a potential bloodbath on the Third Day of Gettysburg. He's attacking across an open plain with about a mile's distance in front of Pickett up hill....for starters. Hancock has his artillery right where Pickett was going.
Posted by geauxbrown
Louisiana
Member since Oct 2006
24736 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 8:34 am to
Photos don’t do it justice. When you walk out of the trees and look across the vastness of that field. It’s amazing any of them made it.
Posted by RollTide1987
Augusta, GA
Member since Nov 2009
69159 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 8:47 am to
quote:

Gettysburg is the one time Custer did anything worthwhile.


You might want to read up on his exploits during the Valley Campaign of 1864 and the Appomattox Campaign.
Posted by RollTide1987
Augusta, GA
Member since Nov 2009
69159 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 9:22 am to
quote:

When you walk out of the trees and look across the vastness of that field. It’s amazing any of them made it.


Well, as Confederate General Ambrose "Rans" Wright told Pickett before the attack started: "It's not hard to get up there, the trick is staying there." His men had assailed Gibbon's brigades atop Cemetery Ridge the day before but had to withdraw due to a lack of support.
Posted by soccerfüt
Location: A Series of Tubes
Member since May 2013
72561 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 9:25 am to
quote:

Pickett's charge is one of the largest blunders in a long series of blunders by Lee.
A long time ago I heard it referred to a the simultaneous high and low water marks of the Confederate Army’s war effort.

That always stuck with me.
Posted by DByrd2
Fredericksburg, VA
Member since Jun 2008
9873 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 10:50 am to
quote:

Well, as Confederate General Ambrose "Rans" Wright told Pickett before the attack started: "It's not hard to get up there, the trick is staying there." His men had assailed Gibbon's brigades atop Cemetery Ridge the day before but had to withdraw due to a lack of support.


This was the oversight by Lee. He hadn't considered that this geographical high ground would be equally valued by the Union, ESPECIALLY after they had nearly lost it to the Confederates the day prior. Anyone could probably at least have the thought that the Union would reinforce that area if they had trouble with it just hours before. A break in the center of their line would have been disastrous.

Had Lee simply considered what he would do were he in his enemies' shoes rather than double down and throw everything at a perceived weakness 18-24 hours after the fact, we likely are in a MUCH different America today.

Lee was absolutely a brilliant General, but he was a tad headstrong at times and had a tendency to overlook small details. This got him into trouble in other battles as well.

This post was edited on 7/3/25 at 11:01 am
Posted by Drank
Member since Jun 1864
Member since Dec 2012
12015 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 10:55 am to
quote:

Photos don’t do it justice. When you walk out of the trees and look across the vastness of that field. It’s amazing any of them made it.


While the park has been doing a phenomenal job restoring it to its wartime appearance, the field was vastly altered after the war. The Pickett/Pettigrew/Trimble charge field was used as 'Camp Colt' tank training camp during WW1. The commander? One Dwight David Eisenhower.
There was even a swimming pool in the middle of that field. Also a trolley train system (part of the path can still be scene not to far from The Wheatfield) winding around the battlefield, souvenir shops, amusement park rides etc. Now, thankfully, most of the circus is in town away from the hallowed fields. I can't recommend visiting enough. It's an absolutely powerful and amazing place.
Posted by SpotCheckBilly
Member since May 2020
8162 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 10:58 am to
quote:

Photos don’t do it justice. When you walk out of the trees and look across the vastness of that field. It’s amazing any of them made it.


Go there, walk out from the copt of trees for 50 yards or more towards the Lee statue that was where they started from. Then turn around and walk back. It's not hard to imagine the hell those men were walking into. It is hard to do without a lump in your throat.
Posted by doubleb
Baton Rouge
Member since Aug 2006
41610 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 11:15 am to
quote:

A break in the center of their line would have been disastrous.


Even if the initial charge would have been successful, the short interior lines of the Union defenses allowed them to move reinforcements to weakened spots very easily.

