Started By
Message

ETA Spinoff - Traffic Laws - TODAY, exist primarily as an end around the 4th Amendment

Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:11 pm
Posted by Grumpy Nemesis
Member since Feb 2025
2033 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:11 pm
Okay because apparently it wasn't clear. The point of this thread isn't that traffic laws in and of themselves are crooked. It's the fact that their existence allows the government through the police to circumvent the Fourth Amendment or otherwise they couldn't. And this problem is rampant across the United States

Whatever their original reason. Whatever the average voter THINKS traffic laws are for.

In practice, they've become little more than a constitutional end around allowing police to shake down and search people they otherwise couldn't touch.................confiscate property they otherwise couldn't have...........and create a default tax revenue stream they otherwise couldn't have passed.

Discuss
This post was edited on 6/11/25 at 7:40 pm
Posted by Nosevens
Member since Apr 2019
16977 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:21 pm to
Exactly right ! No way we should be required to stop at a red light to allow flow from another direction under penalties for not doing so. It would be much better not having to stop just to hope that your son or daughter makes it across the intersection at say 80-90 mph while another vehicle tries not to T-bone them doing 80-90 mph themselves
Posted by Grumpy Nemesis
Member since Feb 2025
2033 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:22 pm to
quote:


Nosevens
Exactly right ! No way we should be required to stop at a red light to allow flow from another direction under penalties for not doing so

Sigh. Your lack of comprehension is noted.

Posted by Purple Spoon
Hoth
Member since Feb 2005
20121 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:23 pm to
quote:

Discuss


No.
Posted by SallysHuman
Lady Palmetto Bug
Member since Jan 2025
13345 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:28 pm to
We can have 'profiling' or traffic laws used for otherwise impossible shakedowns.

I'd prefer profiling.

All in all, it sucks... but a large segment of society can't follow the rules the rest of us have no problem following.
Posted by SallysHuman
Lady Palmetto Bug
Member since Jan 2025
13345 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:30 pm to
quote:

Sigh. Your lack of comprehension is noted.


That's not fair, Grumpy... you didn't detail which traffic laws were nefarious vs ones that are actually useful and beneficial to society. Give us something meaty to discuss.
Posted by FATBOY TIGER
Valhalla
Member since Jan 2016
12825 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:32 pm to
Why can I turn right at a red light when no one is coming but, not left.
Posted by Nosevens
Member since Apr 2019
16977 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:32 pm to
My lack of comprehension? You are trying to outdo 4cubbies on insane nonsensical thoughts and demand people comprehend your idea. Next you’ll be demanding others to call you by your preferred name of Queen of Sheba
Posted by SallysHuman
Lady Palmetto Bug
Member since Jan 2025
13345 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:33 pm to
Right turns involve one lane... left is crossing lanes. That's all I got.
Posted by RazorBroncs
Possesses the largest
Member since Sep 2013
15748 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:37 pm to

I agree that most tickets are just a way for the local LEO to collect money, especially in some of these smaller towns that use them not to protect and keep people safe - but to rack up an easy quota.

We absolutely *need* traffic laws enforced, and oftentimes they aren't enforced nearly enough. Its just that most local PD aren't enforcing the RIGHT traffic laws and are targeting the easiest to churn out tickets, and seem to have an obsession with making themselves easier and easier to hide in order to catch the soccer moms doing 6 over.

This erodes public trust in the police and makes it feel like they're just there to "trick" and catch people, instead of their intended purpose which is safety. If the intended purpose was simply making their presence known around every corner so everyone would obey traffic laws in fear of the penalty, they'd want to be as bright and obvious as possible. Not this route they're taking where they have these invisible decals and non-typical vehicles.

I could go on and on about this, and I am in law enforcement myself. It almost brings me to a rage when considering what these local police have done to ruin the reputation and erode public trust of law enforcement.

I'm not a patrol officer, or I would singlehandedly focus on non-blinker users, left lane cruisers, and paper/no tag vehicles - over people going slightly over the speed limit.
Posted by TutHillTiger
Mississippi Alabama
Member since Sep 2010
49830 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:38 pm to
They are revenue model for too many bullshite like towns and counties
Posted by Brosef Stalin
Member since Dec 2011
41514 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:41 pm to
Mostly true, especially in small towns. Police will always make up some excuse to search your car, whether legit or not.
Posted by Lynxrufus2012
Central Kentucky
Member since Mar 2020
18184 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:42 pm to
Well Grumpy, that is kind of Dopey. We have too much traffic at too high speed not to have traffic laws. Running lights, stop signs is a good way to get people killed. Our roads are designed with vertical and horizontal curves for certain velocities and exceeding those can be fatal for someone.

No, the primary purpose is safety taking into account stopping distances, perception and reaction time and sight distances. Now maybe some officers abuse the traffic stop but the design guidelines and signing are for safety, not for searches.

Are FAA flight rules for circumventing the fourth? Boating rules? Railroad crossings? Rules in horse racing? Limits on Indy cars?

No, same thing. Safety.
Posted by TrueTiger
Chicken's most valuable
Member since Sep 2004
79735 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:45 pm to
quote:

No way we should be required to stop at a red light to allow flow from another direction under penalties for not doing so.


There can be a middle ground where regulatory infractions can be enforced but not used as an elevation point to greater crimes.
Posted by FATBOY TIGER
Valhalla
Member since Jan 2016
12825 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:46 pm to
I can turn left at a stop sign after I stop.
Posted by SallysHuman
Lady Palmetto Bug
Member since Jan 2025
13345 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 6:54 pm to
quote:

I can turn left at a stop sign after I stop.


True... hmm... I think you might have a point!

Although there are places and states you can't turn right on red either.

THIS would have been a good example for Grumpy to offer up for debate!
Posted by Spaniard
Pine Belt
Member since Apr 2011
1115 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 7:00 pm to
Are inspection stickers considered a traffic violation ?
Posted by ChineseBandit58
Pearland, TX
Member since Aug 2005
47823 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 7:01 pm to
weak attempt at something = so weak I don't even get your point.

The OP has a point - too many small communities do use any sort of 'infraction' to stop and then 'notice' something suspicious, and then search.

Not often - but way too often.

I think there should be some sort of 'danger factor' involved with any stop exclusively for traffic "violations." Of course there should be some upper limits that are not merely a traffic violation but a 'public endangerment' type charge.

There is zero reason why rigid enforcement of the "letter of the law" should always be given a ticket - HOWEVER - I would not object to 'borderline' situations getting a warning.
Posted by Keltic Tiger
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2006
21449 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 7:04 pm to
So, admit it, you are a Sovereign Citizen?? The 4th Amendment is their bible. And still lose in court every time.
Posted by Whiskey Delta Actual
DIXIELAND
Member since May 2025
35 posts
Posted on 6/11/25 at 7:29 pm to
quote:

confiscate property they otherwise couldn't have...........and create a default tax revenue stream they otherwise couldn't have passed.


All of this because they ran a stop sign? crossed the fog line? failed to signal?

Maybe it was the cocaine, bulk currency and/or smuggled bodies they recovered that led to your scree,
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 3Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram