Favorite team:New Orleans Saints 
Location:
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:744
Registered on:5/22/2020
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tH5gk4M933k

This is the best, most thorough documentary I've ever watched on WWI. I think it was originally a french production called Apocalypse. It's 5 parts but the link I attached has all 5 parts in one long video. It's really good if you want to take your time to watch.
quote:

You missed the point. Water baptism replaced circumcision as a rite of entrance into the faith.
:dope:
quote:

You're reading the Bible wrong.

From the early Church, we have always believed that Baptism in the Name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit, Saves you. Right then and there, if you die right after Baptism, you are Saved.

So, somebody told you the wrong thing here. I don't know where you get this idea that Baptism doesn't do anything for anybody with regard to Salvation.

The Church has never believed what you believe, because what you believe is wrong.


I'm not gonna spend my Sunday debating with you. You have shown repeatedly in thread after thread to not have a grasp on scripture. If your priest tells you to do something then that's all you need to hear. Immersing someone in water does not save them.
quote:

Canon and Memphis have displayed that repeatedly as they are unwilling to grant that the gospel can be anything other then salvation from this earthly life into another life.


Correct, because scripture tells us what the gospel is. This statement right here shows that you really don't know what you are talking about. I take you for someone that is highly educated based on your writing style but I just don't think you get it. You are too smart for your own good as the saying goes.

You have repeatedly made assumptions about what I believe or don't believe in regard to living our lives in the here and now. Somehow you are equating the idea of believing the gospel for salvation after we die with washing our hands of doing anything good while we are still here because we are getting in. No one has even tried to argue a case for that so I'm unclear where you are getting it from. You have some stereotypes in your mind, probably based on your past experiences about "protestants", that are simply not true.

You said you wanted to wrap this up yet you continue to try to argue your point. You have yet to provide any scriptures to back up your claim but continue to post articles and links to people that share your viewpoint. My position from the outset and it has not changed is that recognizing we are sinners separated from God and thus believing in the death, burial and resurrection of Jesus (i.e. the gospel in 1 Cor. 15) is what saves us from eternal separation from God when we die. As a result of believing this simple gospel a person is born again from above and given the holy spirit who teaches them how to live. We are then called to do good works and love our neighbors, etc., but it is because we have believed the gospel.

Titus 3
8 This is a faithful saying, and these things I want you to affirm constantly, that those who have believed in God should be careful to maintain good works. These things are good and profitable to men.


When you and others like you try to lump the gospel into something "bigger" than it is, you confuse people. People begin to seek the experience or begin to rely on their deeds or their charity or participation to qualify them for salvation. People who do this without out ever trusting in Jesus alone for salvation will not be saved. For this reason I have been so adamant that we make it clear what the gospel actually is and what it isn't.

You are also hung up on bringing heaven or the kingdom to earth, as if somehow you living this "gospel life" or whatever, is gonna help clean up the world and make it suitable for the Lord to return. The world is only gonna get worse friend. When the Lord returns it will be to restore this corrupt world back to the way it was in the beginning.

You will probably come back and link a bunch of articles that someone wrote that no one is going to read or listen to. But I think you have shown that you really don't understand the gospel. You are seeking something that you will never find until you finally come to the end of yourself and rest in Jesus and him alone for your eternity. Only then can you begin to have the joy that you are seeking.

quote:

I don’t wish to carry on.
I stand by everything I’ve said.
I know that it makes sense to a lot of people in the world.
I wish you were one of them, but Mark Noll was really into something with that book he wrote.

The gospel is bigger than your narrow version of it.
Your version of it is 200 years old (at best).
That’s undeniable.


No it's not undeniable. You don't want to have to refute scriptures so you'd prefer to refer to books written by whoever and then call it quits? Fair enough. I have stuff to do anyway. I have wasted so much time on this thread. lol

The gospel is 2000 years old as I've presented it. Jesus gave it himself and Paul, John, Peter, etc. confirmed it. To say it is only 200 years old or less is being disingenuous. Instead of using scriptures you have repeatedly referred to books and writings of anyone and everyone except the bible. I said it earlier and I'll say it again, I think you are searching and hope that you will compare everything you are reading against what scripture actually says.

I am glad the mods let this thread continue on without anchoring and shutting it down. Hopefully they will allow future religious discussions if they remain civil.


:cheers:
I've been through this with him since yesterday. Prepare thyself to be more confused about it than you are now.
I have presented the gospel the same way Paul does and I have done it repeatedly for the last 2 days yet you claim that the "modern" gospel is watered down or weak. So since I used that verse from Paul written in the 1st century are you saying Paul's gospel is weak or how do you interpret what he is saying if not the way I've presented it?
quote:

A result of Sola Scriptura is individual interpretation, which has led to an American evangelicalism that gets weaker by the decade. That has been well documented in the posts that I’ve written against over the last 2 days.


Where is the weakness in this? How do you interpret this? You haven't given one single scripture in this entire thread that I can recall. You continue to espouse writers of books and church fathers... What is wrong with this that Paul wrote 2000 years ago?

1 Now I make known to you, brothers and sisters, the gospel which I preached to you, which you also received, in which you also stand, 2 by which you also are saved, if you hold firmly to the word which I preached to you, unless you believed in vain.

3 For I handed down to you as of first importance what I also received, that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, 4 and that He was buried, and that He was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures
quote:

But you're not talking to an unbeliever and I've been clear that the gospel is more than the afterlife, so maybe apply salvation to how it can bring God's kingdom down.


There are unbelievers on this board reading all of this.

So how can salvation and your understanding of the gospel speed up God setting up his kingdom on earth? I have my own point of view but interested in you giving a clear explanation. So far you’ve talked about hot dogs and basketball and picking up litter.
There has to be a clear distinction between believing the gospel and then as result how we should live because we believe. When you blur the lines people believe the works and church participation are making them right with God. This is why I’m so adamant that there has to be a clear distinction.

I also enjoyed the Harry Potter series…gasp lol.
no argument from me. But he is saying that the gospel is more than something to be believed. That it is the here and now in how we live. I contend that how we live is because we believe the gospel. It is not lumped in with it. This is where non believers get confused about how to be right with God when it's presented this way.
quote:

and it can and should guide our living.


I don't think anyone disagrees with believing the gospel should guide our living. But "our living" is not the gospel. The gospel is something to be believed.
quote:

You take a clear verse to the neglect of the larger narrative and you run with it.


quote:

Yours is the minority view.


:lol:

I think I'm gonna roll with what Paul says the gospel is instead of Anglican Bishop Nicholas Thomas Wright.
Maybe you don't understand what the word gospel actually means. It's the good news that Jesus died to save sinners and those who believe in him for everlasting life will be saved. It's not all of this other stuff that you are talking about. What you are describing comes after believing the gospel. But when we lump it all in together then people get confused about what actually saves them. They begin to think the experience or their good deeds are what saves them and these are the people that Jesus will say he never knew. I'm not saying this is you, but we have to separate the gospel for what it actually is. You don't have to agree with me but that is my position.
CS I think you and I are on the same page but the only thing where I differ is in the fact that Jesus remains faithful to us even when we aren't faithful to him. I don't believe God will allow one of his children to fall away to the point of being lost again. I believe that once someone enters into a saving relationship with the Lord they pass from death to life and God now deals with them as children.

John 5:24
Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that heareth my word, and believeth on him that sent me, hath everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation; but is passed from death unto life.

Jesus is the good shepard and says that of all the father give him he shall lose none.

I believe there are people who say some words and think they are saved and they aren't. I believe there are true born again people that wander off into all sorts of things they shouldn't. But the Lord knows who are his and will leave the 99 to go and retrieve the one that has wandered off.

If someone dies while still being "wandered off", that is not for me to judge. God is their judge and I know my weaknesses and where I fail so I can't judge anyone else. I just leave that up to him.

And none of this is wink or a thumbs up to sin. Sin is wicked and wrong and the reason we are in this mess in the first place. So no one needs to think that I think sin is no big deal.


:cheers:
quote:

I’ve merely been attempting to steer you toward considering that the gospel is much bigger than “me and my salvation”…a fact that is biblically and historically undeniable.


The gospel is in fact about me and my salvation. It's not bigger than that. The gospel is simple so even children can understand it. Yet I'm a middle aged man and I'm having trouble understanding what you are conveying. What I think is that you are trying to lump the christian life or experience in with the gospel. They are not the same thing.

From reading your posts not only in this thread but other religious threads it seems that you are searching. For whatever reason you have had bad experiences in Protestant churches (me too), and somehow this has left you questioning what you were taught all of these years. If that is not the case then I stand corrected. But what you are describing is not the gospel. And the answer is not necessarily in another denomination. The answer is in the inspired scriptures, not books written by men. I notice you always refer to books written by so and so but I haven't seen you post any scriptures to back up what you are saying. Again if I've overlooked anything than please correct me.

Edit:
quote:

When taken as a whole, I’m attempting to make Christianity more all encompassing for all of this life and the next—all in line with what the church has always believed.


I agree with this statement you made a few posts up. CHRISTIANITY is more than just believing the gospel. It is a life experience where we live out our faith. Where we fall sometimes and we get back up again. But the christian life is not the gospel. It follows believing the gospel. So yes I am pigeon-holing the gospel down to what I believe it is as described in 1 Cor. 15. This is how we are saved. The christian life follows this.

Churches are full of people living the "christian" life but they have never believed the gospel. They are not saved because they believe that their "christian" life or experience is what makes them right with God.
quote:

I’ve addressed this twice. Salvation ordinarily occurs within the church.
There are occurrences were salvation may happen outside of the church, but they are
1. Unordinary. Not regular.
2. Should be followed by baptism and participation in Christ’s church.


Explain #1 in a more detail if you are inclined to do so. People get saved all of the time by simply believing the gospel. I got saved 31 years ago in my car driving down the road and praying out loud to Jesus when he revealed my fallen state to me and revealed himself to me as who he really was. Are you saying that was out of the ordinary?

I understand #2 to mean you believe that baptism and church participation should follow believing the gospel. Correct me if I'm misinterpreting that. Will you say that if someone believes the gospel but is never baptized and for whatever reason they don't participate in organized religion that they aren't saved?

Also I am enjoying this thread and I'm glad it's been allowed to continue. I don't have any ill will toward anyone here and so none of my posts have been intended to malign anyone in any way. Just wanted to put that out there. Also, it's Saturday and I've got much to do today so will have to check back after while.
Are you saying that someone can't be saved outside of the church? Because that is what is sounds like you are saying. My statement meant nothing to do with the church not being important. But being involved in a church or taking sacraments or insert whatever else you want here can't save someone. One is saved when they acknowledge they are a sinner and are persuaded to believe the gospel and they place their faith in the only one who can save them. No church is needed for that.

Again, I have explained this already but I'll do it again. My statement about the gospel having nothing to do with how we live is that we are not saved by our behavior (i.e. how we live). We are saved by what we believe. If you believe the gospel and are born again (this is required) then your behavior will align with what you believe. The gospel is believing in Christ, not behaving in Christ. I'm not sure why you can't wrap your head around this.

If you believe works are required to get or stay saved then just come on out and say that.
Bengal...Jesus died and rose again so that we could believe and be reconciled to God. We no longer have to fear death because of what he has done for us. Jesus didn't die to give us a great life here. As a matter of fact he told us that in this life we would have tribulation but be of good cheer because he had overcome the world. I'm not sure what you are seeking in this life but the gospel is not more than what I just said above. It's God's plan to redeem mankind from death and separation from him because of the curse of sin.

The fullness of life or the joy of your salvation or whatever you call it are results of believing the gospel while walking in the spirit and maybe that is what you are attempting to convey. However, the gospel in it's simplest form is the redemption of mankind through the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ.

:cheers:
quote:

When you say "Your denomination can’t save you. Only Jesus can save you" ...you're missing A LOT and downplaying the role of the church in salvation.


Go on.... Tell me how the catholic or baptist church or (insert denom) can save me. Apparently it offends some here to say that the catholic church can't save anyone. To believe that is to believe a lie. Salvation is between the sinner and his savior.

You've called me gnostic and antinomian because I believe the gospel as presented in the scriptures which is Jesus Christ crucified and risen plus nothing else. I don't know what else I can say about that.