The Union had the position, and numbers on their side. I think a frontal attack against the center was futile. Stuart couldn’t help them. It was a bad plan hatched by a desperate man.
Posted by DByrd2
Fredericksburg, VA
Member since Jun 2008
9873 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 11:33 am to
quote:

Even if the initial charge would have been successful, the short interior lines of the Union defenses allowed them to move reinforcements to weakened spots very easily.


That's what happened. Part of his plan was to have his cavalry sweep in behind and prevent reinforcements.. That didn't take into account that reinforcements had already been sent to the hilltop, and thus rendered that strategy useless.

I don't think he was desperate at that point in the battle. I think he had a good plan if the conditions didn't change in that 18-24 hour window between that initial and nearly successful charge and Pickett's Charge itself, to be honest.

His problem was the oversight of the simple fact that "everything changes". Epic-level blunder to not consider the fact that the Union would reinforce a strategic high ground that they had nearly lost the day before.
Posted by RanchoLaPuerto
Jena
Member since Aug 2023
1734 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 11:36 am to
It will always be Longstreet’s Assault to me.
Posted by doubleb
Baton Rouge
Member since Aug 2006
41610 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 12:02 pm to
quote:

I don't think he was desperate at that point in the battle


By desperate, I mean he was forced to make something happen after two days of heavy fighting had cost him dearly.

He had to get a big win. Another loss on foreign soil like Antietam would put the rebellion in a precarious situation. He knew that would be seen as a major failure.
Posted by BFIV
Virginia
Member since Apr 2012
8668 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 12:14 pm to
quote:

Pickett's charge is one of the largest blunders in a long series of blunders by Lee.


Agree. I have never been able to understand why Lee ordered or even envisioned this attack after the lessons learned at Malvern Hill and Fredericksburg.
Posted by LSURussian
Member since Feb 2005
133396 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 12:55 pm to
quote:

Today is the 162nd anniversary of Pickett's Charge...


Posted by RollTide1987
Augusta, GA
Member since Nov 2009
69159 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 1:13 pm to
quote:

I have never been able to understand why Lee ordered or even envisioned this attack after the lessons learned at Malvern Hill and Fredericksburg.


Because by the time you get to Gettysburg, Lee believes that his army is unbeatable in the field. He had very little regard for the fighting prowess of the Army of the Potomac and assumed the setbacks his army took in assailing the flanks of the Army of the Potomac the day before had more to do with poor coordination than they did with the Union army.

He also had a very poor understanding of the tactical situation during the evening of July 2. He failed once again to meet with any of his corps commanders and told Longstreet by courier to resume his attacks from the second on the morning of the third. Lee was oblivious to the fact that two of his three divisions took heavy losses and were in no condition to continue the attack. When Lee finally saw just what Longstreet was working with and what he was facing, he decided to change tactics and focus all of their efforts on Cemetery Ridge.

What's more: when he picked the divisions of Heth and Pender to take part in Pickett's Charge later in the day, he failed to grasp just how severely those two units had suffered on the battle's first day. Five of the eight brigades that participated in their part of the assault had taken heavy losses fighting the Union's First Corps on the first day of fighting. They were in absolutely no condition to make the charge Lee was asking of them.
Posted by Ace Midnight
Between sanity and madness
Member since Dec 2006
94593 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 1:34 pm to
Posted by PJinAtl
Atlanta
Member since Nov 2007
13898 posts
Posted on 7/3/25 at 1:53 pm to
quote:

Fredericksburg

If I remember correctly, after the assault is turned back, the Federal troops stand and cheer, "Fredericksburg! Fredericksburg!"

To me one of the more moving markers on the field is the one showing where General Lewis "Lo" Armistead fell. He reaches the wall and places his hand on it, possibly even begins to step over it when he is cut down by three shots. He is transported to a Federal field hospital where he does on 5 July.

He is buried in the Old St. Paul's Cemetery in Baltimore, next to his uncle Lieutenant Colonel George Armistead, commander of the garrison of Fort McHenry during the War of 1812.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram