Started By
Message

Oak trees close your house

Posted on 8/3/24 at 8:19 am
Posted by SouthernInsanity
Shadows of Death Valley
Member since Nov 2012
25660 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 8:19 am
So we had two different varieties of oak trees growing thru the middle of some azalea on the back side of our house, with one being about 8ft and the other maybe 5ft tall. I like oaks but not a tree expert and figured why not ask this place.... if there's a preferred oak variety that you allow to grow if it was close to your house.
Posted by bapple
Capital City
Member since Oct 2010
12194 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 8:35 am to
Anything but a water oak. They grow for 30 years then die for 30 years from the inside out. Slowly get hollow and brittle until the whole thing falls. And since they grow very tall and narrow they have a lot of velocity when they hit the ground. Just all around a bad tree to have to deal with later.

EDIT: Added photos of the one I cut down last year.





I have 2 live oaks in the front yard that I have zero concern with though. They are quite robust and give us good shade.
This post was edited on 8/3/24 at 8:38 am
Posted by LSUA 75
Colfax,La.
Member since Jan 2019
4654 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 9:19 am to
“Photos of the one I cut down last year”

I hate to think about how much that cost.
Posted by OceanMan
Member since Mar 2010
22762 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 9:22 am to
Water oaks are trash trees do not let them grow near your house. I wouldn’t let any tree grow that can fall on my house, I’ve learned the hard way. They can all fall.

We had a black oak that had hollowed out just like the water oaks do.
Posted by jmarto1
Houma, LA/ Las Vegas, NV
Member since Mar 2008
37999 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 9:38 am to
I bet getting that cut out a dent in the gun budget
Posted by El Segundo Guy
1-866-DHS-2-ICE
Member since Aug 2014
11406 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 10:02 am to
I love oaks. My farm has tons of white oaks, red oaks and pecans.

Just the other day I cut down 3 white oaks that were close to the house. A little too close for comfort. And they wouldn't allow grass to grow un that area due to the shade.

I cut them myself. If you cut down 2-4 mature trees per year like I do, go to treestuff dot com and order a good rope with an eye splice for a carabiner. Also get one of those weighted bean bag throwing things and that twine for them.

I throw the bean bag over a limb high up in the tree, connect it to the thick rope through the carabiner and pull taut. Hook that to the FEL on the tractor for tension as you're making the back cut and to help with the correct direction of fall.

I can take down any fricked up tree and make it fall where I want to.
Posted by bapple
Capital City
Member since Oct 2010
12194 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 11:41 am to
quote:

I hate to think about how much that cost.


Got some quotes and $5k came out to be the cheapest. Definitely hurt the wallet but I’m at peace knowing we’re not at risk anymore - that thing is about 5 feet from the master bed and bath.

quote:

I bet getting that cut out a dent in the gun budget


Made a purchase before I cut it down - all part of the strategy.
Posted by sosaysmorvant
River Parishes, LA
Member since Feb 2008
1466 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 12:23 pm to
How close to your house? Oak trees get HUGE.
Posted by SouthernInsanity
Shadows of Death Valley
Member since Nov 2012
25660 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 1:25 pm to
These were about 6-7' from the house and were only smaller in diameter than baseball.
Posted by turkish
Member since Aug 2016
2269 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 2:15 pm to
That’s way too close for any tree.
Posted by sosaysmorvant
River Parishes, LA
Member since Feb 2008
1466 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 2:17 pm to
Way to close to your home. Cut them.
Posted by jmarto1
Houma, LA/ Las Vegas, NV
Member since Mar 2008
37999 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 3:47 pm to
The state should do grants with cutting down trees. It is so expensive to do and would mitigate a lot of damage
Posted by Allthatfades
Mississippi
Member since Aug 2014
8724 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 4:28 pm to
I have oak trees and all I do is pick up damn limbs and sticks
Posted by Zach
Gizmonic Institute
Member since May 2005
116746 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 5:01 pm to
Thirty years ago I bought a lot in a heavily forested area and built a house. I have a giant oak 15 feet from the front of the house. I called LSU ag extension and they sent an arborist out to look at it. He said the tree is about 200 years old and is dying.
Me: "So, I should cut it down."
Him: "No. A tree that old takes a very long time to die and it has stopped growing. You'll die first.
It's still there. But if it were a younger tree still growing then that would have been way too close to the house.
Posted by Bayou
Boudin, LA
Member since Feb 2005
41596 posts
Posted on 8/3/24 at 8:59 pm to
I'm a little scared.
We have two giant oaks in the front yard. Both are tall (50') and relatively narrow although the red oak is bushier at the top. The red oak is slightly closer to the house 25'-30' away. The other is a pin oak.
Posted by Sidicous
NELA
Member since Aug 2015
19296 posts
Posted on 8/4/24 at 5:31 am to
I don’t like oaks near the house. The old family place was originally a wood frame along the wooded fence line and more than once lightning struck the oaks and jumped to the phone line or the tv antenna wire. More than once setting the curtains on fire. If the house had been empty any of those times it would have burned down.

Posted by Zach
Gizmonic Institute
Member since May 2005
116746 posts
Posted on 8/4/24 at 9:27 am to
quote:

I'm a little scared. We have two giant oaks in the front yard. Both are tall (50') and relatively narrow although the red oak is bushier at the top. The red oak is slightly closer to the house 25'-30' away. The other is a pin oak.


Well, one thing I learned from the ag extension guy. They refused to take money for a visit and advice. You might call yours and see.
Posted by Canon951
Member since May 2020
387 posts
Posted on 8/4/24 at 9:34 am to
Depends on how close to the house you are talking about. I just had 3 cut down last summer (a red oak and 2 water oaks) and an handful of other smaller trees. After 20 years of cleaning out ungodly amounts of leaves from my gutters, raking said leaves up every spring, squirrels getting in my attic due to limbs near the roof, tree roots growing under the foundation, etc. I decided it was time to cut them down. I won't have any trees near my house ever again.
Posted by gumbo2176
Member since May 2018
19416 posts
Posted on 8/4/24 at 9:41 am to
I take it you've never seen tree cutters using bottle jacks to fell trees in the direction they want with almost clear certainty. Lots of u-tube videos showing how it's done and it's very simple.

Cut your notch in the trunk in the direction you want the tree to fall, go on the opposite side and cut out a pocket big enough to place the bottle jack with a thick metal plate between the plunger and the wood and pump it up snug. Then make a couple plunge cuts on the backside of the trunk to remove the meat holding it together and a few pumps on the bottle jack gets the tree moving in the right direction.
Posted by El Segundo Guy
1-866-DHS-2-ICE
Member since Aug 2014
11406 posts
Posted on 8/4/24 at 10:33 am to
I have seen it. I have never needed it.

My dad had a degree in Forestry and worked for the Forest Service, so I've seen all sorts of crazy tree felling techniques, and that's a good one. For me, the rope works great. If I really need some oomph, I borrow my buddies track hoe and push with the bucket while making the cut.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram